At the end of the day the "Startup" world is the world of finance, and I think the explosive crop of high risk private equity (Angel, VC, hedge) investors are trying to get as many "makers" into it as possible.
Whether this is good for the new entrants or not is too early to tell. I think it probably is when compared to the alternatives, but my guess is that I am missing something.
It's also interesting. I don't think I'd have gotten much out of the class as an undergrad, but a decade later, I'm learning a lot from this lecture series. Among the things I've learned: I probably don't want to start a startup; I'd rather focus on great products and execution in my field.
I view it as more in line with the Graham/Buffett school of giving back as you go. PG (not BG) has an academic bent, and academics like share what they've learned.
Thank you, YC. It's a worthwhile course.
what most investors mean here is not to obsess over small differences in valuation (most good investors don't do this either, but some do).
In my experience, terms with lots of if-then conditionals are the most common flag. The last "messy" term sheet I saw had an unusually long diligence period. Predictably, the investor "found" a bunch of problems at the 11th hour and pulled out, leaving the startup in a financial lurch.
Anything that differs from standard docs should be _highly_ suspect, assuming you can get ahold of some.
As a lower bound, I've never seen terms presented on Shark Tank that weren't off-the-wall insane. :D
> How would a first time founder tell the difference?
By talking to other founders, advisors, and their attorneys. This book was useful when I was approaching the first term sheets I ever saw: http://www.amazon.com/Term-Sheets-Valuations-Intricacies-Big...
I 100% agree with you (and I have such contacts to help me out), but I lament the fact that many founders will lack such contacts to give them a sanity check. Perhaps one can reach out to people about it, but without a preexisting network to tap, I am afraid that many will simply accept the bogus terms rather than deal with the discomfort of reaching out for help.
As an aside, I think it's really hard to get clean terms when you're outside silicon valley... I had a friend raise money in Utah recently and he was saddled with all sorts of strangeness. (board for a $200k seed investment, etc.)
Another startup hub advantage.
Which is the whole point. I was told point blank by Cooley that no one outside of the valley will ever do SAFE because it is different.
They also will never do post money options pools which are what YC seems to push for.
So good luck everyone else (myself included).
Thanks for this great lecture series, it is very helpful!!
The best VCs have extremely simple, straightforward terms. I've seen a term sheet from a top tier VC that was just half a page long with no bs in the share purchase agreement either.
There are some seriously unscrupulous investors out there. If any terms give you cause for concern, get second, third and fourth opinions from independents.
http://ecorner.stanford.edu/authorMaterialInfo.html?mid=3301
There seems to be a dangerous line between taking a good deal as offered and getting nailed by a bad deal. It's easy for the VC to say "don't sweat the terms", they are setting the terms after all. The advice makes sense if you're working with a top tier firm that has a reputation to protect, but it seems like it could be quite dangerous when applied to lower tier VCs?