Why is there an opportunity with bitcoin? Aren't the costs and fees paying for the legal agreements, risk management, arbitration and things like that? Bitcoin might possibly reduce the cost of moving the dollars around but I suspect this is a very small fraction of the cost of this type of service.
An m-of-n transaction with a decent and trusted intermediary (or multiple less trusted intermediaries) could also replace bank guarantees, which is the simplest form of trade finance. There are also other opportunities in using bitcoin as proof of ownership or proof that you hold a product.
So let's replace banks with... banks?
The overhead costs that bitcoin will save are just the wire transfer fees. Beyond that, there's still lawyer time, intermediary escrow fees, etc. Those will not change.
Dealing with arbitration services rather than with escrow makes this much simpler, drops the entry/operational costs to nearly nothing and does not even require a lawyer to assist you with the process. This lowers the barriers of entry significantly and allows to create a competitive market for arbitration services in a way that's simply not possible when an escrow is required, leading to reduced end-user costs and improved service quality.
Source: I'm the founder of Bitrated [1], a service that enables exactly those kinds of arbitration services, and received extensive legal advice on this matter from my attorney. Do note, however, that this is a new and somewhat gray territory that can be interpreted in multiple ways (and of course, IANAL/TINLA apply - ask your own lawyer before doing anything.)
(P.S. Bitrated v2, a complete rewrite I've been working on for the past 6 months, which now includes an identity & reputation management system, is about to be shortly released. If anyone is interested, you can follow @bitrated on twitter for updates. </shameless-promotion>)
That is just to replace the trust element of a bank, not the financial function. At the moment it is nearly impossible to split trust across more than one institution - which means there is a single point of failure in the trust chain and if 2008 repeats again x% of people will lose funds. m-of-n allows you to distribute that trust, even if its just more banks signing the transactions to begin with.
Further, there are other ways to do proof of reserve with bitcoin that don't involve m-of-n.
In terms of the financing and risk assessment element, you could carve that out in tranches and sell out it on auction. At the moment the $2 trillion p.a trade finance market is limited in entry to only those who have a banking license, hence the thick fees and profits in it. You could open up the financing and terms to an open market, just like crowdsourced venture funding or project funding, or have smaller institutions that specialize in certain types of risk that they better understand (it is crazy that there are a half-dozen major banks who pretend to be able to understand and price every time of import / export finance situation anywhere in the world).
Structured trade finance is a whole other matter, that is where you have bespoke instruments and teams working on deals - usually with businesses that see $50M+ p.a in deal flow.
In either case I mentioned in my post that having a lawyer do a terms of trade or supply agreement is cheaper at the low end.
Call your bank - most of them have a trade finance desk, or Google the term. A slightly cheaper way of doing it is to have a lawyer draft a terms of trade or supply agreement with either the funds in escrow with the firm or a bank guarantee.
Having your bank finance the trade is worthwhile as interest rates are so low at the moment. Common terms are 60, 90 or 120 day delivery with FED/LIBOR + x% (where x is the risk profile of your business - shop around to get prices) cost over the term.
The agreement would contain delivery timetables, warranties, customs clearance, liabilities, indemnities, guarantees, who pays what, etc. and you are protected legally without handing over tens of thousands of dollars or more upfront. These contracts are protected by law in almost all jurisdictions.
You don't finalize the transaction and pay for it until all conditions have been met and you have the goods in hand and have verified. The seller is trusting an international bank or a law firm escrow, and they should also have a lawyer or bank on their end (a trusted seller can receive the cash upfront for a fee with the bank picking up the risk, although I doubt any bank would finance a bitcoin atm without verified trade volume and a lower risk profile).
Talk to your lawyer and talk to your bank, having expensive items delivered without risking the full cost is a solved problem as old as finance itself and trillions of dollars annually are traded in this way. The extra $1k or so you'd pay on a $25k deal are worth it for the guarantee. If you ship goods regularly the costs are amortized as you can use the same contracts and finance suppliers. Don't deal with anybody shipping $20k+ valued products that doesn't deal with a bank trade finance desk or law firm and is instead asking for a bank transfer.
This is how most high cost goods are traded - from oil and other commodity supply contracts through to companies like Boeing and Airbus supplying planes, or GE supplying turbines for a power plant. Most people without experience lead into it thinking that buying something that costs $25k, $100k or millions of dollars is just the same as purchasing something at your local store just with bigger numbers. It isn't.
Bitcoin multisig transactions, or m of n transactions are also worth investigating as they cut the costs - although there is currently a lack of escrow/intermediaries who are as trusted as major law firms or an international bank. There is a huge opportunity in cutting the costs and fees associated with trade finance with bitcoin.