News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Breakthroughs that have unleashed AI development by diminoten on Monday October 27, 2014 @04:45PM (#8518068)
CS isn't going to stumble onto AI, someone's going to have to theorize about it first. Much like CS doesn't "stumble" onto new equations for modeling physics, CS isn't going to accidentally build an AI.

A generalist AI must be immensely difficult to create, but won't the most difficult part be the design? I don't think it'll be CS researchers coming up with the design, either -- it'll be doctors, biologists, neurologists, etc.

Re:Breakthroughs that have unleashed AI development by tachyonbeam on Monday October 27, 2014 @04:56PM (#8518134)
In my opinion, CS is going to provide the basic components (neural networks, computer vision, planning engines, knowledge bases) and engineers will put them together in a useful way. I think the reason CS hasn't provided AI yet is because general intelligence (as implemented in the human brain) is not one magic universal algorithm, it's an assembly of many necessary components, some of which are specialized for specific purposes.

The human brain was created ad hoc through evolution, and its complexity is beyond what "pure" CS usually deals with, which is algorithms that can be described in one page or less. Creating a self-aware AI is going to take engineering work, experimentation and incremental improvement, rather than someone inventing an overarching design and going "yes, that's it, that will produce self-awareness".

Re:Breakthroughs that have unleashed AI development by dominotw on Monday October 27, 2014 @05:22PM (#8518266)
I see that the term 'self-awareness' is being used a lot in this discussion. Can it be defined simply? Is it basically a mechanism which divides intelligence into two parts one of which is 'observing' the other ?
Re:Breakthroughs that have unleashed AI development by tachyonbeam on Monday October 27, 2014 @05:50PM (#8518393)
To me, self-awareness is, as I said before, having a model of the world that is complete enough that it incorporates a model of yourself within this world as well (and possibly other agents you encounter in this world). I guess I would add that the model should be sophisticated enough to be able to model your interactions with the world and make some sensible predictions about the future. I suppose according to this definition, a smart thermostat could be considered self-aware, but the bar for self-awareness goes up with the complexity of the interactions you can have with the world.
Re:Breakthroughs that have unleashed AI development by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @04:58AM (#8520028)
> Much like CS doesn't "stumble" onto new equations for modeling physics

Physicists come up with new equations for modeling physics. Metaphysicians make up elaborate reasons why they're actually intellectuals and not just on privileged-white-man welfare.