News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try t... by pohl on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @01:59PM (#853177)
I don't buy that theory. I'm fairly sensitive to intonation, and have never heard it intoned in the manner you suggest.

I think it's more likely that people parrot the sounds without thinking of the words and/or the meaning. Compare to "for all intensive purposes", for example.

Re:You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try t... by aristoxenus on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @02:40PM (#853304)
"I couldn't care less" is the literal way to state the sentiment, but it sounds weak and petulant compared to the idiom. There are multiple intonations that could potentially achieve the sarcastic effect, but the common one is just a flat dismissive delivery.

I agree with your observation of that common mechanism for mangling English, though. The mis-quote you mention is particularly embarrassing to behold.

Re:You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try t... by Radix on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @05:23PM (#853739)
Somehow I hadn't noticed 'intensive purposes', so thanks. Recently I have found the use of 'practically' as a replacement for 'pretty much' irksome. We have plenty of words for that and no more to indicate 'for practical purposes'.

As others have pointed out: language is meant to be understood. It would be enough to always take the meaning from a speaker, except if we do that chronically, we begin to lose words. Which will make communication more difficult when you need those specialized meanings.

Bother.

Re:You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try t... by jwhite on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @07:40PM (#853984)
If you're a fan of Strunk & White, you can usually do without "pretty much" as well. What does it add?
Re:You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try t... by mr_justin on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @02:45PM (#853316)
That's fine if you don't buy it, but it still seems to be an accepted idiom.
Re:You're the Smartest Guy In The Room ... but please, try t... by thras on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @02:04PM (#853192)
Maybe it's regional. Regardless, Stephen Pinker discusses the intonation of "could care less" in The Language Instinct.