Well, Occam's razor is very subjective, dependent on what each person finds the simplest explanation to be.
Some people deny experiential consciousness exists at all (how they deny this, I'm not sure, because to me it is the one thing I am most certain exists), so to them the p-zombie argument would be the simplest.
No, indeed. I came up with the "experiential" qualifier, because the term "consciousness" is highly overloaded indeed, and I do not know the generally accepted phrase.