News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by enraged_camel on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:14PM (#8454482)
"Sign up with Facebook"

No thanks. I'll stick with OKCupid.

edit: since this is a YC company, I'll add some content to my criticism (even though most of this should be obvious).

1. This is a new service, and people don't know you yet. Asking them to sign up with their Facebook account is asking for too much, because there is no trust element established. Consider having a stand-alone sign-up mechanism that enables some bare-bone features with the option to hook up to Facebook for additional benefits (i.e. 5 matches per week vs. 2 matches, promise for more accurate matching, etc.). Users need to see some value out of the service before they volunteer their Facebook info.

2. Lots of people don't use Facebook, and even more of them are leaving Facebook. There are also lots of people who are cynical towards it and use it as little as possible. You are certainly alienating them by requiring a Facebook account.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by danpalmer on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:25PM (#8454552)
Working at a company appealing to non-tech people, with a "Sign up with Facebook" ability as well as "sign up with email", I can tell you most people just sign up with Facebook.

We don't have anything that says "we won't post to your wall" etc, but most people use it anyway.

Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by laurenkay on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:19PM (#8454519)
Ha, we definitely get that that's a dealbreaker for a lot of people. Most top dating sites are populated by a ton of fake profiles, so while logging in with Facebook isn't ideal, it helps us as a small startup to prevent spammers. We don't post to members' walls / we basically just ask for birthdate and photos.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by enraged_camel on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:26PM (#8454559)
I totally understand where you're coming from. However, consider that there are more fake Facebook profiles on the Internet than fake online dating profiles. Facebook itself does not to any sort of identity verification, so the benefits of relying on it to filter spam are dubious.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by laurenkay on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:34PM (#8454599)
Additionally, our matchmakers review each profile before approving a member. So Facebook definitely isn't perfect, but it helps to prevent some spam, as well as multiple signups from the same person. It also makes the signup flow a lot faster for members.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by laurenkay on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:43PM (#8454662)
Considering that this is the biggest complaint we've heard, we're also considering adding a way to sign up without Facebook.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by prawn on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:17PM (#8455521)
This is a bit rich considering that further up you're defending yourself against criticism of spam?
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by jonathanjaeger on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:24PM (#8454547)
OkCupid has fake profiles but it's not THAT bad (maybe Tinder has spam problems, or so I've heard, but they're spammed because they are at scale). Nothing a reverse-image search on Google can't usually solve.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by mdupont on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:46PM (#8454677)
I used to work there. Fraud/fake profiles are one of the hardest & most important problems to solve, and one of OKC's main competitive advantages is doing so in a scalable way. It's not a problem from the user perspective, but that's a testament to a lot of intelligent effort, not a reason why fake profiles aren't an issue.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by shostack on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @04:59PM (#8455776)
I've always been fascinated by that aspect of dating sites. Could you share some of the technical specifics as to what the hardest challenges are that still remain to be solved and how the cat-and-mouse game has evolved?
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by Xdes on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:22PM (#8454533)
Then I should make a fake facebook so I can make a fake profile? One more layer of indirection doesn't necessarily add more security.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by lmm on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @02:20PM (#8454864)
Facebook can afford to have dozens of smart people working full-time on eliminating fake profiles. A small startup can't.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by UrMomReadsHN on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @08:24PM (#8456609)
And.... there are tons of fake Facebook profiles. So how does that prevent spam?
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by megablast on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:42AM (#8457200)
It just has to make it harder. The idea behind everything is just to make it harder. Captchas aren't 100%, they just make it harder.
Re:Show HN: Dating Ring (YC W14) – We do the work, you do th... by bdlbdl on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @02:21AM (#8457371)
1) It requires very little trust to FB connect a site. FB now lets you explicitly control what they can access and what they can post, very easily. This used to be an issue, but not anymore.

2) True, but when you are a startup it's better to focus on making your experience great for some people than making it OK for all people. You should definitely support non-FB users over time, but it's pretty reasonable to have a single code path at launch.