News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdos... by kristofferR on Thursday October 16, 2014 @12:10AM (#8463317)
You're forgetting alcohol. You can't argue that society considers drug use immoral when the drug alcohol is legal and widely used.

Sure, it's a legal drug, but it's certainly a drug. If it's the illegality of the other drugs that makes society consider it immoral then that's a completely irrational circular argument.

"Illegal drugs are bad because they are illegal, therefore they are immoral and that's why they should be illegal" is basically what they think, without realizing it. It's not "reasonably sensible within their framework" at all, it's insane.

Re:After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdos... by ubiquit on Thursday October 16, 2014 @12:51AM (#8463421)
When you subscribe to the framework that the laws should reflect moral values, inevitably your law reflects your religion.

The law's stance that alcohol is okay is silly to an empiricist, but not surprising.

Re:After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdos... by thomasfl on Thursday October 16, 2014 @03:25AM (#8463794)
...and coffee! Coffee is the elephant in the room. Caffeine is the worlds the world's most widely consumed psychoactive drug. It doesn't cause much harm because it's normally used in low doses.

I admit I am addicted to the stuff, and find it hard to quit.

Re:After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdos... by Natsu on Thursday October 16, 2014 @12:20AM (#8463336)
> You're forgetting alcohol. You can't argue that society considers drug use immoral when the drug alcohol is legal and widely used.

And you're forgetting that they did, in fact, try to ban it for those very reasons...

Re:After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdos... by beedogs on Thursday October 16, 2014 @01:35AM (#8463518)
...and that they learned absolutely nothing from that stupid little adventure.
Re:After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdos... by greeneggs on Thursday October 16, 2014 @02:19AM (#8463635)
People aren't stupid. They learned from Prohibition that it is hard to ban a drug once it is legal and established. Hence the reluctance now to legalize marijuana. If it turns out to be a mistake, it will be hard to roll it back. That seems like an honest and fair argument to me, even if one might disagree.
Re:After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdos... by biehl on Thursday October 16, 2014 @06:17AM (#8464182)
But it is not the argument one usually hears from probihitionists...
Re:After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdos... by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday October 16, 2014 @06:52AM (#8464274)
Let's not forget that jails and security are a business, and the War on Drugs has been extremely good for that business.

The possibility exists that the moral posturing around drugs has sometimes been a cover for less noble aims.

See e.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kids_for_cash_scandal

Re:After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdos... by Natsu on Friday October 17, 2014 @02:49AM (#8469731)
That came after, not before. Given that I've heard no one defend those heinous crimes, I find that as lacking an explanation as the silly notions that scientists are advocating climate change because they expect to get grant money.
Re:After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdos... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday October 16, 2014 @01:14AM (#8463481)
Good ole' 18th amendment.
Re:After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdos... by Steuard on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:34PM (#8467905)
Again, you're basing this on a rational assessment of the different drugs in question. That's just not the mindset that we're talking about here. When you grow up hearing your parents and your preachers and your teachers all telling you that alcohol is okay in moderation (for adults) but that using other drugs is wrong (and thus illegal), that can have a real impact in establishing your moral compass for those issues. Those influences are pretty much the defining source of your community's norms and traditions.

So if you're the sort of person whose inclination or upbringing leads you to strongly honor your elders and their ideals, it's not a matter of "irrational circular argument". It's not even a matter of "argument" at all: proper morals and laws aren't based on reason, but on received wisdom. In this view, Moses wasn't supposed to ask, "Why not covet my neighbor's house?" It's enough to simply be told what is wrong and what's not.

Once again, I personally do not think that way, and I'm sure that I'm misrepresenting the perspective of folks who do in multiple ways. But my point here is simply to explain why arguing about these issues based on rational consistency or benefit/harm calculations is so often unproductive.

Re:After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdos... by kristofferR on Thursday October 16, 2014 @06:42PM (#8468297)
I agree with you that many people think that way. Or more accurately = don't think.

> But my point here is simply to explain why arguing about these issues based on rational consistency or benefit/harm calculations is so often unproductive.

What else can the proponents of change do? How can you change the thinking of people with a framework based on not thinking? Are you suggesting that irrational arguments would be more effective?

Re:After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdos... by rrhyne on Thursday October 16, 2014 @12:18AM (#8463333)
Many states try to heavily regulate alcohol. Where and when you can buy it is often frustration and varies from state to state.