Re:We Are All Confident Idiots
by Dewie on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @07:12AM
(#8520355)
I swear this is HN's favourite bias to bring up on any topic relating to intelligence and aptitude.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:We Are All Confident Idiots
by bryanlarsen on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @08:28AM
(#8520567)
Not inappropriate to bring up when the author of the original article is Dunning, though
Personally it brings me comfort to remember that maybe just maybe I'm not as stupid and mediocre as I feel most of the time.
Re:We Are All Confident Idiots
by emotionalcode on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @07:22AM
(#8520382)
I think the Dunning Kruger effect has been a meme/cultural/conceptual construct long enough (like the measurement of intelligence) that we need to test for a Reverse Dunning Kruger effect, where knowledge of the Dunning Kruger Effect correlates with bias in self evaluation.
Knowing about the Dunning Kruger effect makes me more inclined to ask other people how good I am at something instead of relying on my own opinion. Which I think would make my evaluation more accurate.
Do you really think Michael Jordan needs to ask anyone in order to test his basketball skills? I'm fairly sure he doesn't do that and no matter people (some people) will tell him about this or that players being better, he firmly believe that he could win them in court, in his prime. IMHO Dunning-Kruger effect doesn't work if you reverse the claim.
or it might make you more selective about who you ask for feedback?