News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut... by adventured on Friday October 31, 2014 @07:31PM (#8541603)
It's striking that Comcast so thoroughly dominates the US Government that the FCC has to approach 'solutions' from the position that they have to route around Comcast.

Hybrid systems always lead to a worst of both worlds outcome. Such systems are always designed not with excellence in mind, but with placation in mind. Someone with influence threw a tantrum at the proper solution, so the hybrid was introduced as a way to pacify them.

This is not how you lead the world in Internet connectivity and deploy universal gigabit+ broadband with no tax on Internet services (ie what we should be aiming for).

Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut... by api on Friday October 31, 2014 @08:38PM (#8541796)
"Hybrid systems always lead to a worst of both worlds outcome."

Not necessarily in engineering, but in politics generally that's true.

We have a hybrid healthcare system for example. It combines all the worst things about private for-profit healthcare with all the worst things about socialized medicine.

Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut... by wpietri on Friday October 31, 2014 @08:56PM (#8541836)
Don't sell it short. The US healthcare system also has many special flaws all its own. For example, I don't think either a fully for-profit or a fully socialized system would get taken for a ride on pharmaceutical and vendor costs the way we do.
Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut... by jrcii on Friday October 31, 2014 @08:08PM (#8541728)
To say nothing of its merit, it looks like they're going to rely on the justification that reversing past deregulation policy would create a situation where their own past arguments would be used against them in court when the ISPs inevitably challenge their decision.
Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut... by sgift on Friday October 31, 2014 @10:31PM (#8542013)
"We've wised up on our earlier judgement. We were wrong when we stated these things because of foo, bar, baz, bat, bam, bla" ... that sounds like a good answer to any "You had other arguments in the past!!!" attack?
Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut... by doctorshady on Friday October 31, 2014 @08:31PM (#8541778)
I'm thinking the ISPs will probably challenge it anyway. The impression I'm getting is a lot of them wanted nothing to do with Title II.
Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut... by privong on Friday October 31, 2014 @09:25PM (#8541904)
Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut... by dbrower on Friday October 31, 2014 @08:41PM (#8541803)
Awful. Instead of throttling Netflix at the backbone level, they'll do it in the local loop.

A single, neutral regime is the only viable one that doesn't mess things up.

The trick is how to NOT turn title II into a highly regulated service like the POTS loop, but into one the encourages competition within the bounds of traffic neutrality.

Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut... by themartorana on Friday October 31, 2014 @11:52PM (#8542132)
"or to be vulnerable to criticism"

Let's not do this insanely important thing that may define the next hundred years of access to information because someone might say mean things about us??

Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut... by chatmasta on Saturday November 01, 2014 @02:15PM (#8543996)
"The retail portion...which allows the consumer to access any legal content on the Internet.."

"legal content"

The real motivation lies in that sentence.

Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut... by just2n on Saturday November 01, 2014 @02:01AM (#8542328)
“any use of Title II would be problematic.”

For you, not for us.

Re:F.C.C. Considering Hybrid Regulatory Approach to Net Neut... by rhizome on Friday October 31, 2014 @09:31PM (#8541915)
Nothing like installing the thin edge of the wedge from the start.