There are lots of reasons to buy a new car. I drive a new car every three years, so I lease. Fiscally, the decision to drive a new car every three years is about the worst decision you can make. I make that decision in the light of day though. I'm able to afford it, and we still maintain a household savings rate of 30%. Yes, I could increase that savings percentage even more by paying cash for a car and driving it in to the ground, but I choose not to. I choose the luxury of a new car in spite of its fiscal downsides.
Or you could argue, education is correlated with higher income, so educate people, increase their income, and hope that their abilities go up as well.
Not sure if we're disagreeing or agreeing here, but all I am saying the problem isn't always as easy as, let's just give poor people more money and education. Problem solved.
At some point we'll have to recognized these difference in people, but it's embedded deeply in our culture that everyone is created equal. Which to be honest, I love.
So if we could very quickly call something an attack on in-out group psychology (you know, like aggressive branding, or professional sports, or so called amateur sports, or much of political discourse or ...), maybe it makes it easier to sway people to resist it.
I guess if you figure out the right package, you do better than when you wave your hands around and mumble incoherently.
For financing, a first step is to point out that the real cost is often hidden in the length of the contract.
I have a friend who is pretty well educated in a non stem field and is decently successful (lower middle class).
We both drive the same car that is currently worth 9k (a car which he shouldn't have gotten either, but I digress).
We spent an hour the other day debating why he shouldn't buy a brand new 22k car that will save him 900 per year on gas.
For the life of me I just couldn't get him to see why the best decision financially was to drive his current car into the ground.
His argument was literally, in 10 years my new car will be worth more than yours. I was dumbfounded - I could not get him to see that it was coming at a cost of an additional 13k up front. He said it in a "haha got you! - you forgot about that!" kind of way.
I just gave up.
At what point do we just admit that no matter the education level, no matter the background, some actors in the economy just won't make the most prudent choice?