News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by vlunkr on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:08PM (#8459196)
I don't understand these people that hate her so much, even if you disagree with her. All she has done is create a series of videos pointing out what she thinks is wrong with the gaming industry and she gets death threats. Why is no one allowed to be critical of video games? If anything, they are just proving her point by responding with violence.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by iamdave on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:36PM (#8459491)
>Why is no one allowed to be critical of video games?

There's a lot of vitriol going back and forth by both sides of this latest iteration of the 'Battle of the Sexes'. I think abstracting back, a lot of very good points are being brought up that need to be discussed (lots of bad ones too, in the interest of intellectual honesty). It's not until you get a bit more granular that ugly heads start to rear up and we ultimately end up with this.

We're at an unfortunate point right now that dissent is a tacit admission of complicity with the various social ills that people like Sarkesian are trying to explicate on a large scale at best, and treated as an existential threat to 'progress' at worst. No, that's not an indictment of the entire movement of feminism, but it's also not hard to find for anyone who goes and looks for it.

I used to care about this, a lot. Now? I prefer to just sit back and let both sides of screaming ninnies tire themselves out so that the people who are willing to reach across the table, admit that their movements have baggage and are mature enough to look past that baggage can have a melding of the minds to get things accomplished.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by llamataboot on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:55PM (#8459709)
I'm sorry, but this is a false equivalence. On one side you have people literally threatening people with violence to the point of being forced to leave their homes, cancel speaking appearances, etc. On the other side, you have people pointing out this unfortunate fact.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by iamdave on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @01:00PM (#8459779)
I ask this earnestly, but did I give some indication that the threats being delivered don't deserve scrutiny or should otherwise be waved aside as negligible? I guess I'm not entirely getting where you're coming from; my point was that there's a worthwhile discussion that needs to be had regarding sexism in gaming, but much of it has been muddled by participants from both camps.

The death threats here, just happen to be example of muddling of side "A".

Name calling, death-threats, "doxxing", there's mud being flung here, calling it a "false equivalence" when I've implicated both parties of not moving the ball forward seems rather obtuse.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by ben0x539 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @01:21PM (#8460029)
Yeah, you did give that indication, you're constantly framing abuse and harassment of women as a "battle" between two equally positioned sides, incidentally sides where one would be arbitrarily placed in by accident of birth.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by iamdave on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @01:28PM (#8460099)
If the problem is my choice of the term 'battle', I was borrowing a phrase from game theory: http://www.wikiwand.com/en/Battle_of_the_sexes_(game_theory) which I genuinely believe the subject matter has many contextual parallels to.

Obviously I do not intend to speak as if the social conversation about sexism in gaming, tech and other industries is an actually even battle where both sides have equal rhetorical or empirical firepower to "win" or "lose".

And if indeed the problem is that I called it a 'battle', then I'll conditionally accept correction on that (even if I think it ignores the larger point I was attempting to make).

I think now is a good time for me to step aside from this before we go off the rails.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by ben0x539 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @01:48PM (#8460295)
My problem with the particular phrase 'battle of the sexes' is that invites a reduction in this context that gamergate holds a reasonable male position and Sarkeesian merely holds an equally reasonable female position, and that men can't be blamed for holding the gamergate position and that only women should reasonably hold Sarkeesian's position. I admit I'm ignorant of the game theory allusion you're making.

More generally I fear I don't understand the larger point you're trying to make if you weren't trying to do the "two sides, both have some good points and some bad points, let's ask the peope receiving death threats to sit down with their abusers and find a compromise" truth-is-in-the-middle thing.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by iamdave on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:04PM (#8460454)
let's ask the peope receiving death threats to sit down with their abusers and find a compromise" truth-is-in-the-middle thing.

Except I never said that. I never insinuated that, if you think that's the case, then it appears you're trying to force your interpretations into my statements, and that's not cool.

Instead, what I've asserted repeatedly is this:

1) Sexism in gaming, tech and other industries needs to be addressed. Absolutely and positively.

2) Many who carry the banner of "Feminist" and many who carry the banner "Gamer" have taken unfortunate and problematic stances, as well as have made unfortunate and problematic statements to get "their" side more validity to the point where taking a side either way carries many severe consequences in the interest of moving a conversation forward.

3) Instead of simply jumping to one side because of how the other side reacts, I personally have decided to abstain from participating further until I see an opportunity where I personally feel comfortable participating and not be accused of being sexist/misogynist/whateverist or otherwise chided for not expressing myself in absolute support.

Is that a little less ambiguous?

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by ben0x539 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:30PM (#8460676)
I still think 2) is one hell of a false equivalency, ymmv.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by iamdave on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:34PM (#8460691)
Please break it down for me? I'm clearly not seeing it (we often fail to see the failings in ourselves, it's just human), I for my part tried to clarify my stance; repeating "false equivalency" doesn't help me understand your response any better.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by ben0x539 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:50PM (#8460824)
As far as I can tell, there's the gamergate people organizing the harassment of people, posting their victims' private addresses, sending them death threats and all kinds of abuse, bullying people into withdrawing from their online identities, all under a propaganda screen of fabricated pretenses and smear campaigns.

Then there's the "feminist" crowd which wants that sort of thing to not happen, and also talk about videogames.

Your way of putting it implies that these two are equivalent in being "unfortunate and problematic", which in my opinion is a severe misrepresentation of the situation.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by iamdave on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @03:01PM (#8460902)
Your way of putting it implies that these two are equivalent in being "unfortunate and problematic", which in my opinion is a severe misrepresentation of the situation.

In your opinion then, what's a better way to present it? I'm trying to look at this as broadly as I possibly can without getting strung up in highlighting granular, "this instance" and "that instance" responses, effectively coming across as a 'single issue debater'.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by llamataboot on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @04:16PM (#8461445)
A better way to present it would be, "I don't agree with all the points that people identifying as feminists in these arguments are making, for example XYZ. However, I strongly condemn calls for violence against them and think that the violence and threats of violence discredits any argument the GamerGate people may be making and reinforces the fact that we live in a patriarchal society and a rape culture where violence against women is all too common and normalized. Arguments against the content of arguments and counter examples are fine and okay, however the word of someone claiming they personally are being marginalized and victimized should generally be given more weight than someone else claiming that that person isn't. We can have civil and even enthusiastic discussions about how sexism manifests itself in the videogame industry (or doesn't), but misogynist violence is never okay and de facto reinforces how big of a problem sexism is in tech culture, and the way that both covert and overt violence is used to silence women.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by iamdave on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @04:38PM (#8461560)
however the word of someone claiming they personally are being marginalized and victimized should generally be given more weight than someone else claiming that that person isn't.

No it absolutely should not, and the applications that we've seen when this framework of thought is proof enough of what happens when we give the victim more legal weight than the accused.

Title IX is a perfect example of this flawed implementation of "justice" to the point where the victims receive all the benefits of due process, but the accused does not. Taking the victim at their word is preposterous and absolutely and wholly contrary to the way our legal framework was designed, and ought to work:

Quote: "OCR’s language implies that the rights of accused students at public colleges do not merit lengthy discussion and further suggests by negative implication that accused have any rights at all.57 The Letter also states that “[w]hen taking steps to separate the complainant and alleged perpetrator, a school should minimize the burden on the complainant, and thus should not, as a matter of course, remove complainants from classes or housing while allowing alleged perpetrators to remain.” In other words, alleged perpetrators should automatically suffer life-upending punishments like expulsion from their residences upon accusation because they are likely guilty. The writing on the wall from this treatment of due process rights is unmistakable: it implies, “oddly and ominously, that the statutory rights of the accuser trump the constitutional due-process [sic] rights of the accused.”"

Source: "A HOSTILE ENVIRONMENT FOR STUDENT DEFENDANTS: TITLE IX AND SEXUAL ASSAULT ON COLLEGE CAMPUSES" (http://chaselaw.nku.edu/content/dam/chaselaw/docs/academics/...) p.61 pp.2 - p62 pp.1

You can absolutely have a civil discourse on how sexism manifests itself in the video game industry and others, and misogynist violence is absolutely never okay. But once we get to the point where conversations depend on giving one person more credence than another simply because of their status, or role in the affair, we're entering very dangerous waters.

One such example of the treacherous possibilities comes from the events of October 2012 at Ohio University where two students publicly engaged in lewd acts, photographs showed the female participant smiling, engaging and interacting with the male participant, and still cried rape to the detriment of the male participant even when local law enforcement could not find evidence to indict;

Source: http://www.mindingthecampus.com/2013/11/is_this_a_campus_rap...

No.

No we do NOT give the accuser "more weight".

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @04:32PM (#8461521)
Further: threats of violence used to silence anyone, are not anything like a valid argument form. They are the usual tool of a corrupt, authoritarian voice. The practice is to be condemned by all who support rational dialog.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by ben0x539 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @04:10PM (#8461398)
It's a 4chan-style raid/social media harassment op. There's not much to it. It's what they do.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by anonymousab on Thursday October 16, 2014 @12:41AM (#8463398)
That "feminist crowd" is just as guilty of harassment, doxxing and threats.

Like mailing syringes filled with unknown chemicals. Or threatening ten year old "comedians" with "a shanking".

The fact is that you cannot attribute such things to the majority for any side in such matters. It's intellectually dishonest.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by sb057 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @06:38PM (#8462238)
>On the other side, you have people pointing out this unfortunate fact.

https://i.imgur.com/eUjdl5K.jpg

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BzQqokICUAEyhWy.png

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BzFBQrMIEAA487S.png

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Bzko-VhIgAAX9WK.png

https://twitter.com/leighalexander/status/464779743175655425

https://twitter.com/Boogie2988/status/522156760623484928

It's ridiculous to say that that side is only "pointing out this unfortunate fact," especially after so many Gamergate supporters have denounced the doxxings and threats.

https://www.reddit.com/r/KotakuInAction/comments/2jabgg/can_...

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by Houshalter on Thursday October 16, 2014 @01:11AM (#8463474)
"Your opinion is wrong because someone associated with your opinion did something bad."

Death threats have, unfortunately, always been very common among controversial figures. Obama gets 30 a day, about 40,000 in total.

[dead]
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by ben0x539 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:30PM (#8459430)
A death threat doesn't become less real by not being followed through it, otherwise it'd be called murder, not death threat.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by seanflyon on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @07:54PM (#8462524)
The implication (dubious as it is) is that the threats were made by people on her side in order to garner sympathy. I think that would make the threats "not real", if it were the case.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by Rubix117 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:34PM (#8459469)
I mean I very doubt they are real, she has been shown time and again to be a liar.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by ben0x539 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:53PM (#8459686)
This is a shitty gamergate meme and has no basis in reality.

The evil "women in gaming" conspiracy would have to be very, very well organized to fabricate the amount of false flag abuse they're constantly subjecting themselves to just on twitter.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by _wdh on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:47PM (#8459613)
Do you have a source or owt for that? You can't just drop something like that without any evidence.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by DanBC on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:56PM (#8459735)
Do you doubt that she has received death threats? Do you doubt that other women recieve death threats?
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by vlunkr on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:34PM (#8459470)
Even if they aren't real at all, how is that an appropriate response?
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by Rubix117 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:39PM (#8459520)
Because lying about death threats causes more problems. I honestly can't believe people take this woman so seriously. As I have commented before she has been shown to be a liar. Nothing she says has any credibility.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by nrinaudo on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @01:13PM (#8459947)
I'm sorry, I've been following this story for a while and every single one of the instances where she has been accused of lying that I know of has been debunked.

I'm not calling you a liar, merely asking for you to point me to what I've been missing. I run in circles that are pretty pro-sarkeesian and may have suffered from selection bias.

Do note, however, that simply stating that she's a liar is not an actual proof of anything. I'm asking for actual articles from reputable outlets, not quotes from Guest11743 on 4chan.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by Karunamon on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @05:52PM (#8462030)
Maybe less direct lying and more by omission, but the one I always think of is but one of her videos points out a few supposedly misogynistic portions in the Hitman series of games - while forgetting to mention that the game penalizes you for doing what she's complaining about.

There are other instances of this kind of failure to research - see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bwwFx-tz9TY&feature=share, starting at about 5:33.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by nrinaudo on Thursday October 16, 2014 @03:26AM (#8463796)
Right, I see where we misunderstood each other. You're talking about conclusions she reached that are debatable - and, indeed, debated rather a lot. I also disagree with some of them, but don't feel that qualifies her as a liar, just someone with whom I don't agree on everything. Possibly even someone that sometimes uses hyperbole to make her points. I'm most likely guilty of the same sin myself and don't begrudge her this stylistic shortcut.

I was talking about, for example, accusations that: - she made the threats up - she was the author of some of the threats - she never actually did report the threats to the police

These lies have either been debunked (the police report was produced, for example) or "proved" by nothing stronger than "it stands to reason", which I read as "there is no proof and never will be".

We do not necessarily disagree on your points, just on whether that makes her a liar. Facts tend to show that, on average, she's much less of a liar than the people who attack her.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by Karunamon on Thursday October 16, 2014 @09:45AM (#8464811)
In my mind, intellectual dishonesty equates to lying; especially considering how she absolutely refuses to accept any kind of criticism or address the very real and concrete problems with her conclusions.

Some of these things aren't "debatable", she's completely ignorant (either willfully or not is another question, and i'm leaning towards 'willful' due to either the total lack of response or personal attacks that anyone disagreeing with her gets) of information that completely invalidates her arguments.

And saying "well gamergate is worse" is just a cop-out.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by nrinaudo on Thursday October 16, 2014 @10:58AM (#8465234)
In case the "lack of response" was directed at me, for the very specific Hitman thing: yes, the game penalises you for killing the dancers (hookers?). I'm pretty sure the penalty is lifted if you hide the bodies, though. So, yes, you're penalised, unless you are not. One might almost think you willfully witheld that particular piece of information.

As for the "well gamergate is worse" thing.

It was not what I meant, although I see how it could come off that way. My point was: the people who accuse her of lying have been repeatedly shown to be lying themselves. On the whole, I'd rather trust the person who has not (yet?) been proven to be a liar than the ones who have.

Lastly, it's usually the case that when accusing someone of something, said accusation looses all credibility if its author is guilty of the same thing - regardless of the initial accusation's merit. If you want your argument that she lies to be listened to, then you need to stick to the truth, hard as it can be. If you want to accuse her of witholding information, make absolutely sure you're not doing the same thing.

And, and this should go without saying, if you want to have any credibility, do not willingly associate yourself with people who threaten to rape and kill someone over games (I realise that you haven't explicitly stated you were part of gamergate - you're using the rethoric, but I apologise is my assumption is incorrect).

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by Karunamon on Thursday October 16, 2014 @12:51PM (#8465925)
Nono, the "lack of response" was directed at Sarkeesian - there is not one instance in which she or her supporters respond to criticisms of her arguments with anything other than silence or personal attacks.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by ben0x539 on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @01:27PM (#8460089)
You gotta realize that at the point where you observe a women fearing for her safety and having to manage her life around constant harassment and threats of violence and your public reaction is "clearly she must be making it up for attention and all those benefits she's getting from being a public target", you've gone so far off the rails of the process of forming conclusions from reasonable assumptions that your implicit agenda is showing really, really flagrantly.
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by le_hackour on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:50PM (#8459655)
Perhaps the reason for your confusion is because there has never actually been a response with violence against her?
Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @10:35PM (#8463031)
Per Wikipedia, the WHO defines violence as:

"the intentional use of physical force or power, threatened or actual, against oneself, another person, or against a group or community, which either results in or has a high likelihood of resulting in injury, death, psychological harm, maldevelopment, or deprivation..."

Death threats would certainly qualify under that.

Re:Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat by burke on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:53PM (#8459689)
So death threats are okay as long as you don't follow through?