Ion Torrent didn't put Illumina out of business or anything but it did define a new market segment in high throughput DNA sequencing for small to mid size labs. Ion Torrent's PGM is like the PC of DNA sequencing to Illumina's mainframe HiSeq and forced Illumina to respond with their MiSeq machine. I for one am very excited to see the democratization of DNA sequencing as it gets more available to smaller labs and individuals.
Can't wait to see what he and the team pull off on this one as we certainly need a few more breakthroughs in the clinic both in price and ease of use!
I was thinking of trying to make a smartphone-powered ultrasound awhile back and looked into it, and these devices don't look too complicated. You put a piezo in a little box, and cycle it to send/receive vibration in the form of sound. The software to decode the signal into an image is the hard part. But if it's Rothberg behind this...well, I'll take his word for it being a hard thing to make low-cost.
The truth maybe that the technology just has fundamental limitations. But I'd would say that's not objectively clear.
The Illumina (Solexa) platform also had significant limitations, it took a lot of platform development to get it where it is today. In contrast Illumina have executed quite well, providing systematic improvements to the Solexa platform.
Ion Torrent raised around 60MUSD according to angel.co. They sold for 375MUSD, with milestone payments making it up to 725MUSD. I've no idea if they hit their milestones or not.
454 was a lot less... I think a few hundred million. But they also raised less IIRC.
His two DNA sequencing companies (454 and Ion torrent) have both had what I would consider successful exits (solid to Roche and Life technologies respectively). But more importantly both products made their way into the hands of consumers (which is actually rare for DNA sequencing startups). However after acquisition both products failed to gain significant traction (Roche has just shelved 454).
He also engages in a certain amount of showmanship [1], which has as gained him some ridicule. I think he has to be respected to successfully executing in a market where most startups fizzle out though.
I hope this pans out though, it sounds awesome. I really hope this (and other research/medical device) technology makes its way into the hands of normal consumers (not just research labs/medical institutes).
[1] Oh and he has a scale model of Stonehenge in his back yard. http://clonehenge.com/2009/01/17/circle-of-life-connecticuts...