Re:Why Inequality Matters
by notahacker on Thursday October 16, 2014 @04:46PM
(#8467598)
I presume the example university employee doesn't have the luxury of tenure. The distinction is actually pretty straightforward. The "well-spoken" junior assistant librarian with their 2:2 in Latin from Exeter could get a job at McDonalds, if need be. The pretty-smart high-school leaver earning a fair percentage above minimum wage as a store manager at McDonalds would struggle to get a job as a junior assistant librarian at a university library even if they were willing to accept the pay cut.
Needless to say there are also plenty of "uneducated" plumbers whose skills earn them well above the national average wage whilst many marketing graduates embark on serial unpaid internships updating Twitter feeds in the hope someone will eventually deem their university-enhanced flair for on-brand 140 character communication worth paying for.
In the UK more so than most places "economic class" owes as much to Veblenesque notions of the luxury status of jobs as it does to how much employees actually earn and whether real opportunities for progression exist.
There's a meaningful economic class distinction to be made, probably, between a tenured faculty member at a university and a fast food worker, even if somehow their income ends up similar (the former having greater economic security than the latter, likely).
But I think the distinction you are making is more about subculture than economic class. This particular axis of subculture may sometimes be referred to as "class" (particularly by the people on the "higher" end of it) -- though its probably less common in the US to do so than it would be in Britain -- but its really a largely orthogonal concept to economic class distinctions. Not completely independent though, as -- as many axes of subcultural variations do -- it can have important relations to social networking opportunities that play a role in economic opportunities.
This is clearly even more visible, and arguably more substantive, in the United Kingdom -- where, in addition to the kind of examples you cite, there are, for instance, still hereditary peers in the House of Lords, and, heck, still a House of Lords -- than the United States.