News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Should people be eating more fat? by bane on Monday October 20, 2014 @11:33AM (#8482614)
Yes. Animal fats particularly. We know from the fossil record and studies of traditional societies that even bone marrow (high and dense in fat and calories) is prized. Science shows it to be unbelievably rich in all sorts of good stuff.

There are some theories out there that modern human brain development was strongly tied to the ability of early humans to make tools to successful extract as much marrow out of an animal carcass as possible. It's basically the raw building blocks brains are made out of. Plus it increases wound regeneration and boosts your immune system.

The science of nutrition is so stunningly complex and difficult that lots of notions about what to eat and not eat have been overturned time and time again. The only thing that seems to have held out is to eat a wide variety of foods from all sources. Limit sugars and sweet things, eat lots of fiber, protein and fats. Cook in butter if you need to use oil. It's better for you and it tastes better.

Traditional societies actually do a pretty god job on many of these fronts. There's some things they screwed up on, nitrates aren't real good for you, but limited amounts of alcohol is. Yogurt is great for you, but Bracken (Fernbrake) turns out to not be so great an idea. Many traditional diets are usually rich in variety, and many of the good things you should be eating, and usually don't have too many of the things you shouldn't be eating. Don't confuse traditional with customary. A customary full-English breakfast every day is something north of 1,000 calories, but there's not much reason to assume it's a good traditional foodstuff. It turns out oatmeal with some fruit is probably better for you.

If in doubt, variety variety variety. As evolved opportunistic omnivores, our bodies are superbly evolved to eat a little bit of just about everything, but don't do so well on lots of one kind of thing. Humans are one of the few species on the planet that can do what we do, and it turns out, just like with any animal, that we kind of have to do what we do to live right.

Re:Should people be eating more fat? by applecore on Monday October 20, 2014 @12:06PM (#8482821)
Interesting theory regarding bone marrow consumption and early human brain development... Can you recommend any articles or research on the topic to learn more?
Re:Should people be eating more fat? by bane on Monday October 20, 2014 @12:26PM (#8482970)
In terms of modern science, we know marrow can have direct impact on neuron development in adults.

http://www.foh.dhhs.gov/NYCU/BoneMarrow.asp

Earlier scientific work has shown that bone marrow cells can enter the mouse brain and produce new neurons. However, the new study is the first to show that this phenomenon can occur in the human brain. The study appears in the January 20, 2003, online early edition of the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences1.

http://www.ninds.nih.gov/news_and_events/news_articles/press...

http://www.pnas.org/content/100/4/2088.full

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/08/140808110709.ht...

In terms of archaeological record and Early Man

http://www.bbc.co.uk/nature/life/Homo

Tooled up But around two million years ago, telltale cut marks on the surface of animal bones reveal that early humans were using crude stone tools to smash open the bones and extract the marrow. Stone tools allowed early Homo to get at a food source that no other creature was able to obtain - bone marrow. Bone marrow contains long chain fatty acids that are vital for brain growth and development. This helped further fuel the increase in brain size, allowing our ancestors to make more complex tools.

The tools made by habilis are called 'Oldowan tools'. The process used to make these tools was incredibly simple. Hominids picked up one stone, known as a core and broke it with another, known as a hammerstone or percussor. This gave them a sharp cutting edge that could pass through an animal's hide.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V2YMfzhm8ao

Some of the oldest stone tool use we've discovered appears to be tied into marrow extraction by pre-human species about 3.4 million years ago. Long enough for evolutionary forces to have a major impact.

http://www.nature.com/ejcn/journal/v56/n12/full/1601646a.htm...

Another fruitful line of evidence for early hominid diets is from analogy with modern humans, rather than other living primates. In a recent paper Cordain et al, (2001) also argue that the observed increased brain size through time in the Homo line requires the consumption of animal products. They point out that there are two essential fatty acids, docsahexaenoic and arachidonic, that are essential to brain development in modern humans, and the best sources of these two fatty acids are bone marrow, and particularly ruminant brains. Therefore, the consumption of these animal products would have facilitated expansion in brain size and increased cranial capacity over the long term. Similar arguments regarding omega-3 fatty acids are presented by Chamberlain (1996, 1998).

There's tons more. It's pretty well researched and the hypothesis is generally accepted.

There's a documentary somewhere that demonstrates marrow extraction with recreations of millions year old stone tools. There's some co-evolution arguments about the orientation of our hands and the size and strength of human triceps (designed to hold and smash), but I can't find the papers on those right now.

Re:Should people be eating more fat? by smartial_arts on Thursday October 23, 2014 @08:06PM (#8501436)
The bone marrow studies look at implanted, not orally consumed material.

Just in case anybody assumes "If I eat more bone marrow I'll get new brain cells built from the cells I eat".

Re:Should people be eating more fat? by applecore on Tuesday October 21, 2014 @04:20PM (#8489675)
Thank you.