Re:After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdos...
by kristofferR on Thursday October 16, 2014 @06:42PM
(#8468297)
I agree with you that many people think that way. Or more accurately = don't think.
> But my point here is simply to explain why arguing about these issues based on rational consistency or benefit/harm calculations is so often unproductive.
What else can the proponents of change do? How can you change the thinking of people with a framework based on not thinking? Are you suggesting that irrational arguments would be more effective?
So if you're the sort of person whose inclination or upbringing leads you to strongly honor your elders and their ideals, it's not a matter of "irrational circular argument". It's not even a matter of "argument" at all: proper morals and laws aren't based on reason, but on received wisdom. In this view, Moses wasn't supposed to ask, "Why not covet my neighbor's house?" It's enough to simply be told what is wrong and what's not.
Once again, I personally do not think that way, and I'm sure that I'm misrepresenting the perspective of folks who do in multiple ways. But my point here is simply to explain why arguing about these issues based on rational consistency or benefit/harm calculations is so often unproductive.