Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut...
by api on Friday October 31, 2014 @08:38PM
(#8541796)
"Hybrid systems always lead to a worst of both worlds outcome."
Not necessarily in engineering, but in politics generally that's true.
We have a hybrid healthcare system for example. It combines all the worst things about private for-profit healthcare with all the worst things about socialized medicine.
Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut...
by wpietri on Friday October 31, 2014 @08:56PM
(#8541836)
Don't sell it short. The US healthcare system also has many special flaws all its own. For example, I don't think either a fully for-profit or a fully socialized system would get taken for a ride on pharmaceutical and vendor costs the way we do.
Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut...
by jrcii on Friday October 31, 2014 @08:08PM
(#8541728)
To say nothing of its merit, it looks like they're going to rely on the justification that reversing past deregulation policy would create a situation where their own past arguments would be used against them in court when the ISPs inevitably challenge their decision.
Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut...
by sgift on Friday October 31, 2014 @10:31PM
(#8542013)
"We've wised up on our earlier judgement. We were wrong when we stated these things because of foo, bar, baz, bat, bam, bla" ... that sounds like a good answer to any "You had other arguments in the past!!!" attack?
Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut...
by doctorshady on Friday October 31, 2014 @08:31PM
(#8541778)
I'm thinking the ISPs will probably challenge it anyway. The impression I'm getting is a lot of them wanted nothing to do with Title II.
Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut...
by privong on Friday October 31, 2014 @09:25PM
(#8541904)
Except when it benefits them: https://www.techdirt.com/blog/netneutrality/articles/2014103...
Hybrid systems always lead to a worst of both worlds outcome. Such systems are always designed not with excellence in mind, but with placation in mind. Someone with influence threw a tantrum at the proper solution, so the hybrid was introduced as a way to pacify them.
This is not how you lead the world in Internet connectivity and deploy universal gigabit+ broadband with no tax on Internet services (ie what we should be aiming for).