Re:Bilingual brains: Variety makes you mentally fit
by emgeee on Friday October 17, 2014 @07:38PM
(#8473993)
I might not be so much about the language but about the paradigm. Certainly going from Java to C++ might not be that different but through in something like Haskell and you almost have to entirely rethink your solution.
Re:Bilingual brains: Variety makes you mentally fit
by josu on Friday October 17, 2014 @08:11PM
(#8474103)
One thing is setting your logic to follow a certain way of thinking, and a completely different thing is the language you are using to think.
Furthermore, programming languages are written in English. A real language cannot be written in another language.
I'm not a linguist nor a programmer, but I'm trilingual, and I have scripted at a basic level. And honestly, although I see the resemblance, I don't think that programming languages and real languages work the same way.
Re:Bilingual brains: Variety makes you mentally fit
by blalabro on Friday October 17, 2014 @10:26PM
(#8474421)
I'm trilingual (Spanish,French,German) and program fluently in at least 3 languages (Python, Javascript, PHP).
Things in common: You build an idea in the air and shoot it in the language. Happens to me a lot in German where I don't have a vocabulary as wide as Spanish on English that the brain will have to build a sentence maybe 30% longer but it will eventually bring out something that does the job. When I'm coding I just know the program needs to do certain thing. Python is very straightforward while with PHP usually I need to build some auxiliary function (same as German , not that the word doesn't exist but I don't have it in my Head at the moment). Also, very obscure concepts like "Dativ" conjugation do exist in spanish but since it looks the same as "Genitiv" and "Akkusativ" , nobody pays to much attention. However when you are speaking German you'd better understand that as you need them to correctly build a sentence of the fly. An example analogy with coding would be generic data structures like arrays in PHP but in Python are more rich like Lists, Dictionaries and Tuples(IMHO)
Re:Bilingual brains: Variety makes you mentally fit
by estebank on Saturday October 18, 2014 @06:22AM
(#8475069)
You're not trilingual, as you also speak English :)
Re:Bilingual brains: Variety makes you mentally fit
by collyw on Saturday October 18, 2014 @06:59AM
(#8475109)
I agree. I notice that when I do imperative programming, I think through a sequence of steps, usually writing them down on paper if there is any complexity. When I "think in SQL" I read out the "from" and "where" clause in my head (or out loud). There is definitely a verbal element in my SQL thinking.
Re:Bilingual brains: Variety makes you mentally fit
by jimmaswell on Friday October 17, 2014 @11:09PM
(#8474498)
>As far as I know, people don't think in Python or C. I would say that a programming language is like math.
Are you saying people don't think in math? They definitely do
As far as I know, people don't think in Python or C. I would say that a programming language is like math. You can use it as a plugin in your language, but you still need the main program which is your language.