News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by tedunangst on Sunday October 26, 2014 @04:47PM (#8512343)
Will Uber be reimbursing the drivers for expenses since they apparently told the drivers it was legal?
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by trevyn on Sunday October 26, 2014 @05:01PM (#8512390)
http://www.phillymag.com/news/2014/10/26/uber-calls-ppa-uber...

"We fully stand behind our partners and will cover all costs associated with this deplorable charade."

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by tedunangst on Sunday October 26, 2014 @05:13PM (#8512455)
Thanks.

"Deplorable charade." Are they referring to their own actions? I mean "charade (n.) something that is done in order to pretend something is true when it is not really true." The PPA regulations are true, are they not? It's the legality of driving an UberX which is the charade, no?

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by toomuchtodo on Sunday October 26, 2014 @05:20PM (#8512491)
Perhaps the "deplorable charade" is the argument that PPA regulation isn't necessary in the mobility space? Or overbearing?

I don't much care for Uber's practices, but I agree with the argument that taxi medallions are rent-seeking and all efforts to break down senseless regulation of the taxi industry should take place. Note I said "senseless" regulation. You should still require insurance, background checks/driver's license verification or drivers, and so forth.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by akerl_ on Sunday October 26, 2014 @05:58PM (#8512644)
Whether it's necessary or not doesn't change the fact that Uber knew the current state of the laws and told their drivers they were operating legally.

It looks like Uber set up the situation so that these drivers could be martyrs in Uber's PR cause. Uber can now say "look, how terrible the PPA is, we shall defend our drivers from this injustice!". They score some PR points at the cost of massively affecting the drivers' lives.

The non-shitty way to accomplish their goal would have been for them to organize the people who wanted the laws to change and to actually participate in the political process, rather than trying to end-run the system by just moving in to town and setting up shop.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by toomuchtodo on Sunday October 26, 2014 @06:58PM (#8512862)
> The non-shitty way to accomplish their goal would have been for them to organize the people who wanted the laws to change and to actually participate in the political process, rather than trying to end-run the system by just moving in to town and setting up shop.

Unfortunately, Uber's process is much more likely to evoke change than "participating in the political process". Consumers are much more interested in the interests than your average voter.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by akerl_ on Sunday October 26, 2014 @07:07PM (#8512886)
If the average voter doesn't want the system to change, should it?

I'm not sure I'm fully a fan of derailing this thread into a discussion of the disconnect between progress and true democracy, but if we allow the minority of the population to override the majority's decision because we "know better" than them, are we still being democratic?

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by waterlesscloud on Sunday October 26, 2014 @07:22PM (#8512929)
I don't think that's derailing it at all. It's at the very core of my ambivalent feelings about companies like Uber and AirBNB.

There aren't great social injustices at work here, overheated rhetoric aside.

At worst there's run of the mill corruption. The concepts of what these kinds of regulation do are well-founded and something society has clearly wanted. The exact implementations may well have been corrupted, but the stated intent of the laws and regulations are in the public interest, and the public has been happy-ish with them.

Does that then mean the fix is to throw out the whole regimen of rules? For example, someone mentioned Seattle hasn't issued new medallions in decades. So the solution is to do away with medallions? Why not just issue more?

What about county level food safety inspectors? Many of those regulatory agencies are also corrupt. And don't even start with alcohol licensing. But should we "disrupt" those too? Just ignore them because there's some corruption in the system?

When you get down to it, none of these companies want to increase consumer choice. In their perfect world, they'd be the only choice. So it's hard to accept they're really out for the public good.

And that makes it really difficult for me to cheer them on as they pick and choose which laws they accept as valid expressions of the people's will.

The people aren't really being given a vote here. Well, actually, they have been given a vote, and these companies are choosing to ignore it for their own benefit.

As I said, it's not some great social injustice at stake. Civil Rights leaders broke the law with greater purposes in mind than "So my company can be valued in the billions".

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by malandrew on Sunday October 26, 2014 @07:16PM (#8512910)
Once the number of people using these P2P economy services reaches a critical mass, shouldn't voting with their dollars by using these services be seen indirectly as a vote supporting these changes?

Furthermore, there is absolutely no indication that the status quo is the "majority's decision". These days, which regulatory capture, the revolving door and pork barreling, it's pretty much impossible to tell what laws were passed because it's the majority decision and which were favors traded among members congress to support the interests of their biggest donors.

We have at best a quasi-democratic system; i.e. just enough democracy to maintain an illusion of a functioning democracy.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by toomuchtodo on Sunday October 26, 2014 @07:39PM (#8512993)
> I'm not sure I'm fully a fan of derailing this thread into a discussion of the disconnect between progress and true democracy, but if we allow the minority of the population to override the majority's decision because we "know better" than them, are we still being democratic?

The majority of the population (I speak US-centric here, as I'm a US citizen) wasn't for same-sex marriage nor healthcare reform, yet we "knew better" to enact both.

> If the average voter doesn't want the system to change, should it?

Yes. We should never cater to the lowest common denominator.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by akerl_ on Sunday October 26, 2014 @08:05PM (#8513086)
This logic works really well until you consider that everybody thinks that they're the ones who "know better".

Historically, there haven't been many vocal groups who thought they were on the wrong side of the cause they were championing.

How does society tell the difference between non-majority groups who are actually right and non-majority groups who just think they are?

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by Dylan16807 on Monday October 27, 2014 @01:26AM (#8514016)
>minority of the population to override the majority's decision

That doesn't sound like a good description. The largest group doesn't care one way or the other, and should probably be excluded from the decision.

If some arbitrary issue has 80% uncaring, 15% for, 5% against, I would say it should definitely happen.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by tedunangst on Sunday October 26, 2014 @07:24PM (#8512934)
At a minimum, Uber could have advised the drivers that they were engaging in civil disobedience. They appear to have resorted to conscripting protesters.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by swartkrans on Sunday October 26, 2014 @06:02PM (#8512656)
If you pay someone to commit a crime, doesn't that make you criminally liable as well? How are they going to reimburse someone for being caught breaking the law? That seems less than sane.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by fiatmoney on Sunday October 26, 2014 @06:30PM (#8512759)
It's unclear if it's a criminal case (my guess is no). It is relatively common to indemnify partners against civil penalties.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by baddox on Sunday October 26, 2014 @06:37PM (#8512780)
If you legislate and enforce a law that is harmful to society, does that make you criminally liable?
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by swartkrans on Sunday October 26, 2014 @07:55PM (#8513055)
Crime is a function of law, an action is only a crime if it breaks the law. So no legislating the law by lawfully elected individuals is not a crime. This is true even if you disagree with the laws that were written. I will be candid and share with you that I think what you asked is a stupid question on multiple levels. I assume you're riled up whenever the government does its job of governing, which yes, involves enforcing the law and taking things from people, like their freedom and or property.

There's a democratic process in place in our country that allows you to help decide who is in power, if you're unhappy with who is in power become more involved in elections.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by baddox on Sunday October 26, 2014 @08:26PM (#8513156)
It's not so simple. I'm not aware of all the laws that would apply in this particular case, which is why I asked the question, but I know that in many jurisdictions there are laws against abuse of power and corruption. If a political official were to explicitly say "I am supporting Proposition X because it will return some benefit to my benefactors," would that not be a criminal offense? Granted, it's well-accepted that such is the norm in politics, but I don't think that means that it's not criminal. Many politicians have been charged with crimes like abuse of official capacity, bribery, and fraud, for similar actions.

I disagree with and resent both your claim that my question is stupid and your claim that the recourse for a broken political system is becoming more involved in elections.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by swartkrans on Sunday October 26, 2014 @10:37PM (#8513492)
Corruption is illegal, but that isn't what you asked. I take back what I said about it being stupid though, I've given it more thought since then, and I was stupid for saying it was stupid. It's actually an interesting question.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by runeks on Sunday October 26, 2014 @07:51PM (#8513041)
Only if your intent is to cause harm, I would say.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by ripb on Sunday October 26, 2014 @05:03PM (#8512403)
Strong statement and fair play to them for standing behind their operators.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by morganvachon on Sunday October 26, 2014 @05:05PM (#8512410)
It's a strong statement, yes. But will they follow through? They've screwed their drivers over many times in the past.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by ripb on Sunday October 26, 2014 @06:04PM (#8512665)
Out of interest, could you give examples?

Because abandoning Uber operators at a time of transition, or industry revolution as it could be called, would in many ways undermine its expansion if potential operators have abandonment to fear.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by Dylan16807 on Monday October 27, 2014 @01:51AM (#8514067)
Yeah, most of those are uber screwing over drivers.

Except the one you quoted, which really confuses me. It's not uber's fault if demand is low in a particular location. Heck, that's actually a pretty good rate, full-time minimum wage for only doing a ride every two hours.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by morganvachon on Monday October 27, 2014 @07:08AM (#8514799)
The reason I included that one is because Uber pushes the fantasy that you can make enough money in a weekend of driving to replace your full time job. The reality is that competition is fierce, especially in larger markets, and unless you're a reckless, aggressive driver you'll never make enough in a full week to pay for the brand new car they require you to drive along with a living wage.

Basically, you end up an indentured servant, getting pennies on the dollar.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by ripb on Sunday October 26, 2014 @09:16PM (#8513289)
Very interesting, thank you very much.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by morganvachon on Sunday October 26, 2014 @05:04PM (#8512409)
That was the first thing that came to my mind too. The more I read about Uber, the more I dislike them. And it's really just that company I don't like; I think the idea of taxi alternatives like Uber and Lyft is a good one, but Uber has shown several times that they don't give a shit about their drivers, their riders, or the law. I see other companies like Lyft, who seem to be playing by the rules and treating their drivers and riders with respect, as the future of this industry.
[deleted]
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by rblatz on Sunday October 26, 2014 @05:06PM (#8512415)
So yes?
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by jacquesm on Sunday October 26, 2014 @04:51PM (#8512355)
Is that a rhetorical question?
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by sillysaurus3 on Sunday October 26, 2014 @05:06PM (#8512414)
I had the same question, for what it's worth. Why make someone feel dumb for asking?

I wonder if HN would benefit from a guideline like, "If someone asks a question whose answer seems obvious, try to answer it in a straightforward way. For example, 'You really don't know what 2+2 is?' can be shortened to '2+2 is 4.'"

There are interesting followup questions on this topic, too. If Uber won't reimburse them, why not? On the other hand, would it even be legal for Uber to reimburse them, since Uber is doing so with the intent of "transferring" the penalty of the law from the driver to Uber? One reason to have laws is so that their penalties act as a deterrent. If Uber is preventing the deterrent from having an effect, then perhaps the legal system might take a dim view of this. Whether that'd be punishable, I have no idea; the point is simply that there are many interesting questions that can be derived from the starting point of "Will Uber be reimbursing the drivers?"

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by jacquesm on Sunday October 26, 2014 @05:08PM (#8512433)
That's not meant to make him/her feel dumb, it is an honest question.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by sillysaurus3 on Sunday October 26, 2014 @05:11PM (#8512445)
Oh. My apologies.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by tedunangst on Sunday October 26, 2014 @05:14PM (#8512462)
Not entirely. I certainly expected the answer to be "no", but I was surprised.