News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by sz4kerto on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:21AM (#8491991)
Some background.

- the proposed rate is 150 HUF/GB, that's around 0.5 EUR/GB or 60 cents/GB.

- the internet speeds in Hungary are relatively high, it's quite common to get 100 Mbps for $20/mo

- the minimum wage is around 250 USD/mo, the average net wage is $650/mo

- the levy should be paid by the providers, but probably they're going to be able to deduct it from their other taxes, that means profitable companies won't pay, currently non-profitable companies will

- the tax will be capped per subscription, the cap is rumored to be around $4 for individuals and around $25 for companies -- but most households have 2-3-4 phones, cable internet, etc.

- it's very likely that this is going to wipe out the currently loss-making telcos that can then be bought by the state (nationalized) and their assets funneled to cronies (even there was a public bid for the assets nobody would start a new company as it'd be making losses in the beginning therefore they could not deduct this tax from their taxes -- so it'd result in even more losses)

Also, it's very much likely that this is a deliberate distraction from the political conflict between the USA and Hungary that has emerged last week. (Edit: it's still bad though, as a journalist put it, it's like spraying pepper in the eyes of a pitbull: it's distracting, but you might end up in a really big trouble.)

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by netcan on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @06:57AM (#8492168)
The problem is not necessarily directly the tax, but the barriers and bureaucracy around it making the whole industry less dynamic. $4 per household is not in itself terrible. The cronyism is also a concern.

The reason policies like this are viable politically is because public policy economists are far more comfortable estimating the direct effects of a tax than they are estimating some of the murkier, but nonetheless inevitable implications. 1st year microeconomics students learn to draw the supply and demand curves, draw in the price after tax and calculate lost consumer surplus and profits. It's core economics material.

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by pentium10 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:23AM (#8491994)
internet speeds in Hungary are not so high. Look at east Romania what offers, you get 1GBps for 7 euro/mo.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by sz4kerto on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @05:30AM (#8492010)
Romania is really an outlier -- but compared to the USA or the UK, Hungary still fares very well (a cheap 100 Mbps internet basically 'should be enough for anyone' -- not completely true, but that can serve multiple 4K video streams at the same time, so for most households it's perfect).
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by Ecio78 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @06:07AM (#8492078)
I am paying 50euro/month for 30Mbit/10Mbit Fiber in Luxembourg :/ In Italy I was paying about 25-30Euro/month for 20Mbit/1Mbit ADSL (and actually 20 was never 20 but more around 12-15..
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by wil421 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:15AM (#8492308)
Do people actually have multiple 4k montiors and multiple streaming services to serve content to those devices?

I pay about $40 for 50Mb/15Mb and there is barely anything I can do to max this out.

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by scrollaway on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:33AM (#8492370)
Please remember that not everyone lives in a household of one. A household hosting say, six independent people can easily cap a 100Mbps connection.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by mrottenkolber on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @01:05PM (#8493647)
I was living in a household of ten heavy internet users on a 18Mbit/s line. The only times we had trouble was due to our service provider (outages, severe packet loss). This included mostly games and streaming.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by wil421 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:20AM (#8492537)
I live with 3 people and unless someone is downloading a torrent there is no way netflix/hulu/youtube playing at once is going to cap 50Mb or 100Mb.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by scrollaway on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @10:29AM (#8492845)
How about a group of 4 friends who buy a game on steam together and want to download it and try it out together? That can easily be 30 gigabytes that has to be downloaded by 4 people, capping the connection over a sustained amount of time.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by qq66 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @11:35AM (#8493162)
Sure, but does any public policy need to be directed towards this use case, or the six simultaneous Netflix streams? I would think that increasing Internet adoption by 1% would have more tangible gains than increasing speed by tenfold, once you are at figures like 5 or 10 Mbps.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by ericd on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @12:19PM (#8493393)
Yes, because there are many use cases which will crop up once internet speeds aren't so constrained in so many places. If you could download very large files very quickly in almost every location, I'm fairly sure that computing would change rather dramatically.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by scrollaway on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @01:13PM (#8493706)
Think of it this way.

What do you think would have more effect on the world: Increasing processing power 100-fold, or increasing desktop usage by 1% of the entire world population? How about 10-fold and 5%? I can guarantee you it's the former.

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by jimmaswell on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @02:40PM (#8494328)
download it once and copy over the files locally
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by zoner on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @04:10PM (#8494838)
You don't probably do torrent or just ignoring the fact that the vast majority of internet traffic globally is peer to peer traffic between dynamic IP addresses, so clearly torrent.

It's more true in case of Hungary where the minimum wage is around 250 EUR and people have a relatively luxury broadband speed, need (and addict) for car and historically good in pirating content since the world invented the VCR.

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by NicoJuicy on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @06:38AM (#8492134)
"Fun" fact: the reason why internet is cheap / fast is because of the webcam industry in Romania.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by hippiehippo on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @07:11AM (#8492194)
TL;DR: BitTorrent being the reason doesn't sound so interesting for a Vice article.

As a person who helped build a "district ISP network" back in the early 2000s, I can tell you that that reason is just some Vice.com style linkbait.

Romania has great Internet speeds because the authorities tolerated us installing cables all over the darn place. Back then it wasn't uncommon to have almost half a dozen ISPs in a one square mile neighbourhood, all offering 50-100 mbps in the city and 1-2 mbps actual Internet speeds, without any FUP.

We were almost the same age and people didn't care about the low international speeds because we could all share movies and music at 50+ mbps (and 0.5 mbps was more than enough for browsing).

This was happening way before the video chat industry took off. Also, for that kind of stuff you need good sustained upload, but the ISPs are still limiting the upload speed to around 30 mbps even for gigabit connections. This doesn't affect BitTorrent (which can be left open over night).

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by NicoJuicy on Thursday October 23, 2014 @03:16AM (#8497028)
According to http://www.itu.int/ITU-D/treg/broadband/BB_MDG_Romania_BBCOM... , there was only a broadband penetration rate of 5,5% . Perhaps some of the Vice article are lies, but probably not all of them.. As bittorrent doesn't generate as much money as the webcam industry...

Could be, it's just "believing" that the article isn't a whole lie.

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by WalterBright on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @03:34PM (#8494631)
A very interesting counterexample to the notion that telcos are a "natural monopoly" because of the problem of laying wires.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by paganel on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @06:48AM (#8492155)
I'm not so sure about that. Source: I'm Romanian. The best and most accurate explanation that I could find after a quick search was this one: http://np.reddit.com/r/europe/comments/2ct58s/average_intern...

""" tl;dr Romanians love movies, we needed a way to download them and fiber was the answer. Much cheaper than copper, no risk of the cables getting stolen. """

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by shock on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @01:19PM (#8493750)
Spotted: Python programmer ^^^
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by alandarev on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @07:46AM (#8492253)
I can tell you for sure, why Lithuania has fibre and 4G across country.

Most EU money are invested into country's infrastructure, there were lots of debates whether it is wise, as infrastructure by itself does not boost production. I can just assume that Romania and many other East Europe countries did the same.. It is not cheap at all to fiber up whole conutry, but when you have "free" money to spend, it suddenly becomes an attractive laundering option.

In my opinion, saying that country X has fast internet because users desire is a wild guess and only. I am sure Americans love watching video and skype'ing too.

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by PeterisP on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:36AM (#8492612)
I'd attribute it to the lack of pre-entrenched cable TV service.

If you want to connect a home, then the expensive part is laying the cables. If you've put in copper already, then putting in fiber is expensive; but if you're putting in a cable now (or recently) then putting fiber instead of (or in addition to) copper is cheap.

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by dzhiurgis on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @04:52PM (#8495053)
Stop talking shit.

4G coverage is not across the country, although not too bad, but its only one provider. Look at 4G coverage in Sweden.

EU money was used to fund RAIN and RAIN2 projects - connect the main cities and then rent out the lines to ISPs.

The (Swedish) monopolist ISP had reasonably smart CEO who realised that laying last mile in fiber costs same as laying it copper, but you'll lock-in your users for decades, no competition will ever be able to compete with that.

And the main reason of cheap fiber installation was fact that majority of people live in blocked houses, so population density is really high. Now look at households in US - massive houses, separated by massive land. One US house is probably equal to 20-30 Lithuanian families.

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by plainOldText on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @12:56PM (#8493591)
I think it's actually the other way around: The reason webcam industry has become popular, is because the internet service offers excellent speeds.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by ciupicri on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:51AM (#8492431)
No, it's cheap because it was designed that way. People were poor and the wild West like environment let us build cheap infrastructure using plain copper based Ethernet.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by MrJagil on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @06:42AM (#8492142)
source?
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by cbg0 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @06:08AM (#8492079)
12.45 EUR actually with VAT, assuming you just buy the Internet connection, and not as part of a package.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by butterbeer on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:57AM (#8492451)
Are there data caps? Also, how is the upload speed?
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by sbalea on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @01:40PM (#8493893)
No data caps, 100mbps in network, 30mbps upload speed to the internet at large.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by ionelm on Thursday October 23, 2014 @05:26AM (#8497314)
> Also, it's very much likely that this is a deliberate distraction from the political conflict between the USA and Hungary that has emerged last week.

Strange theory. Have you considered they just need the extra money? Also, it wouldn't be a huge distraction anyway (from whatever) - I'm pretty sure they could invent more revolting taxes if they wanted to.

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by topppk on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @07:06AM (#8492183)
what you're referring to as 250USD/mo is basically unemployment benefits. i've got no idea where you got $650/mo from though.

-the minimum wage in hungary is actually 328 EUR (~430 USD) / month in 2014

https://www.google.hu/search?q=minimum+wage+in+hungary

-the average wage in hungary for full-time employed people was actually ~975USD / month in the first half of 2014.

http://www.vg.hu/gazdasag/makrogazdasag/ennyi-az-atlagber-ma...

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by sz4kerto on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @07:22AM (#8492212)
$650/mo is the avg. wage _after tax_ (around 150kHUF) -- I should have mentioned that. You're absolutely right that I got the minimum wage wrong (I meant net minimum wage though).
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by SilasX on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @02:27PM (#8494237)
You did mention it: "the average net wage is $650/mo"; I assumed "net wage" meant "wage after taxes". There's no star to indicate that this phrasing is the result of a later edit.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by sz4kerto on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @03:17PM (#8494541)
Oops, you're right. I assumed that the grandparent is right and I made a mistake without looking at my original post. Well, lack of self-confidence :) (I didn't edit that part of the original post.)