News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by rayiner on Friday November 07, 2014 @10:11AM (#8572817)
There are "immoral laws" and there are "immoral laws." Mandatory female genital mutilation is an "immoral law." Making drugs illegal might be bad policy, but I don't think it rises to the level of immorality.

The fact is that drugs have externalized effects, whether you're talking about peer pressure to engage in drug use, crack babies, broken homes, or drug addicts committing crimes to feed their addictions. It's a pretty widely-accepted that society has a right and legitimate interest in policing things that have externalized effects. It may be the case that it's futile to make drugs illegal--that criminalization creates worse societal harms than drug use, but that doesn't make the laws immoral because there is no denying that drug use does in fact cause societal harms. Drug laws are in that sense no different than gun control laws or liquor laws. They may or may not have the intended effect, but it's hard to deny that they address real societal harms.

Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by duaneb on Friday November 07, 2014 @10:50AM (#8573027)
Morality is an aspect of subjective perception. It is not, in fact, entirely clear that these black markets are unhealthy for the world. Are they causing drug epidemics? Are they funding terrorist groups? It's hard to say. Maybe this would remove drug activity from the streets. But the point is, they're pursuing novel problems in the world without actually giving any effort to show us the calculus that went into their decisions, and that is immoral as an agent of justice paid by our taxes.
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by venomsnake on Friday November 07, 2014 @10:22AM (#8572872)
The current drug laws have quite a bit of racism woven into their fabric. This is quite high on the immoral scale.

From everything I have read the 100:1 (and the current 18:1) ratio was targeted towards minorities.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_Sentencing_Act

Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by smokeyj on Friday November 07, 2014 @11:01AM (#8573094)
Reporters are getting their heads chopped off in Mexico. How about the morality of propping up violent drug cartels?
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by mike_hearn on Friday November 07, 2014 @11:59AM (#8573446)
The Mexican cartels don't only engage in drug related crime; the idea that Mexico would become a peaceful utopia overnight if only you could buy crystal meth at your local supermarket doesn't have much evidence to support it.
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by smokeyj on Friday November 07, 2014 @12:39PM (#8573631)
Could you try making a principled argument in favor of prohibition? I haven't seen much evidence to support it.
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by tptacek on Friday November 07, 2014 @12:41PM (#8573637)
That's a dramatic shift of the goalposts, isn't it? His argument was that ending prohibition wouldn't immediately make Mexico a safer place. It wasn't that prohibition was itself an intrinsically good idea.
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by smokeyj on Friday November 07, 2014 @12:50PM (#8573673)
A dramatic shift of goalposts would be equating not having your head chopped off with utopia.

His argument was not that prohibition wouldn't end immediately, it's that "The Mexican cartels don't only engage in drug related crime".

This is a correct statement. Cartels also profit from sex prohibition, but I'm not sure why this justifies anything. Hence my request for a principled argument. Maybe you can help out.

Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by tptacek on Friday November 07, 2014 @01:19PM (#8573846)
That's a very uncharitable summary of the comment you replied to, and also a stretch, since you're the one introducing "utopia" in the the discussion.

I have an easier time mounting a principled argument against prostitution than for drugs. Here it is:

Adults in western societies compete with other adults in the market (in its broadest sense). You can see this, for example, in every job interview.

Usually, competition is benign.

Some forms of competition are not benign. We've decided for example that the competitive tactic of cornering a market and using that position to fix prices is malignant.

As a public policy matter, we allow the market to operate freely except in those cases where the competition becomes malignant.

As a public policy matter, we've decided that it's malignant to allow the form of competition where the winner is the person most willing to compromise their sexual integrity.

We can do that even while understanding that different people have different notions of what comprises "sexual integrity". That's because we recognize that if you allow competition based on sexual compromise, the market races to the bottom, and we operate at the lowest common denominator of "sexual integrity". The market punishes people for not compromising. That emergent property takes on the coercive force of public policy.

In the same sense as there's no intrinsic moral problem with buying a specific amount of, say, lysine, but there is with buying all the lysine and fixing prices, there's no intrinsic moral problem with exchanging money for sex, but there's an emergent problem with allowing people to compete based on their willingness to sell sex.

Put more simply: legalizing prostitution would be at least in some sense (and I think probably in a very powerful sense) coercive of poor women, and particular poor single mothers who have an extraordinarily powerful obligation to finance the upbringing of their children. Not selling your body would become a luxury. It's terrible public policy that allows that to happen.

It happens, obviously, regardless of the policy levers we pull. But society as a whole doesn't create the expectation that people can/should do that. That would stop being true if we allowed red-light districts in our cities.

Preemptively: you asked for a principled argument, by the way, not a dispositive one.

Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by smokeyj on Friday November 07, 2014 @01:43PM (#8573998)
"the idea that Mexico would become a peaceful _utopia_ overnight if only you could buy crystal meth" - Mike_hearn

Mike didn't just shift the goal post, he packed it up, shipped it via fedex, and had it smelted.

Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by mike_hearn on Saturday November 08, 2014 @03:53PM (#8578112)
Um, I used a phrasing that was intended to be slightly more interesting and less dry than "the idea that Mexico would not have violent cartels overnight if ...." - but it should have been obvious what I meant.

You're indeed the one who shifted the goal posts there. You suggested that prohibition is the reason reporters get their heads chopped off in Mexico. I pointed out that it's not the case; cartels do more than just drugs trafficking. You then requested I provide a principled argument for prohibition, as if that's a response to me pointing out a flaw in your own argument.

Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by tptacek on Friday November 07, 2014 @01:45PM (#8574008)
You're right. I'm wrong. I retract that part of my comment and apologize.
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by smokeyj on Friday November 07, 2014 @01:53PM (#8574038)
All good. Regardless I'm interested in reading your position on sexual prohibition. I'll take a closer look later.
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by rayiner on Friday November 07, 2014 @09:10PM (#8575741)
Thank you for a wonderful articulation of that argument.
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by innguest on Friday November 07, 2014 @02:42PM (#8574274)
I find it funny you have a problem "coercing" poor women and single mothers (by allowing them the choice to sell a product they have) but you don't have a problem coercing sex workers out of the industry they chose to work in.

> That would stop being true if we allowed red-light districts in our cities.

Except that the world has several red-light districts and what you're saying would happen never did and never will.

Look, those prostitutes in the Netherlands making pennies for sex, they still have to sit and wait for clients. During that time they can pick up a book and learn other skills. If they're not doing that it's because they don't want to do something else other than have sex for money.

Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by rayiner on Friday November 07, 2014 @03:06PM (#8574402)
You're looking at it the wrong way. You're taking away the "choice" of a small number of women who would choose to engage in sex work, in return for removing the pressure to do so from a large number of women on the margin.
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by tptacek on Friday November 07, 2014 @03:12PM (#8574429)
Yes. Rather than antitrust law, the better analogy would have been to the minimum wage.
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by rayiner on Friday November 07, 2014 @05:47PM (#8575094)
Or workplace safety laws. You take away the "choice" of people to work for employers who cut-corners in terms of safety, to reduce the pressure on desperate people to take such jobs.
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by spacemanmatt on Friday November 07, 2014 @11:23AM (#8573228)
How about the morality of BofA laundering billions for the same violent cartels?
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by vidarh on Friday November 07, 2014 @10:25AM (#8572882)
> Making drugs illegal might be bad policy, but I don't think it rises to the level of immorality.

I do. Because we know that it leads to increased detrimental effects of abuse amongst those that abuse drugs, as well as vast amounts of violent crime to support the drug industry.

Personally, I consider legislators that continue to support drug laws no better than mass murderers.

> The fact is that drugs have externalized effects

There is however little to no evidence that outlawing drug use has had a positive effect on these, and a lot of evidence that outlawing drug use is directly causing some of these, such as pushing drug addicts into other crime.

Before these effects were understood I would have agreed that drug laws were not yet immoral. But these effects are known. There's no excuse.

> that doesn't make the laws immoral because there is no denying that drug use does in fact cause societal harms.

Since when it is a requirement that a law has not positive effect for it to be immoral?

> Drug laws are in that sense no different than gun control laws or liquor laws.

What massive social harm does gun control laws or liquor laws cause? How many people are left dead because of gun control laws or liquor laws?

> it's hard to deny that they address real societal harms.

Yes, they are causing a substantial proportion of them.

Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by Nursie on Friday November 07, 2014 @06:09PM (#8575153)
I'm not sure why you're getting voted down for this.

The drug laws kill, they kill more people that take drugs than they help. They also cause collateral damage all over the place, fund organised crime on a massive scale and contribute to the undermining of stable governments across the world.

There is no doubt at all that prohibition is horrifically immoral.

Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by vidarh on Saturday November 08, 2014 @11:23PM (#8579092)
I was probably getting downvoted because I was rather undiplomatic about how I expressed it. E.g. drawing the parallel between voting for keeping drugs illegal and mass murder means I also implicitly accused anyone who belives drugs should remain illegal of sympathising with mass murder. It's harder to ignore that, than if someone "just" claims that drug prohibition kills without connecting the dots.

But I stand by that.

Still, it stands at 0 at this point, which is quite moderate given how harsh I was.

Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by rayiner on Friday November 07, 2014 @10:09PM (#8575862)
Source for the relative amount of cost versus benefit? What is the avoided cost of kids not feeling social pressure to engage in legal drug use (as they do with legal alcohol abuse)?
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by Nursie on Saturday November 08, 2014 @09:51AM (#8576997)
There is significant evidence that legalisation doesn't really affect the levels of use, particularly with weed. So that argument doesn't hold a lot of water.
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by Nursie on Friday November 07, 2014 @06:10PM (#8575156)
They make those harms demonstrably and measurably worse. They kill. If negligent homicide is immoral then so is the drug legislation and so are the people that prop it up. In fact it goes way beyond negligent.
Re:How the FBI made the world a more dangerous place by shut... by innguest on Friday November 07, 2014 @03:01PM (#8574380)
ahallock asked the right question, but your response is wrong.

Saying there are "immoral laws" and "immoral laws" as if to imply a difference, is intellectually dishonest and violates the law of identity in logic. You're simply trying to weasel in some other definition of "immoral". I'm simply identifying the rhetorical device you're using, and that it doesn't fool everyone as perhaps you wished.

Mandatory genital mutilation is immoral, in the end, because no one ones another person's body, and no one has authority over another person's body.

Making drugs illegal is immoral for the exact same reason.

Drug addicts committing crimes that harm other human beings is also immoral for the exact same reason.

Society has no right to police things because only individuals have rights, not groups. If you think groups have rights I'd love to be convinced of that.

> there is no denying that drug use does in fact cause societal harms.

This is so easy to deny. There are many ways to go about this. We could say caffeine helps society be more productive and so in the end it may be a net benefit. There are other drugs we could argue are helpful, at least for some people, like lithium, aspirin, etc. Moving on, if you don't accept any of the beneficial drugs, I could argue that many instances of drug use result in neutral societal consequences, for instance, every time I use drugs, there is never a societal harm. I'm taking 'societal harm' to mean violations of the rights of any individual in that society. When I take drugs I do not violate any one person's natural rights. So really, there are so many examples of how drug use does not cause societal harm, that for you to say there's no denying that, is frankly delusional.