News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by sfk on Saturday November 01, 2014 @10:13AM (#8543081)
If open source parasites like tip4commit don't learn, the next logical step is to trademark projects and send DMCA notices without wasting any further time.

Also, with this kind of sleazy behavior, the advertising clause in the BSD license suddenly becomes very appealing again.

Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by chakalakasp on Saturday November 01, 2014 @10:43AM (#8543199)
I don't think DMCA applies to Trademarks, it is a law that specifically pertains to copyright. The two areas of law are quite different.
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by scotty79 on Saturday November 01, 2014 @02:52PM (#8544150)
Yeah. I noticed people treat DMCA as "don't do anything I don't like with what I'm involved with" law.
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by tokenizerrr on Saturday November 01, 2014 @11:14AM (#8543313)
The author of tip4commit has already stated they're not from America. DMCA is only relevant within America as far as I know.
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by sfk on Saturday November 01, 2014 @11:19AM (#8543336)
Their ISP appears to be LINODE-US. But the other commenters are right that DMCA probably does not apply to trademarks.
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by godzilla82 on Saturday November 01, 2014 @01:46PM (#8543886)
Also their domain name is registered via a company registered in US.
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by Bill_Dimm on Saturday November 01, 2014 @10:48AM (#8543222)
I thought DMCA applied to copyright (hence the "C" in the name), not trademark. Am I wrong?
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by cookiecaper on Saturday November 01, 2014 @12:04PM (#8543499)
No, you're right. DMCA and trademarks are completely unrelated.
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by Cakez0r on Saturday November 01, 2014 @11:33AM (#8543373)
Giving money to open source developers. How parasitical.
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by ubernostrum on Saturday November 01, 2014 @12:06PM (#8543504)
Consider that some of the projects they collect on "behalf" of already have donation mechanisms in place, both from a technical and legal perspective, and would prefer to see those mechanisms used.
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by monort on Saturday November 01, 2014 @01:23PM (#8543815)
Django don't accept bitcoin as donation.
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by Elepsis on Saturday November 01, 2014 @02:29PM (#8544059)
And that is a choice they get to make because it's their project. They also don't accept mitten donations as far as I know. Are you going to collect mittens from people on their behalf and email every committer to receive their mittens?
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by sfk on Saturday November 01, 2014 @12:17PM (#8543555)
Overloading productive open source devs with spam and administrative bullshit is parasitic. (Allegedly) collecting money after a project has told them to stop is parasitic at best.
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by dlisboa on Saturday November 01, 2014 @11:38AM (#8543402)
Not all open source developers want money for their open source software. You think collecting money using someone else's hard work isn't a bad thing. A hard work that the person explicitly went to the trouble of making free and abstained from any income derived solely from it.
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by cookiecaper on Saturday November 01, 2014 @12:03PM (#8543495)
Lots of people want to make money from their open-source projects, directly or indirectly.
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by dlisboa on Saturday November 01, 2014 @12:39PM (#8543655)
This project is only directly, which violates indirectly. Lots of people don't want to be paid directly for their open-source projects.

Mainly because that's precisely what open-source isn't: it's not distribution of software services. There isn't a consumer-producer relationship.

Indirectly is what works great: someone with a vested interest pays an open source developer for his expertise to make sure the open source project continues on. The developer is backed by the full extent of labor laws, welfare services and all other work-related niceties her or his country might have. Or the developer provides a service with clear boundaries which other people pay for, helping provide income for the project's developer and possibly giving it guidance.

Directly there's none of that. There's only people giving money to someone who now has to bear the full legality of it, unaware of the purpose or source of said money. If they don't want it, don't force it on them. Not to mention most projects which want money already have a system set up for it, a system which they explicitly decided was the best for them.

There are loads of other ways to support open source developers other than forcibly putting them in a situation in which they need to hire a lawyer.

Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by Cakez0r on Saturday November 01, 2014 @11:54AM (#8543464)
I agree that an open source developer can object to donations on a personal level and I think it's a very reasonable request to personally unsubscribe from communications from some entity.

What I don't agree with is complaining that you're being spammed after you put your contact information in the public domain and receive a notification that somebody would like to give you money. I also don't agree that a "project owner" should get to deny any potential contributors to receive donations based on his own personal objections.

Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by dlisboa on Saturday November 01, 2014 @12:25PM (#8543596)
I literally disagree with everything you said.

First I don't agree a request should be made to unsubscribe. There shouldn't have been anything to unsubscribe from.

Second it's not the project owner's fault simply because their contact information is out and about. You're saying spamming people with promises of money that has their legal name attached to is just fine and it's the people's fault they allowed themselves to get spammed.

The worst thing, even, is that the people doing the donating have no idea if their money actually got to the person they intended it to.

> I also don't agree that a "project owner" should get to deny any potential contributors to receive donations based on his own personal objections.

This is the part I most strongly disagree with. You're trampling over people's livelihoods, principles and personal choices. Accepting donations has legal repercussions. Legal repercussions the top4commit owners wilfully disregard and have no intention of paying attention to. There are countries with laws that'd make the open source developer liable to damages and tax evasion.

That is only the legal part. The principle part is that many people don't write open source software to get paid from it. They have abdicated from gaining monetary advantage from distribution of knowledge. If you want to pay them, hire them and pay them for their expertise. It's a personal choice, one that is being disrespected here.

This project should simply work on consent-only or be dismantled. Remove all current repositories and advertise to gain project owners who actually want to be there. The people who created tip4commit have no legal expertise or intent to get legal advice, they're not helping the Open Source community, and most of all they have no transparency or accountability in the event of fraud.

Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by matrix on Saturday November 01, 2014 @10:26AM (#8543139)
Agreed. This behavior is not benign "naughtiness" (as the YC guys like to encourage), it's parasitic exploitation of other people's hard work. Another group I'd lump in with this group is readthedocs.org
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by freakboy3742 on Saturday November 01, 2014 @10:42AM (#8543196)
Why you put Read The Docs in the same category? RTD doesn't host anything unless you specifically set up an account and say you want to use them. They don't troll the web looking for projects, and hosting their docs whether they want them to or not.
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by sfilipov on Saturday November 01, 2014 @10:48AM (#8543221)
Would you please elaborate on the problem with readthedocs.org?
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by legutierr on Saturday November 01, 2014 @10:45AM (#8543213)
readthedocs.org? How so?
Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by matrix on Saturday November 01, 2014 @02:55PM (#8544159)
I put readthedocs in the same category because they try to look like the original source of the documentation. They lift the content and style, lock stock and barrel, and then try to rank higher than the actual project's documentation pages.

I have in the past, unwittingly read out-of-date documentation because it looked exactly like the source site, and I didn't pay close attention to the URL.

If they were truly ethical, they would not try to impersonate the original sites. It fails one of the most basic tests for trademark infringement (which is, essentially: "might someone in a hurry mistake it for the real thing?").

Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by freakboy3742 on Saturday November 01, 2014 @06:29PM (#8544858)
Erm... RTD does none of those things. There's a default site theme that is specific to RTD - they don't try to impersonate anyone. They don't "lift" anything unless the project owner has opened an account and requested that their documentation be hosted on RTD.

I'm at a complete loss how you've even come to the impression that RTD does the things you claim it does - because it does nothing of the sort.

Re:Please remove mitsuhiko/* by woof on Saturday November 01, 2014 @04:40PM (#8544535)
Keep on trollin'