(Sidenote: you know you have been in Japan too long when you spell it colorrary and wonder why the spellchecker flags it. sigh)
I've been trying to get them to do the same with phone/Internet service - my Comcast is about half as much as their Verizon because I'm on a promotional 1 year subscription. Hell, just quitting FIOS, using dialup for a month, and then buying the exact same subscription they already have would save them $10-15/month.
Similar perverse incentives are at work in the job market (you usually get much better offers by changing jobs) and the housing market (apartments tend to jack up the rents as much as possible on existing tenants while offering move-in specials to new tenants). And people wonder why there's no loyalty in America anymore...
Edit: Sorry for being direct? Let me be more cautious:
It's plausible that, under the proposed pricing regime, the 9 year retention rate for customers would rise more than enough to offset the higher margins enjoyed today at the current retention rate.
It's been one of my gripes about business for a long time that they offer more attractive options to people who aren't their customers than they do for people who have been their customers for a while.
So, now that I'm running my first bits of advertising for my consulting/I.T. business, I put a "10% off your next invoice" coupon in the flyer -- for my existing clients.
After all, if it weren't for my existing clients, I couldn't afford to be advertising for new ones.
Remember that [regular business] customers [with opportunity to go elsewhere] who get things cheaper will always want them at that rate though - we paid you £360 last time, why should we pay £400 now?
I don't think most of my existing clients will expect me to continue offering a discounted rate. I've had several of them even tell me that I really ought to be charging a lot more.
Is there a word for this? Is it simply an inability to empathize (i.e., to see the world from the company's point-of-view) or is there a larger fallacy at work (e.g., a belief that the world operates according to some standard of fairness)?
Look at it this way: let's pretend an accident (regardless of fault) actually lowered the chances of a subsequent accident (maybe you're scared into good driving), and the longer you drove without an accident, the more likely you are to have one (maybe you become complacent or something). In this situation, your rates would go down when you got in an accident. Because it's not that they're trying to punish you, but rather they're trying to just charge based on the X% chance you're going to be in an accident, plus Y% overhead/profit.
An example might be the very common rear-end shunt at a roundabout (or "circle" in South Africa, not sure if you have 'em in the US) - an experienced driver will [usually] pull away confidently without hesitating. A less experienced driver can misjudge more often and set off only to suddenly stop, leaving the car behind to crash into them. Strictly road-lore says the rear driver should have observed better, they are liable as they crashed into a [near] stationary vehicle - but the foremost driver is hardly without blame. Yes, the rear vehicles insurance pays out for all damage; but the insurer of the front vehicle would be right in judging them a greater insurance _risk_.
It doesn't always work (some good drivers will just get unlucky and be hit by cars they can't avoid) but that's a rough version of a rationale.
The churn among 9 year customers is miniscule and, to the extent it happens, is largely out of your control.
(They've successfully resisted all temptation to quit for NINE YEARS. Crikey, your commercial relationship is already more stable than many marriages . Typical events precipitating a cancellation sound less like "Found a better deal" and more like "I'm moving outside your service area" or "Dear Comcast: Dad died, please cancel his subscription.")
Thus, offering 100% of 9-year customers a discount to influence a fraction of a sliver of those customers (the number who are seriously considering cancellation who could be motivated to not cancel if they were offered a better price) is just throwing money away.