News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Debunking the Duct Tape Programmer by pvg on Monday September 28, 2009 @11:03AM (#848552)
Joel Spolsky, like all frequent writers, can be full of a great deal of hot air but the case study in his piece is 'a guy who was instrumental in writing and shipping the first widely usable web browser'. The 'debunking' is supported by someone's comment on twitter and a reference to a guy who writes books rather than software. Spolsky might have oversimplified, glossed intricacies over but you're hardly going to refute his point by oversimplifying further, digging through your tweets or summoning the persuasive power of a popular methodology to your aid. Because, you know, the other guy wrote Netscape.
Re:Debunking the Duct Tape Programmer by LSalin on Monday September 28, 2009 @02:41PM (#848941)
Kent Beck and Robert C. Martin are both programmers. They don't just "write books rather than software" so their input is valuable. On the other hand, this blog post was written by by someone employed by a software consultancy company that prides itself from their Agile practices. So I can hardly blame him for defending his employer's practices.
Re:Debunking the Duct Tape Programmer by rdrimmie on Monday September 28, 2009 @08:10PM (#849513)
The article includes a quote "never take software advice from a bug tracking system salesman", and I think the same entertaining aphorism holds true for methodology consultants.

Both have too much invested in you listening to their advice.