Gates didn't come from a middle-class background but from an upper-class one. His father was a highly successful lawyer and cofounder of Shidler & King (then Preston Gates & Ellis, now K&L Gates), his maternal grandfather was an affluent banker (national bank president) and his mother was a Seattle power serving on the boards of United Way, UW, US West (then Pacific Northwest Bell), First Interstate Bank and others.
Maybe it's a British thing, but to me class is only minimally about money, so you can't just say the Gates family are rich so they're upper class.
In Britain you can be penniless but still be upper class, or a billionaire but still working class. Take David Beckham - rich but working class. You can probably find some destitute Baronets somewhere who are definitely still upper class.
Professional people (as people who are predominantly workers, but usually not on living paycheck-to-paycheck and often with small capital holdings that may suffice for a comfortable retirement) are general middle class, yes.
> The US doesn't really have an upper class at all
The US actually does have an upper class, people who are primarily capitalists rather than workers.
> In Britain you can be penniless but still be upper class, or a billionaire but still working class.
You seem to be describing a pre-capitalist, essentially feudal view of class (in a capitalist society, meaningful class distinctions still aren't exactly about money, per se, but more where that money comes from, though there's a relation between the two -- you can't be penniless and be maintaining a comfortable standard of living primarily from capital -- whereas in a feudal class system its more about station of birth independent of money, though, in societies where such a class distinction is meaningful rather than a mere historical artifact, there's a close association between that station and both money and how you get it.)
But then do you have a different term for what I'm talking about? What would you call someone who comes from a well known family lineage, speaks with a refined accent, was privately educated, went to Harvard, listens to classical music, collects french poetry first editions, but earns a pittance as faculty in the classics department at a college somewhere and has no savings or investments?
They don't earn anything, but you can't lump them in with a poor fast food worker can you? What term do you use for this in the US, if you don't call it 'class'? If the UK they would absolutely be upper class. What would you call them?
Here's an insight into the British class system for you: some Army regiments are essentially segregated by the class of their officers. A state school educated officer could join the Royal Tank Regiment but would probably never join the King's Royal Hussars. Of course this is unspoken.
He'd be middle class in the US, mostly because of his income. He's got connections but still middle class. A fast food worker would be lower class. A fast food worker who went to Harvard, with all those connections and hobbies, would largely be the same. But that's an incredibly contrived example. Class distinctions work because of general income-hobby-family background correlations that generally exist.
Also, there isn't much of a "refined accent" in the US that I'm aware of. At least nothing as marked as cockney vs british.
There's a meaningful economic class distinction to be made, probably, between a tenured faculty member at a university and a fast food worker, even if somehow their income ends up similar (the former having greater economic security than the latter, likely).
But I think the distinction you are making is more about subculture than economic class. This particular axis of subculture may sometimes be referred to as "class" (particularly by the people on the "higher" end of it) -- though its probably less common in the US to do so than it would be in Britain -- but its really a largely orthogonal concept to economic class distinctions. Not completely independent though, as -- as many axes of subcultural variations do -- it can have important relations to social networking opportunities that play a role in economic opportunities.
This is clearly even more visible, and arguably more substantive, in the United Kingdom -- where, in addition to the kind of examples you cite, there are, for instance, still hereditary peers in the House of Lords, and, heck, still a House of Lords -- than the United States.
Needless to say there are also plenty of "uneducated" plumbers whose skills earn them well above the national average wage whilst many marketing graduates embark on serial unpaid internships updating Twitter feeds in the hope someone will eventually deem their university-enhanced flair for on-brand 140 character communication worth paying for.
In the UK more so than most places "economic class" owes as much to Veblenesque notions of the luxury status of jobs as it does to how much employees actually earn and whether real opportunities for progression exist.
In french I believe the upper class you are referring to would be called "aristocratie" or "noblesse", while the capitalist upper class would be called "bourgeoisie". I know there are similar words in English but I'm not sure if they carry the same meaning.
Blue collar: an individual whose earnings are derived primarily from physical labor, following someone else's instructions. Blue collar workers are often paid via hourly wages.
Brown collar: a subset of blue collar. The differentiating factor is that these people work outdoors. The brown is often explained by dirt on the collar, but in reality, most people who use this term use it because this type of worker is overwhelmingly likely to be a dark-skinned person.
Khaki collar: a subset of blue collar. Used for military jobs.
White collar: an individual whose earnings are derived primarily from labor requiring specialized knowledge or skills. White collar workers are often paid via weekly salary.
Tailored collar: a subset of white collar, except restricted to executive management, and possibly their immediate subordinates, depending on the size of the business.
Rich: an individual whose earnings are derived primarily from business ownership and investment returns. Rich people may also work in one of the aforementioned categories, but most prefer to enjoy leisure activities, volunteer for charitable causes, manage their own property portfolio, or pursue political goals.
Additionally, we have some terms for class-related nuances.
Ghetto/Barrio/Trailer Trash/Crab Bucket: this person grew up in the lower class, and exhibits many of the negative qualities of people raised in an impoverished, survival-oriented environment. These people are overwhelmingly ignorant of the social norms respected by higher classes.
Trust Fund Baby: this person grew up in the upper class, and exhibits many of the negative qualities of people raised in an affluent, self-realization-oriented environment. These people are overwhelmingly ignorant of the social norms respected by lower classes.
Welfare Queen/Welfare King: this person has no desire to earn their living, and survives primarily on government benefits. Ironically, these people often continue to receive benefits even as people who would rather work than be on the dole are cut off, because they are experts in gaming the bureaucracy.
Beltway Bandit: Welfare Royalty of the incorporated business variety. So named for the Beltway bypass highway around Washington, D.C.
Ivory Tower/Academian: this person was raised to value education above all else, and somehow managed to not learn anything of actual value. Usually white collar, but poor.
Hack: this person only does their job because it pays well. Often compensates for job dissatisfaction and high earned income via conspicuous consumption and being a dick to co-workers.
Wage Slave: contrasts with Hack, in that they are paid only enough to survive and continue working. These people would like to do something else, but cannot afford to support themselves at their preferred job. In the US, this is often someone who would have attended college, but could not afford it. May also be a person who graduated college, but cannot earn enough in their chosen field to pay off their student loans.
Brick/Backroom Boy: this person is absolutely competent and reliable in their job, and perform high-value work, so naturally other people stand on top of them and steal their credit.
Rainmaker: contrasts with Brick, in that they actually get some recognition for the value they produce. Often the top-producing salespeople at a company are recognized as Rainmakers.
Can you source your 40% figure? The only child poverty number I found is 21.8% for 2012. [1]
For those in poverty, can you provide more insight to why you think they have "virtually no chance at all of being able to even play in the capitalist economy"? I think everyone would agree they are at a disadvantage, but there are several people on the Forbes 400 this year who came out of poverty. Both of my parents came out of poverty, even you said you made it out of poverty.
Can you provide some anecdotal insight to your peers who fell "prey for the tech titans, who fill their eyes with glittery visions that make them forget their hunger and cold."
[1] http://web.stanford.edu/group/scspi/sotu/SOTU_2014_CPI.pdf
> who fill their eyes
My presumption is that he is referring to the movement towards digital/virtual consumption and away from physical consumption. The rich and poor entertain themselves in much the same way now, but that doesn't give us a way out of the trend:
http://rick.bookstaber.com/2013/11/live-to-eat-eat-to-live.h...
Maybe poor kids will have more access to tools now, but will those tools be relevant in their economic age? Musicians and artists have had all these amazing tools - but is anyone making a living off of them?
That came out of the blue... can you expand on that? [Note also that Gates said a progressive consumption tax.]
I like a progressive consumption tax because (I currently believe, anyway) that it's harder to avoid than an income tax. Income can happen anywhere in the world, but if you are living here then you are consuming here. You can keep trying to defer income through clever accounting, but that seems harder to do with consumption (if you have a yacht today, you pay taxes today).
It also takes away most arguments about class warfare. A wealthy person can't just call themselves a "job creator" and oppose taxes while floating around on a yacht and running a business into the ground. If they do, it will be obvious the taxes are for their yacht, and not their job-creating ability.
I watch friends in the Bay Area spend everything-save nothing and then call the homeless kids in the Haight lazy bums. I have a savings but if the tech bubble did burst there's a very real chance I could end up home. My family doesn't have wealth and some of my siblings are already homeless.
Puh-leese. Who do you think is buying this? There's no way that figure is anywhere near accurate for people living in "abject poverty".
>Gates, Buffett, and others who claim to be philanthropists work from a point of ignorance, believing that all youth at least have their basic needs covered by this society.
You are aware that the Gates Foundation spends the majority of its resources in Africa, trying to get medicine to the thousands of children that die from ailments that are easily treatable in the US? Almost any child in the US looks massively privileged by comparison. The fact that almost all of our children live to adulthood is a testament to that.
>The idea of taking a couple of months without income to make a startup is laughable- how would I eat and make my house payment?
I don't really know what you're getting at here. Since you were poor growing up, you're too terrified to ever take the risk involved in a startup? Most people are, no matter their economic background. Most startup founders are taking the same kind of risk and don't have years of savings to live off of, but they gather the balls and do it anyway. You're attributing too much of this to your disadvantaged upbringing.
the BASIC needs of survival
40% of youth in the USA today do not even have that, and as such, have virtually no chance at all of being able to even play in the capitalist economy. They will be successful if they avoid homelessness and hunger, which will be a daily struggle.
Gates, Buffett, and others who claim to be philanthropists work from a point of ignorance, believing that all youth at least have their basic needs covered by this society. They are blind. Piketty at least acknowledges the underclasses.
These so-called philanthropists depend on the existence of a permanent underclass to support their "charity".
I was raised on the edges of this underclass and even today, after 20 years in the business doing quite well, I worry every day that I will soon be homeless or hungry. I have no inheritance to count on,other than debt from my family. The idea of taking a couple of months without income to make a startup is laughable- how would I eat and make my house payment? Most of the peers from my youth are on public assistance, in jail, ill, or worse. They are easy prey for the tech titans, who fill their eyes with glittery visions that make them forget their hunger and cold. This is in the Bay Area, mind you, less than 20 miles from the Valley.
Gates' idea of a consumption tax would heavily penalize these people, who have been enslaved into a consumer lifestyle by the wealthy who exercise control over their lives.
The whole "inequality" debate laments the demise of the middle class. But it never acknowledges the permanent underclass that is a necessary component of a society that can take the time for the inequality debate.
I got out, though you never lose the psychic clutches of abject poverty. Most folks never get out.