I could see this being yet another situation where someone writes a utility to produce these URL routes for ASP.NET, and makes me wonder why they took such an approach.
Re:ASP.NET MVC Framework (Part 2): URL Routing
by mcfly on Monday December 03, 2007 @12:40PM
(#85648)
Just skimming over the article, it seems to me that the framework authors are trying to do something similar to Routes in Rails or Pylons (http://routes.groovie.org/).
Actually, I find Routes' much clearer and easier to use (regular expressions and readability don't go very well together, IMO) than Django's URL-scheme. The url-generation feature of Routes comes in handy, too... don't know if Django has something equivalent.
Granted, regular expressions may be more powerful, but I am willing to sacrifice some expressiveness in exchange for ease of use and improved readability.
So, I can see why the framework authors ported that functionality (sort of).
Re:ASP.NET MVC Framework (Part 2): URL Routing
by DarrenStuart on Monday December 03, 2007 @05:28PM
(#85719)
looks really simple just the way I like it...
also you can plugin your own routing if you want to do it your own way I think. I watched the video from part1 and it was mentioned that most of the mvc stuff can be swapped out.
I am really looking forward to getting my hands on this.
Django:
I could see this being yet another situation where someone writes a utility to produce these URL routes for ASP.NET, and makes me wonder why they took such an approach.Actually, I find Routes' much clearer and easier to use (regular expressions and readability don't go very well together, IMO) than Django's URL-scheme. The url-generation feature of Routes comes in handy, too... don't know if Django has something equivalent. Granted, regular expressions may be more powerful, but I am willing to sacrifice some expressiveness in exchange for ease of use and improved readability. So, I can see why the framework authors ported that functionality (sort of).
Interesting, I assumed the django list would make sense what it was doing at a glance to anyone.
I am just picturing a list of ~25 routes, and it being impossible to get an idea of the sitemap.
also you can plugin your own routing if you want to do it your own way I think. I watched the video from part1 and it was mentioned that most of the mvc stuff can be swapped out.
I am really looking forward to getting my hands on this.