News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by vidarh on Friday November 07, 2014 @10:25AM (#8572882)
> Making drugs illegal might be bad policy, but I don't think it rises to the level of immorality.

I do. Because we know that it leads to increased detrimental effects of abuse amongst those that abuse drugs, as well as vast amounts of violent crime to support the drug industry.

Personally, I consider legislators that continue to support drug laws no better than mass murderers.

> The fact is that drugs have externalized effects

There is however little to no evidence that outlawing drug use has had a positive effect on these, and a lot of evidence that outlawing drug use is directly causing some of these, such as pushing drug addicts into other crime.

Before these effects were understood I would have agreed that drug laws were not yet immoral. But these effects are known. There's no excuse.

> that doesn't make the laws immoral because there is no denying that drug use does in fact cause societal harms.

Since when it is a requirement that a law has not positive effect for it to be immoral?

> Drug laws are in that sense no different than gun control laws or liquor laws.

What massive social harm does gun control laws or liquor laws cause? How many people are left dead because of gun control laws or liquor laws?

> it's hard to deny that they address real societal harms.

Yes, they are causing a substantial proportion of them.

Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by Nursie on Friday November 07, 2014 @06:09PM (#8575153)
I'm not sure why you're getting voted down for this.

The drug laws kill, they kill more people that take drugs than they help. They also cause collateral damage all over the place, fund organised crime on a massive scale and contribute to the undermining of stable governments across the world.

There is no doubt at all that prohibition is horrifically immoral.

Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by vidarh on Saturday November 08, 2014 @11:23PM (#8579092)
I was probably getting downvoted because I was rather undiplomatic about how I expressed it. E.g. drawing the parallel between voting for keeping drugs illegal and mass murder means I also implicitly accused anyone who belives drugs should remain illegal of sympathising with mass murder. It's harder to ignore that, than if someone "just" claims that drug prohibition kills without connecting the dots.

But I stand by that.

Still, it stands at 0 at this point, which is quite moderate given how harsh I was.

Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by rayiner on Friday November 07, 2014 @10:09PM (#8575862)
Source for the relative amount of cost versus benefit? What is the avoided cost of kids not feeling social pressure to engage in legal drug use (as they do with legal alcohol abuse)?
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by Nursie on Saturday November 08, 2014 @09:51AM (#8576997)
There is significant evidence that legalisation doesn't really affect the levels of use, particularly with weed. So that argument doesn't hold a lot of water.