Incompetent may be the wrong word. What people (including you) are getting at is that his arguments are unpersuasive upon examination. It's all just fear mongering.
There are two plausible explanations for this. The first is that he doesn't see the holes in his own arguments; that would substantiate the charge of incompetence. The second is that he does but makes the arguments anyway in order to mislead others who don't. That appears to be the case you're making. But I'm not sure scoundrel is a lesser charge than idiot.
A third possibility is that he honestly believes his position is the correct one--or is holding out the possibility of returning to a .gov/.mil job in this or a future administration--and (a) is using the best arguments for his case, however weak or (b) is on a conference panel, not in a courtroom, and is aiming for entertaining one-liners rather than a point-by-point argument that you'd find in a legal brief or congressional testimony.
That leaves "using the best arguments for the case he truly believes in, however weak". This I think would correctly fall under the umbrella of incompetence. At some point, rational people are supposed to evaluate their own arguments and change their beliefs if they can't sustain them anymore.
In this case he has strongly implied that "tech people" with a libertarian bent are naive and their beliefs crumble the moment they're faced with the real world. Insulting the people you need help from isn't a good start. But regardless, I don't know of any tech companies that have real problems complying with a robust, trustworthy process that includes many checks and balances to ensure only people widely agreed to be criminals get investigated. The whole problem has started because that system has broken down over time and post-Snowden been revealed as nothing more than a political sleight of hand.
But this begs the question why otherwise self-respecting panels so often give a soapbox to propagandists. Perhaps instead of using the mindless daily news formula of pitting two self-interested views against each other to see who has better soundbites we should try to put rational, thoughtful people on the stage.
I don't understand how the people who play these games can motivate themselves to get up in the morning.
Forget morality. I'm just talking about a sense that you're doing something worth doing at all.
I just couldn't do it. No matter how hard I tried, eventually the realization that what I was doing was meaningless backbiting bullshit would sink in and I'd blow my brains out.
Maybe it's the "secret to success in New York" joke. The joke goes that the secret is to be smart enough to play the game but not smart enough to figure the game out. My guess would be that applies to DC far more than NY.
That's one reason I decamped to the SF bay area. I have friends still living in DC (or one of its inner 'burbs) who have been saying for over a decade that they want to escape the games and backbiting bullshit, but have never managed to do so. One reason is the compensation can be high: the DC area is home to the highest-income county in the nation[1]. Stewart is a senior partner at Steptoe, where the average partner income is approx. $1M[2]; as a very senior one he might be taking home $2M a year.
Plus housing prices are cheaper than SF or the peninsula, and if you're trained as a political fixer/policy wonk, where else do you go?
On a more HN-relevant point, working in DC means trying to get a bigger slice of a fixed pie. Silicon Valley companies and other startups around the world can make the pie bigger. For more realpolitik, check out this provocative essay on DC-Silicon Valley by San Jose-based Cypress Semiconductor cofounder/CEO TJ Rodgers (it's worth a read even if you disagree, I think): http://www.cypress.com/?rID=34975
[1] "The Washington region dominates the list of the most affluent places in the United States..." http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/govbeat/wp/2013/12/12/th...
[2] http://legaltimes.typepad.com/blt/2013/02/steptoe-johnson-ll...
Using cigarette taxes as an example highlights an intrinsic problem with libertarianism: sometimes government is our only defense against "softer" forms of power. Cigarettes are chemically addictive, so selling them means essentially using mind control to generate repeat customers.
Some libertarians want to be free to create value, but others want to be free to con people. Typical Randians like TJ Rodgers don't see the difference, or they grossly overestimate the ability of free human beings to defend themselves against determined and clever con artistry. Much con artistry, such as financial swindling, is very sophisticated when compared with something as ham-fisted as addictive drug pushing. If humans were good enough to resist that kind of thing, there'd be no jobs for stage magicians. Everyone would spot their tricks.
If I were in government and were doing government's proper job, I'd feel good about my work. My feeling though is that quite a bit of government and its related business orbit isn't doing anything like that.
In other words, you aren't supposed to present both sides of the argument, you're supposed to present your side alone. It's up to your adversary to find the faults in your arguments - if there are any.
Stewart Baker, being a former lawyer, might simply be arguing in this tradition.
The role of the defense is much as you describe; to advance every conceivable argument, etc. The role of the prosecutor is intended to be a seeker of truth, however, which doesn't always mean aggressively seeking conviction.
In practice, however, your description is accurate; it's a rare prosecutor that doesn't pull out all the stops in an effort to convict, regardless of the evidence.
Congress and the court of public opinion have no judges to sanction "lawyers" for misbehaving. The sanctions [are supposed to] come in the form of loss of credibility and people not listening to you anymore. The argument that everyone shouldn't stop listening to him because he's just arguing like a lawyer would literally break the entire political process -- which appears to be what has happened, and it needs to stop.
"We will map your social graph, compromise every computer and smartphone in your country"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mu9puGKfdZE
He is a long-time proponent of export controls for cryptography and government mandated escrow-keys. In 1994, he wrote an article for Wired Magazine titled: "Don't Worry Be Happy: Why Clipper Is Good For You". This guy is a cryptowars veteran.
So, in a sense--you're right, he's not incompetent. Rather, he is a professional ideologue: making the case against privacy rights that crypto-tech enables. If you have experience with KGB "agitprop" and "active measures", you'll be very familiar with the techniques that these sort of people employ for their cause. We should promptly react to his demagoguery by showing it for what it is--sophistry.
That someone is smart does not mean that whatever he says is true.
In fact some of the smartest people on earth use their intelligence to fool and mislead other people.
It is not very smart on this man when he talks about blackberry: "look were blackberry is today". Blackberry in fact did help governments with their encryptions keys.
In particular,people that worked for the NSA need to develop a habit of lying to everyone as a morning routine.
We know that while the CIA and the NSA were crying loud about how encryption was making them "blind", they were in fact spying on more Americans and non Americans than ever.
They see a new and robust revenue stream where the product was being shoplifted, and they're correcting that business oversight. They will give the government what they want, but at a cost.
Be it in a dollar amount, backroom hand-greasing, political football, or other otherwise -- the government will pay that cost.
But the rhetorical device he used, attempting to pin the demise of Blackberry on their choice to encrypt, is found waiting.
Blackberry was defeated by market forces, not a willingness to encrypt user data. The iPhone and Android changed the firmament in the market where Blackberry had been dominant.
His attempt at using this aside, his use of "law enforcement needs access" is also found wanting because the NDA, GHCQ, etc are not law-enforcement.
I read this as Declan saying that he and Baker were sufficiently acquainted for him to form a judgement of Baker's competence, with "he'd show up at parties I held" being to clarify the degree of their acquaintance. He's not claiming that they two things are causally connected.
And ignoring demagogues is not necessarily a good idea.
Stewart is extremely smart, should not be underestimated, and HN comments in this thread calling him "incompetent" reflect badly on the person making the comment. He's likely the single most capable adversary the HN/EFF/ACLU/Cato/Mozilla/etc. axis faces over encryption (if he ends up playing that role).
Stewart is correct that end-to-end crypto will "restrict [companies'] ability to sell" products internationally. And he is narrowly correct that "the market for absolute encryption is more limited than you might think" in a corporate environment. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ak4ZwLU3aX0 [8:45]
But these are merely clever rhetorical devices. Of course Apple/Google/FB/etc. know that HTTPS will vex snoophappy governments; at this point I suspect their CEOs may view that as a welcome side effect and in any case know their business better than a DC attorney does. And of course banks and brokerage firms don't want end-to-end encryption for their employees; they have likely have FINRA and other legal obligations to preserve correspondence.
Okay, Russia and China are snoophappy and banks may want access to employees' email. Now can we go back to talking about the NSA's bulk surveillance of law-abiding Americans?
Stewart's comments at 12:56 about Silicon Valley companies "picking fights" with the NSA are also misleading. In reality, the NSA was "picking fights" by bulk-tapping Google's interdata center links, subverting encryption standards, and (in the 1990s) defending export controls that weakened American companies' ability to compete. I posted more about this here: https://twitter.com/declanm/status/529804398457651201 https://twitter.com/declanm/status/529798596221095937
Today these companies -- and hopefully the startup founders here on HN -- are merely protecting their users by adopting encryption. At http://recent.io/, which I founded after leaving CNET/CBS earlier this year, our forthcoming Android and iOS apps use only HTTPS to connect to the backend. Naturally.
TLDR: You underestimate Stewart Baker at your peril.