News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by warrenm on Thursday October 16, 2014 @03:56PM (#8467240)
Why should it be "illegal"? There's nothing wrong with things being forgotten.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by Shorel on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:41PM (#8467557)
... said the horde who burned the Alexandria library.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by sp332 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:14PM (#8467386)
First, it's my data and the service should keep it instead of deleting it. If I put some stuff in a storage locker, the locker's owner can't just toss it in the garbage, even with 10 day's notice. Second, there's a loss to our culture when a huge trove of media gets trashed like that. It's like a museum deciding it's too expensive to maintain some artwork and just pitching it.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by squeaky-clean on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:50PM (#8468008)
If it's your data, you should keep it instead of handing it off a to a service. Especially a free one with no obligation to hold onto your data. The cool thing about data is you don't need to store it in just one single place.

>If I put some stuff in a storage locker, the locker's owner can't just toss it in the garbage, even with 10 day's notice.

If you never paid for the locker and it wasn't yours in the first place, of course they can.

Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by scholia on Thursday October 16, 2014 @06:26PM (#8468196)
Correct. In addition, Twitpic wasn't a storage locker, and it never pretended to be. As its name implies, it existed for the sole purpose of posting pics to Twitter.

Further to that, I suspect most of the stuff uploaded to Twitpic wasn't actually owned by the people who uploaded it. That was certainly true in my case.

Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by scholia on Thursday October 16, 2014 @06:54PM (#8468362)
Hm, downvotes for making true and accurate statements ;-)
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by tbrownaw on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:40PM (#8467543)
If I put some stuff in a storage locker, the locker's owner can't just toss it in the garbage

If something is in a storage locker, it cannot possibly also be in your attic at the same time. That doesn't apply to bits.

Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by scholia on Thursday October 16, 2014 @06:38PM (#8468270)
Although that doesn't apply here. Twitpic was never promoted as -- and never operated as -- a "storage locker".
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by colbyh on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:38PM (#8467932)
When businesses shut down it's legally acceptable for customer data to be destroyed. Your pictures are just data, and if those images are so important then you should have backed them up in another place. Furthermore I'm positive the EULA you signed when registering covers all of these events.

Expensive artwork doesn't get thrown away, but you'd be amazed how often it gets donated away when a business can no longer operate and can't find a buyer. And this is art that has actual monetary value, not the random sorts of things that find their way to Twitter/Twitpic.

Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by sp332 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @09:16PM (#8468899)
Don't be so positive. Laws for consumer protection, copyright, and data privacy override EULAs.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by bitJericho on Friday October 17, 2014 @08:20AM (#8470524)
I can guarantee you there are works of art on twitpic that cannot be found anywhere else.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by slig on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:27PM (#8467866)
> First, it's my data and the service should keep it instead of deleting it.

If the data is important to you, clearly you have a working backup (or multiple), don't you?

Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by sp332 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:37PM (#8467926)
Sure. But I don't let Seagate off the hook if my hard drive dies just because I have my data backed up. I get a warranty with that.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by scholia on Thursday October 16, 2014 @06:33PM (#8468240)
One difference is that Seagate provides a data store and Twitpic doesn't provide a data store, it provides a service.

It's not even certain that Twitpic kept your original photo or artwork. If you uploaded a 4000 x 3000-pixel image, it reduced it to 600 pixels wide for posting inline on Twitter.

Did you actually use it?

Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by function_seven on Thursday October 16, 2014 @06:41PM (#8468292)
And the warranty replaces the lost data?
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by wise_young_man on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:29PM (#8467462)
Isn't Twitpic a free service? You would pay for a storage locker right? Museums charge money.

This stuff isn't free to maintain.

Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by sp332 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:36PM (#8467516)
A free storage locker couldn't chuck my stuff in the trash either. TwitPic didn't ask anyone to pay to keep their data. They just decided to delete it. And museums don't charge the artist for upkeep.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by Igglyboo on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:18PM (#8467809)
So say TwitPic literally had no money to keep the servers running that housed your data, what then? Tell them to suck it and all get new jobs to support your data? Or give you a grace period to reclaim that data?

Number 2 sounds like a completely reasonable approach.

Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by sp332 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:27PM (#8467862)
So they ran out of money suddenly? With no warning, they discover they have only 10 days to survive? They should still work with archivists to offload the data.

They could at least turn off new registrations, and put some kind of notice on the home page that they're about to shut down. TwitPic is still accepting new signups and uploads.

Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by Igglyboo on Thursday October 16, 2014 @06:44PM (#8468309)
I don't know but what if they did? You offer no alternative other than saying it should be illegal, what if a service actually did run out of money immediately? Throw them in jail because their servers got repossessed by the bank?

If a storage company went under and gave everyone notice to pick up their old shit and after the deadline there were still unclaimed items, what are they supposed to do?

Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by bitJericho on Friday October 17, 2014 @08:23AM (#8470550)
I would sue a storage company and the owners personally that destroyed my possessions without giving me enough time to go get them. 10 days is not enough time. 100 days might not be enough time. The amount of time should be decided by someone, like the state in which the company resides
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by Igglyboo on Friday October 17, 2014 @09:28AM (#8470807)
The company has no money, what are you going to sue them for? If they're properly incorporated you wouldn't be able to go after the owners.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by bitJericho on Friday October 17, 2014 @10:22AM (#8471089)
You can break the corporate veil when execs break the law.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by Igglyboo on Friday October 17, 2014 @11:42AM (#8471501)
Except that's never the case, the silicon valley wage fixing scandal was hugely illegal and they got fined/class action lawsuit. No criminal charges.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by sp332 on Friday October 17, 2014 @09:19AM (#8470765)
This exact outcome (running out of money and shutting down) was foreseeable from day 1. They should have had a plan in place beyond pretending it wasn't going to happen until it was too late.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by bitJericho on Friday October 17, 2014 @08:22AM (#8470548)
Donate the data to a 3rd party company. It's not that hard.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by nemothekid on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:01PM (#8467693)
If I had a friend tell me that his free storage locker chucked his stuff, I'd tell him thats what he gets for using a free storage locker.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by sp332 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @05:08PM (#8467746)
And you would be wrong, because no one deserves to have their stuff chucked and it's actually illegal. Your friend has recourse in that situation.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by MarkPNeyer on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:25PM (#8467439)
"it should be illegal" is very different from "it should not happen."

if anything, i'd bet that law would just make a bunch more data disappear, as hosting any data for anyone else would now become extremely risky; you open yourself up to permanent liability by taking anything anyone uploads. who wants that?

Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by sp332 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:31PM (#8467477)
I don't think anyone said "permanent". But 10 days is not enough time. How about 6 months from the first notification sent to the user? And it should be extended if the export service itself goes down (like TwitPic's is broken right now).
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by bitJericho on Friday October 17, 2014 @08:24AM (#8470555)
I'm ok with companies not taking data that can't handle it.
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by dyeje on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:32PM (#8467484)
It costs money to keep the servers running. If the data is that important, perhaps you should pay for the service?
Re:Twitpic Couldn’t Find an Acquirer, Will Shut Down After A... by sp332 on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:37PM (#8467519)
Sure, where do I send the check?