News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Science of Interstellar [video] by grecy on Sunday November 09, 2014 @11:41AM (#8580201)
> E.g. how they need massive amounts of fuel to get off from earth, but just use their tiny craft to launch twice into orbit from the two planets they visit

The explanation for this is so obvious I'm surprised more people don't see it.

When they left earth, they used external fuel tanks so they didn't burn the fuel in the two craft. That way, when they left Earth orbit the tanks of the two tiny craft were still full, to be used later in the mission.

If they didn't use the external tanks, they could have still left earth (as they left other planets with the little craft), but they would have been heading off without full fuel tanks, which were obviously precious as running low was a mission concern.

Re:The Science of Interstellar [video] by Perseids on Sunday November 09, 2014 @02:17PM (#8580570)
You can use that argument, but then you get other inconsistencies. For example, why didn't they use the same super[1] fuel of the shuttles to also get them into earth orbit and use the extra capacity to add fuel for even more launches into orbit? Or if we go further down the plot, think about the gigantic gravity well necessary to create a time dilation of 1hour/7years ~= 10^-5. Instead of going down to this one planet they should easily have been able to visit each of the other 11 planets.

[1] The improvements above current technologies would have to be enormous: http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/station/expeditions/expedi...

Re:The Science of Interstellar [video] by Sharlin on Sunday November 09, 2014 @04:18PM (#8580927)
You can't escape the tyranny of the rocket equation. If you need external fuel tanks to launch from the Earth, then you need more external fuel tanks to escape the other planet as well, which in turn requires you to use even more fuel to get to the Earth orbit in the first place...
Re:The Science of Interstellar [video] by grecy on Sunday November 09, 2014 @05:31PM (#8581129)
> If you need external fuel tanks to launch from the Earth, then you need more external fuel tanks to escape the other planet as well

I'm not sure you understood what I wrote.

They didn't need external fuel tanks to launch from the Earth. They just chose to use them so they'd have more fuel later on. As demonstrated latter, the little craft are perfectly capable of achieving orbit without external tanks.