Coupled to a automatic or CVT gearbox it may get around this problem.
I do think that your point about it lacking VVTL is somewhat amusing though.
But this gadget would shine there! Quiet, no vibration, run it at a single optimum speed all the time. Where can I get one!
The large rotating mass problem is basically what killed off the pre-WWII-style rotary engines, and the Duke engine suffer from the exact same problem.
I know, that's not a Duke engine. Just wondering who got it wrong the first day and went down this path. Like the old 'drum memory' systems that rotated the heads and left the magnetic memory stationary. Didn't take but 2 years to turn that around and invent disk drives.
Yes, ported intake/exhaust solves the problem of rotating the disk instead of the cylinders, but porting comes with its own set of drawbacks. Ask any engineer who has worked on Wankel Rotary engine design and they'll tell you all about it. Ported engine designs include the Wankel Rotary design, as well as 2-stroke, reciprocating, piston-in-sleve (traditional 2-stroke ICE) engine designs. Both have issues meeting emissions requirements because of inherent limitations of ported engine designs.
Cam operated valves have some very specific advantages that play a large role in the ICE's ability to reach current specific output levels. With a ported engine, you cannot vary the intake/exhaust profiles; with a cam, you can. Variable overlap in intake/exhaust, as well as variable intake/exhaust opening area are key aspects of state-of-the-art ICE design. You give up both of these with ported engine designs.
Wondering about these kinds of things is great, but be conservative with your assumptions, and generous in your interpretation. It's condescending and narcissistic to assume that you can take a cursory look at the Duke engine, wave your hand, and solve a massive design flaw.
Its great to hear from an expert, though one that's clearly invested in the current popular technology to the exclusion of admitting any benefit to this one. I thought you'd be right on board with speculating about where this went wrong. Sorry to have misjudged.
> I thought you'd be right on board with speculating about where this went wrong. Sorry to have misjudged.
You've misread me. There's no thing wrong with asking questions. For example, take the question:
"Why can't we rotate the disc instead of the cylinders?"
Versus your statement
"The idea of valve-less cylinders via rotating ports can be done either way - rotating cylinders or rotating shaft - so reverse them."
You state this as if it's obvious, and it is obvious. It's also obvious (to someone with domain knowledge) that it's not a simple matter. I took us part way down the rabbit hole, and I'm always happy to do that, but it really gets under my skin when questions are states as presumptuous declarations such as, "so reverse them." Not to mention this one:
"Just wondering who got it wrong the first day and went down this path."
This presumes that the Duke solution is the wrong one, and your solution is the right one, but you aren't even familiar enough with ported engine designs to know the basic drawbacks. Again, I'm not an expert, but I know enough to know that I can't make these kinds of presumptions. You don't, and my suggestion is that you should recognize and start with questions rather than insulting someone else's work.
I know this comes across as a scolding, but I genuinely don't mean to be harsh. I just felt like I should say something because of the way your writing came across.
And also including turning the problem on its head. If shaft momentum is such a well-known and pernicious problem, then its not out of line to question why somebody went down that road at all. Obvious really. Its called returning to fundamentals, and anybody can do it.
So, what's the problem with using rotation to port air and exhaust, if the disk is turning instead of the now-stationary cylinder block? A mechanical linkage between the disk and a ported sleeve should do the trick. If its still desirable at all - a stationary cylinder block lets you do it the valve way too if desired.
Anyway, I'm actually astonished that anybody ever thought it was a good idea to rotate essentially the entire engine. Centripetal forces, heavier bearings, linkage issues - it invents all sorts of problems. Whereas the idea of pushing against a tilted disk doesn't require that at all. I can't get over that fundamental notion, and I'm sure its fair to ask "where did they go wrong" without being accused of backseat driving. If there's some obvious need to NOT rotate the disk, I'm all ears. But I didn't read that anywhere.
Duke Engines have been around since 1993, and built their first prototype in 1996[1]. Axial engines themselves date back to 1911; Their practical use is limited to torpedoes, where the cylindrical form-factor is an advantage.
Axial engines have inherently high reciprocating mass compared to conventional piston engines, which is a catastrophic flaw in a performance engine design. Higher reciprocating mass increases inertia (reducing throttle response) and increases the forces at the end of the stroke (reducing maximum RPM). They offer no meaningful advantages in terms of fuel efficiency, and are likely to be less efficient in many applications due to the difficulty of implementing existing efficiency technologies (VVT&L, valve deactivation etc)
Both the current Duke engine and their hypothesised next-generation engine offers poorer specific power than current naturally-aspirated designs. The cylindrical form-factor is more difficult to package than a traditional piston engine; Camshafts offer enormous flexibility in terms of layout, allowing the engine to be squeezed into a multitude of shapes and sizes. Axial engines are inherently balanced, but balance is practically a non-issue in modern engines, even for layouts with very poor inherent balance.
[1]http://www.dukeengines.com/technology/overview/