News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You Are Not Late by Animats on Sunday October 12, 2014 @03:32AM (#8444691)
I've been too early a few times. I was working on secure operating systems in the late 1970s. Proof of correctness in the early 1980s. My major work on the Internet was in the early 1980s. I was working on robotics in the 1980s, and legged robots in the 1990s. I was working on automatic driving in 2003-2005. I figured out how to stop search spam in the 2000s. I have issued patents and published papers on most of this. None of this generated much money.

(Fortunately I also did one of Autodesk's early products, and got pre-IPO stock because they couldn't afford to pay me. I also did the first ragdoll physics engine that worked, and made money off of that.)

In some ways, it's harder now, because there are so many people doing stuff in computing. In the 1980s, the number of people who knew how to make a big program work was quite small. Now everybody can do that. The few people who knew anything about AI had been to Stanford, MIT, or CMU. Now everybody serious takes machine learning class, and you can download good code for it.

There's plenty of opportunity to make money out there, but much of what people are working on is, well, pretty banal. "The best minds of my generation are thinking about how to make people click on ads. This sucks." - Jeffery Hammerbacher, Facebook.

Here's an opportunity to think about. Replace Facebook, and all the various messaging services and streaming video services, with a pay service that costs about $1 a month, with no ads. Computing has become so cheap that you can now undercut "free with ads" on price. Think of a social network as a package like Wordpress - host it anywhere, it talks to everybody else, and it just works. The authentication and spam problems are tough - solve them. There have been a few attempts at federated social networks, such as Diaspora, but the people behind them have no clue how to make them usable or popular. "Ello" is making progress on popularity, but their UI sucks and it doesn't do much. Fix all that.

If you want to do socially useful hardware, look into handheld medical devices. The medical industry tends toward big, heavy equipment designed by doctors. Dean Kamen has made a lot of money downsizing some rather clunky medical devices. Also, the UIs of systems used by doctors for medical records are awful. Doctors used to dictate medical notes. Now they have to type them, worst case on touchscreens. Make that work with voice recognition that understands not only medical terminology, but has access to the patient record for context.

Another possible area - the paperless police car. Cops hate doing paperwork. There's also a movement to make cops carry cameras. Come up with a system which takes the cop's video and audio, and fills in all the info a cop needs to book somebody. Tie the collected video and audio to that for later review if necessary. It would both help to keep cops honest and let them focus on doing their job instead of their paperwork.

So there are a few technically challenging things to do. Quit trying to find the next "Yo". That's like hoping to win the lottery.

Re:You Are Not Late by petercooper on Sunday October 12, 2014 @07:13AM (#8444985)
"The best minds of my generation are thinking about how to make people click on ads. This sucks."

Love your comment but man, I really hate this quote every time it comes up.

The "best" minds aren't doing that.. they're working on the Large Hadron Collider, doing cancer research, coming up with pioneering surgery techniques, programming and landing robots on Mars.. the relatively small group of software engineers and data scientists working on pay per click advertising are nowhere near the top of the genius ladder.

Separate thing entirely, a great example of being too early I came across recently while reading a biography of Larry Elison was Larry Ellison and the "networked computer".. only 15 years too early with that one, alas :-)

Re:You Are Not Late by chippy on Sunday October 12, 2014 @07:24AM (#8444995)
agreed about "best" but in terms of population it's not a "relatively small group" it's the majority.

They are all working to sell stuff - digital marketing for other companies or having ads as a core income for a site. They don't need to be devising the advertising frameworks, they just need to be thinking "how to make people click on ads".

Re:You Are Not Late by mcguire on Sunday October 12, 2014 @11:46AM (#8445575)
chippy, I'll agree with you about the population (the number of people working with the LHC or Mars landers---even indirectly, as the majority of Google employees aren't working on ads---is tiny compared to say, the ad- and social-media-supported technical population of Silicon Valley), but I'm going to have to disagree with "best".

The cohort of people working on the LHC, cancer research, etc., is largely the same as the faculty of any medium sized or larger university. If you went to any research-oriented university, your professors were the ones doing that kind of research. Still impressed?

Re:You Are Not Late by enraged_camel on Sunday October 12, 2014 @07:32AM (#8445006)
Hammerbacher said best minds of his generation. He is Gen Y. And the problems you listed require more domain expertise than most Gen Y people have today. I mean, pioneering surgery techniques? One needs to be a surgeon for a few decades before they can pioneer anything in that area.
Re:You Are Not Late by jamesisaac on Sunday October 12, 2014 @10:43AM (#8445397)
I presumed it was a reference to employees of Facebook/Google/etc? I.e. some of the most talented engineers aspire to work for companies whose purpose is to become the dominant ad distribution network.
Re:You Are Not Late by beaner on Sunday October 12, 2014 @11:31AM (#8445531)
Most of the employees of those companies do not work on those problems. This seriously underappreciates all of the amazing products, open source work, and research that these companies have provided - and that is what the vast majority of their employees work on.
Re:You Are Not Late by jamesisaac on Sunday October 12, 2014 @11:56AM (#8445620)
Well, agreed that they don't directly work on those problems, but as far as I'm aware, these companies make no profits from "products, open source work, and research" - it's practically all from the advertising which can be integrated with, or come as a result of, those ventures.

I'm not looking to discredit the work of talented individuals at those companies - just pointing out that the driving force behind where innovative efforts are focused by senior management is likely to be what can generate the most ad revenue.

That was my interpretation of the quote - so not a literal "they all spend most of their time thinking about ads", but "they're employed by a company whose success is driven by how many ads get clicked".

Re:You Are Not Late by skybrian on Sunday October 12, 2014 @02:44PM (#8446178)
It's still a dumb quote. Discounting important projects because of where their money comes from makes no sense. For example, Google's search engine is an amazing achievement. Switching to subscriptions would not make it technically any better or more useful to its users.
Re:You Are Not Late by jamesisaac on Sunday October 12, 2014 @03:02PM (#8446225)
I think you'd find that would make it better, because the top results would no longer be ads belonging to the highest bidders, but would actually be the most useful and relevant links.

Yes, you can avoid this by having an adblocker installed or being savvy enough to recognise what is and isn't an ad, but that doesn't apply to the majority. Just did a search now with adblock disabled, and 70% of the page is taken up by ads that look extremely similar to organic results.

Can't find the link right now, but there was a well documented case about companies who buy Google ads for things which should be provided free via the government, and slap a large processing fee on top of it. These companies end up making big yearly profits by duping people who don't know any better, and trust Google to show them relevant results, not realising that it's actually showing them the most lucrative results first.

Yeah that one might not bother you, but it's just one example... there are many more ways, some a lot more subtle, that having a primary focus of ad revenue degrades the quality of products.

Re:You Are Not Late by skybrian on Sunday October 12, 2014 @04:44PM (#8446537)
They are always marked. For me, ad blindness works almost as well as an ad blocker. Of course not for everyone, or people wouldn't pay for the ads.

On the other hand, making money from ads requires attracting users at very large scale. You can see this with Facebook and Google who try to make their product universally used, to the point where they have major initiatives to make their services available in third-world countries.

A subscription-based service deliberately leaves out people who are unwilling to pay. Even if those who do pay get better service (sometimes but not always true), there is a loss of utility from serving fewer users, particularly on the low end.

Re:You Are Not Late by jamesisaac on Sunday October 12, 2014 @04:57PM (#8446574)
"Ads or subscription-based" is a false dichotomy though. There are many other options (https://gist.github.com/ndarville/4295324) which don't require excluding those who can't pay, and don't, as the quote describes, revolve around getting people to click more ads.
Re:You Are Not Late by dakrisht on Sunday October 12, 2014 @03:42AM (#8444699)
Might have to print this out and paste on a wall in the office. Awesome

Unfortunately, a lot of young kids are wired to look for the next Yo and or spend their energy and talents on things that don't really matter. It's crazy out there - the whole "make an app, get users and cash out quickly" mindset. It's very bad and is a major reason why we see so many crap companies and apps launching all the time. But this won't last. Andreessen had a good tweet today "your startup is not the next WhatsApp." And it isn't. The 0.01% chance of this happening, already happened.

There are so many exciting and important problems that need smart people to solve them. Everything you've mentioned from the downright garbage that are EMRs at hospitals, to massive medical devices that can be shrunk, to endless paper work for cops and so many other industries who still use scanning and OCR software to organize their databases. Large but seemingly not-that-complex (from an engineering standpoint) problems. These - these need to be fixed.

Re:You Are Not Late by ColinCera on Sunday October 12, 2014 @11:21AM (#8445496)
I see a bunch of startup listing services springing up, e.g., Product Hunt and at least three others that have landed in my mailbox in the past couple weeks, which send out a daily list of new / newly discovered startups.

It's kind of amazing that these services can find 30 or 40 new startups every single day -- a thousand per month, 12,000 per year -- and, even more amazingly, I suspect they're only capturing a small percentage of the real total.

From what I could tell after a couple of exhausting weeks reading these emails at least 99% of these startups are almost completely unnecessary. I'm not using "99%" and "completely unnecessary" as rhetorical bludgeons; I mean quite literally that less than 1% of these startups have anything more than the tiniest smidgen of utility or innovation to justify their existence.

I stopped reading those "startup news" emails because it was depressing to see so much talent and effort being squandered. I don't know exactly what else all these people could/should be working on, but if they can't find some genuinely useful ideas for startups then they (and the world in general) would be better off to just spend their spare time volunteering or reading books or hiking or having coffee with friends.

Re:You Are Not Late by sanderjd on Sunday October 12, 2014 @02:26PM (#8446108)
> they (and the world in general) would be better off to just spend their spare time volunteering or reading books or hiking or having coffee with friends

But those aren't the viable alternatives! These aren't typically wealthy people with time on their hands, they're people trying to find a good place for themselves in the economy by working on something that they think people will like. The real alternative is working for a bigger company, in which their marginal contribution may or may not be more useful to themselves and society, depending on the company, and on their role in it. It's possible to do something useful either as a big cog in a small machine or a small cog in a big machine, but there's no guarantee either way.

What I'd really like to see would be more "small businesses" and fewer "startups", but the economics of the software industry at the moment don't seem to encourage that.

Re:You Are Not Late by greenyoda on Sunday October 12, 2014 @09:34PM (#8447170)
"What I'd really like to see would be more 'small businesses' and fewer 'startups', but the economics of the software industry at the moment don't seem to encourage that."

My guess is that there are currently many more small software businesses than startups, but we don't hear a lot about them because (1) they're targeting business segments that we're not familiar with (e.g., writing accounting software for law practices, or creating web-based front ends for legacy COBOL systems) and (2) the media doesn't find them compelling enough to report on.

Re:You Are Not Late by sanderjd on Monday October 13, 2014 @12:00PM (#8449226)
That definitely has the ring of truth, thanks for giving me some perspective!
Re:You Are Not Late by CmonDev on Sunday October 12, 2014 @05:35AM (#8444859)
Isn't it better to solve tough niche problems while being on a salary or already rich and experienced instead of adding that to an already hard problem of starting up a business?
Re:You Are Not Late by ColinCera on Sunday October 12, 2014 @11:26AM (#8445514)
That's somewhat true, and to the extent it's true, it's an argument for why most people shouldn't be doing startups -- if you're not yet able to start a business that solves a genuine problem, then don't start a business.
Re:You Are Not Late by lukeschlather on Sunday October 12, 2014 @01:49PM (#8445983)
> Here's an opportunity to think about. Replace Facebook, and all the various messaging services and streaming video services, with a pay service that costs about $1 a month, with no ads.

Whatsapp did a tiny sliver of that - they got acquired by Facebook. It's a trap.

The social network needs to be run by a non-profit.

Re:You Are Not Late by icebraining on Sunday October 12, 2014 @03:34PM (#8446320)
Nonprofits can be acquired too (maybe not the org itself, but everything including staff¹). The reason most don't is because the people who run it are usually not interested, but you can get the same result with a for-profit company. Just don't let VCs invest :)

¹ http://www.citylab.com/commute/2013/05/what-happens-when-non...

Re:You Are Not Late by lukeschlather on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @12:10PM (#8454085)
You can build a charter that makes that sort of thing functionally impossible.

Strong data protection guidelines that prohibit giving third-parties access to data would be a starting place, but there are a lot of barriers you could put up to such an outcome (barriers that wouldn't be possible for a for-profit corporation.)

Re:You Are Not Late by msutherl on Sunday October 12, 2014 @11:22AM (#8445503)
"Yo" is the next Facebook.