News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by rryan on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @03:31PM (#8523050)
Seriously, why would I let an advertising company in my body?
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by Florin_Andrei on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @04:01PM (#8523218)
> an advertising company

http://www.wired.com/2014/10/future-of-artificial-intelligen...

> Around 2002 I attended a small party for Google—before its IPO, when it only focused on search. I struck up a conversation with Larry Page, Google's brilliant cofounder, who became the company's CEO in 2011. “Larry, I still don't get it. There are so many search companies. Web search, for free? Where does that get you?” My unimaginative blindness is solid evidence that predicting is hard, especially about the future, but in my defense this was before Google had ramped up its ad-auction scheme to generate real income, long before YouTube or any other major acquisitions. I was not the only avid user of its search site who thought it would not last long.

> But Page's reply has always stuck with me: “Oh, we're really making an AI.”

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by applecore on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @05:29PM (#8523723)
Except, the real answer to that question is: “Oh, keyword advertising will be the single most profitable business model on the Internet.”
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by statictype on Wednesday October 29, 2014 @01:19AM (#8525691)
That's fairly condescending.

Seeing projects like this only affirm what I've generally felt about Google. They don't build stuff to sell ads. They sell ads to do cool stuff like this.

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by reacweb on Wednesday October 29, 2014 @04:38AM (#8526103)
I think this is the key to understand google. They are building the "skynet" of terminator. They won't turn evil before they succeed.
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by throwaway7808 on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @04:49PM (#8523499)
Most likely you and your kids are gonna be wiped out by intellegent machines just in a few decades.
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by pgodzin on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @05:04PM (#8523570)
More realistically, they will make your life easier as many machines before them have.
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by gtremper on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @07:46PM (#8524510)
I'm more worried about intelligent humans
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by notduncansmith on Wednesday October 29, 2014 @01:32AM (#8525730)
I worry more about the other side of the bell curve.
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday October 29, 2014 @09:56AM (#8527139)
>> But Page's reply has always stuck with me: “Oh, we're really making an AI.”

Well, I burst out laughing when I read this. They've been trying for 12 years and haven't managed major publishable advancements in AGI?

I mean, they did establish the annual AGI conference in 2005... so that's something.

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by jfuhrman on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @09:13PM (#8524903)
[Edit: Downvotes, why?]

Which of these actions are about making an AI?

Most of the Google search page area is now occupied by ads, or ads disguised as content

http://searchengineland.com/google-results-too-ad-heavy-1662...

Decreasing contrast in the background of ads, this especially hurts older people as ability to see contrast decreases with age, and the FTC found that almost half the people fail to notice that there are ads on the page, thus forcing products that are first in the organic results to pay Google for ads.

http://ppcblog.com/fbf0fa-now-you-see-itor-maybe-not/

http://blumenthals.com/blog/2012/01/31/is-google-intentional...

http://wallstcheatsheet.com/stocks/ftc-googles-ad-practice-i...

Tracking the emails in the free Google Apps for Education and even paid Google Apps for Business to build ad profiles, making misleading statements to the public that they're not doing so, and then when it finally came to having to make statements to federal court, having to tell the truth about it and then claiming the consumer Gmail policy applied to Apps for Education data.

http://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2014/03/13/26google.h33.ht...

Paid inclusion for shopping search results

http://marketingland.com/once-deemed-evil-google-now-embrace...

Ranking Google+ reviews over Yelp results even if the user explicitly searches for Yelp

http://www.searchenginejournal.com/yelp-complains-outranked-...

Conspiring to kill SkyHook(and succeeding) with its 500lb outsized influence like Microsoft used to.

http://www.theverge.com/2011/05/12/google-android-skyhook-la...

Getting fined by FTC for violating Gmail users privacy by exposing their friends lists in Google Buzz in order to compete with Twitter http://www.netcompetition.org/antitrust/why-ftcs-22-5m-googl...

Tracking the physical location of Android phones for ad purposes without properly informing users and disabling things like Google Now if you disable the tracking.

http://digiday.com/platforms/google-tracking/

Google employee accesses personal information of others. Google says it has fixed the issue, but how do we even know? Is there any legal safeguard against someone at Google reading your email?

http://gawker.com/5637234/gcreep-google-engineer-stalked-tee...

Tying Android App store to having Google search engine as default on Android, ensuring that alternative search engines cannot be shipped as default.

http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2014/02/12/documents-shed-light-...

Stopping Acer from shipping Aliyun OS by threatening to pull the Play Store and Android beta access. Bonus points for enforcing this by the duplicitous moniker 'Open Handset Alliance' doublespeak

http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2012/09/report-google-threate...

Making people literally cry with the forced Google+ integration into Youtube and making confusing UX to make people share more than they want to, in order to compete with Facebook.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ccxiwu4MaJs (warning, NSFW language)

Extracting petty revenge on CNET for googling(!) information on its CEO

http://money.cnn.com/2005/08/05/technology/google_cnet/

Convicted in the courts for colluding with other tech firms in illegal non-poaching agreements

http://pando.com/2014/03/22/revealed-apple-and-googles-wage-...

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by dannyr on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @03:43PM (#8523116)
Ah, we see what we want to see.

You see Google as a company that is just serving ads.

I see Google as a company collecting and organizing information.

Should companies not do things beyond what they are doing right now even if it means improving people's lives?

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by wpietri on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @04:39PM (#8523446)
Companies over time become whatever their revenue stream requires of them. There are exceptions, but very few.

If you'd like to read further, The Innovator's Dilemma and related material has a lot of examples of companies where inertia around existing lines of revenue was strong enough to kill them.

But it's deeper than that. It's only obvious because those companies had their markets shift under them. I think the same sort of inertia is endemic, but it only becomes visible when circumstances change. E.g., look at the number of newspaper companies that existed before 1994, and look at how many are thriving today.

Google's not immune to this. Whatever wonders they come up with, the company is stuffed with people who are very good at selling their users (that is, us) to their customers (the advertisers). It's entirely reasonable to fear what those people will do with my medical data.

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by bduerst on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @04:22PM (#8523347)
There's that, but I also think some users are still a little spooked about the whole NSA scare, and are hesitant to give up trust to a company that could be forcefully controlled by the NSA or secret court rulings.

It's not Google's fault, but more the U.S. Government for being incapable to reign in control of certain organizations.

Personally I don't care - from a data perspective I'm know I'm not a special snowflake, but for others I can understand their stress.

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by enraged_camel on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @07:24PM (#8524376)
>>You see Google as a company that is just serving ads. >>I see Google as a company collecting and organizing information.

You can see it however you want. The truth can be found by asking a simple question: how does Google make money? By serving ads. They may collect and organize information in the process, but ultimately they are an advertising company.

I'm on the fence about this detector. On the one hand, yes, there are significant benefits. On the other hand, the costs are also monumental. One has to cast their fanboy/hater hat aside and weigh these pros and cons carefully and objectively before making a decision.

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by wfjackson on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @08:47PM (#8524795)
>I see Google as a company collecting and organizing information...

...and then making it hard to access on Windows Phone.

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by adventured on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @03:48PM (#8523149)
If they came up with a highly effective method to quickly and inexpensively screen me for cancer or an impending heart attack...

I would do it because their interests are aligned with mine: they want me to live a lot longer so I can do a lot more searches and view more youtube videos etc, and so do I. Our reasons for wanting me to live longer are different, but they get their benefit and I get mine, fair trade.

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by drdeadringer on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @04:25PM (#8523357)
A part of me is imagining a dystopian Doctorow saying: "...a computer is something my mother puts my life into".

Another part of me is saying: "Shut up and tell me if I have cancer".

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by arnarbi on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @03:39PM (#8523091)
Because it might add 20 years to your life?
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by sharkweek on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @03:42PM (#8523109)
All sarcasm and cynicism aside... that IS 20 years extra life for them to be showing a warm body advertisements
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by spydum on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @03:53PM (#8523176)
So google is trying to keep us alive longer to generate more revenue! Should we be offended or flattered?
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by owyn on Wednesday October 29, 2014 @01:52AM (#8525775)
Interesting question: what is the lifetime value of a person who uses a search engine to a company like Google?

Looks like about $180 per year at the moment:

http://www.digitalstrategyconsulting.com/intelligence/2014/0...

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by eclipxe on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @05:12PM (#8523618)
Win-win all around
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by msabalau on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @07:04PM (#8524226)
"We are the inventors of the technology but we have no intentions of commercialising it or monetising it in that way," he said.

"We will license it out and the partners will take it forward to doctors and patients."

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by epeterson19 on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @05:48PM (#8523799)
So you can be directed towards doctors/procedures/products to treat whatever they find? Advertising isn't necessarily bad...
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by ripb on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @05:57PM (#8523847)
>So you can be directed towards doctors/procedures/products to treat whatever they find? Advertising isn't necessarily bad...

Which promotes those who can pay the most to advertise, not the best in their field or even a given user's area/feasible options.

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by epeterson19 on Wednesday October 29, 2014 @11:22AM (#8527644)
One could argue that the best doctors would be the ones with the most deployable capital. Not too many lotto winners in medicine.
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by jerrickhoang on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @03:51PM (#8523161)
And what is the worst thing that could happen?
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by tedks on Wednesday October 29, 2014 @12:50AM (#8525613)
2018: Google Health Scanner begins operation in selected pilot cities. Lines wrap around the block as people try to make it in while it's still free (even though the crowd is exclusively composed of people who could certainly afford it, because it's in a whitewashed, gentrified suburban neighborhood).

2019: Apple (January) and later Microsoft (October) respond with their own health scanners. Integrating with their respective data silos on personal health data, only people with iPhones or Windows Phones can be screened at an Apple Store Clinic or Windows You location.

2025: A federal case reveals that Google's initial scanner, in an attempt to reduce false positives, left millions with false confidence in their health. Google settles and introduces a subscription plan.

2027: Leaked emails, photographs, and a misconfigured Hangout that was broadcast live on YouTube show decisively that Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, and Oracle are colluding to keep wages low for the medical staff they employ. Oracle doesn't even have any medical staff, it just wanted in on the collusion. The federal government reacts by saying "These people have our medical results now and we're not going near this with a ten-foot pole."

2030: Google announces Nexus Implant, a biometric device that relays data in real-time to Google. This is lauded by the CDC as a major help in combating epidemics. Apple launches iMe later that year. Microsoft released a biometric implant in 2004, but it was derided as "too clunky." Surface You comes out in 2032.

2031: For the 2031 flu season, biometrics users are advised to upgrade to a version with vaccination pods. Capable of being intelligently released if it detects you are exposed to a specific flu strain, this enables the immunocompromised to be "just-in-time vaccinated". Thanks to the tracking data reported back from the implants, flu is at an all-time low.

2033: Massive vulnerabilities rock the now ludicrously decrepit but still used X.509 CA infrastructure. Nobody discusses leaving X.509.

2034: First jailbreak exploits for iMe released, allowing users to circumvent the trusted computing chip on the iMe and load custom firmware. This is initially used by biohackers looking to access raw sensor data.

Spring 2035: Unrest in Bahrain turns coldly bloody as the regime infects anyone with an iMe, Nexus Implant, or Surface Inside with acute vaccination sickness, caused by firing all vaccination pods simultaneously (all implants are now pre-loaded with vaccinations for common infections). A postmortem of the attack determines that the Bahrainian national CA deployed an exploit similar to the jailbreak to issue rogue commands to the vaccination units.

Fall 2035: Protestors in China, Russia and the Ukraine keel over, eyes bleeding, as a custom-made virus is released from backdoored implants. Google defends placing the kill-switches as a cost of doing business in accordance with foreign law in foreign countries.

Winter 2035: As tensions run high during a trade dispute between China, Greater Korea, and Malaysia, rouge cyberattackers kill thousands of people using unpatched implants. Calls increase for implants to be recalled, but the flu season looks to be the worst in a long time, and critics say superbugs caused by on-demand antibiotics use via the CleanU app (YC 2033) could be more fatal than the unpatched implants. After heavy lobbying, Google supports Android Z for the Nexus Implant.

Spring 2036: The trade dispute worsens, and after a misstep on the part of a US mediator, a cyberattack from "patriotic Chinese citizens" kills several local, state, and federal government workers and politicians. Presidential hopeful Chris Schwarzenegger is killed. The United States demands sanctions on China, alleging the attack to have originating from PLA-controlled networks. Both countries enter into an economic death spiral as they try to disentangle their economies. A SpaceX launch is misinterpreted by a Chinese early-warning system as a nuclear launch and, fearing annihilation, the PRC unleashes its now-substantial nuclear arsenal on America and NATO. Russia interprets Ukraine-bound missiles as attacks on its soil and, confused by the stealth signatures, fires on NATO as well. The United Kingdom is destroyed instantaneously. This escalates to a full-scale nuclear exchange between the United States, China, Russia, Saudi Arabia, New Rhodesia, and France. The world is a smoking ruin. As the radiation slowly declines over the next few million years, the wasteland left behind is left to the lichen.

Moral of the story? Stay away from Google's medical initiatives.

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by billforsternz on Wednesday October 29, 2014 @02:06AM (#8525808)
I am not necessarily convinced, but kudos for an imaginative, interesting, passionate contribution to the debate. With lots of nicely constructed details.
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by notahacker on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @04:05PM (#8523244)
Purely hypothetically: access to affordable medical insurance becomes contingent upon such a scan. You have a developing condition which will render you uninsurable.

I'm not suggesting Google would or even legally could consider creating a bidding system for insurance companies to use clean scans as a leadgen system, but in the unlikely event that they did feel so inclined, it wouldn't exactly be a wild departure from their business model

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by brandonb on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @04:16PM (#8523303)
The best thing about the Affordable Care Act is that it prohibits discrimination based on preexisting conditions. If a sick person applies for health insurance, the insurance company has to issue it, and the rate can only be set based on your age, smoking status, and location.
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by zo1 on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @05:52PM (#8523821)
So the entire risk pool/population has to bite the cost of the "previously uninsured"? Whether they want to or not? Sorry, nevermind that second question, it was rhetorical. Of course it doesn't matter if they want to or not, it's effectively a government mandated "tax". Taxes are almost never voluntary.
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by theworst on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @06:27PM (#8523995)
Yes, it makes sense if you think about that "tax" as the payment for the lottery ticket of a functioning body and brain.

Every person here won that lottery ticket, when we could have just as easily suffered from any number of horrible diseases and disorders. Not wanting to pay higher premiums b/c the "lotto losers" are included is like not wanting to pay for a lotto ticket after the fact because you know the rare outcome won't hit you.

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by dkrich on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @04:41PM (#8523461)
So because the current best option is grouping people based on imprecise risk factors like age, demographics, and hereditary problems, we should forever turn a blind eye to individual warning signs even if they could save our lives?

This is a depressingly pessimistic way of ignoring the real underlying problem: health care is too fucking expensive.

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by annamarie on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @04:11PM (#8523275)
Well, if google adds 20+ years to the avg life span, the whole insurance industry will need a massive revamp to keep up (already needed, IMHO).

I wonder what the actuaries think of this product.

Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by anigbrowl on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @04:55PM (#8523533)
You blow your nose and find a personalized advert in the tissue :)
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by _random_ on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @04:11PM (#8523273)
Yes, sending info straight to insurers/lenders.
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by bduerst on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @04:25PM (#8523354)
I doubt a company would jeopardize their reputation by doing that, and even if they did, the Affordable Care Act would prevent insurance companies from discriminating against you on your medical history or genetics.
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by xofer on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @04:39PM (#8523447)
The ACA, if left intact, would prevent companies from discriminating against you when they provide you with /health/ insurance. Life, disability, etc. not included.
Re:Google is developing cancer and heart attack detector by pgodzin on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @05:06PM (#8523584)
There's an incredible amount of regulation with health data/records that force companies to anonymize them and not allow them to sell it.