News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by click170 on Sunday October 12, 2014 @02:11AM (#8444562)
I get it, their business model is to sell the appliance for cheap and recoup the costs on the K-cups. But this DRM "solution" is anti-consumer, anti-competition, and isn't something I'm comfortable supporting. When my Keurig dies, I will be downgrading to a coffee-pot style machine, and in the meantime I will be avoiding the non-"pirate" Kcups.

I hope they turn around with their next versions, I enjoy the convenience even at the higher cost. But I draw the line at new DRM. I concede there is already DRM in my home, but my goal is to eliminate it all, not add more.

Edit: To be fair not all DRM is bad. DRM in Linux that prevents modules I haven't signed from loading would be a Good Thing so to clarify, my goal is to eliminate harmful DRM. Defined as anything I don't have full control over.

Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by cududa on Sunday October 12, 2014 @02:57AM (#8444645)
If "DRM'ing" cups was anti-competitive why haven't there been any third-party making cheap keurig-like machines for use with the cups on which the patent expired?
Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by jaak on Sunday October 12, 2014 @09:10AM (#8445178)
There are some K-cup compatible machines available (like http://www.amazon.com/MCU-Single-Multi-Use-Coffee-Brewer/dp/... ). I think the reason you don't hear about them much is Keurig really dominates the market.
Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by girvo on Sunday October 12, 2014 @09:41AM (#8445239)
Here in Australia, there is, at least we have one at home. No idea what brand it is, but the cups are different to a regular keurig, and far easier to find (and cheap!)
Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by Vendan on Monday October 13, 2014 @05:03PM (#8450652)
There's tons. My wife found one for about $20 that also has a fancy basket thing, so we don't even need the "reusable coffee pod" junk for normal coffee
Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by colinbartlett on Sunday October 12, 2014 @05:22AM (#8444844)
Because there's no money in the machine. The profit comes entitely from the coffee pods.
Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by FollowSteph3 on Sunday October 12, 2014 @07:05AM (#8444974)
Then the price for "standard" or "compatible" machines need to increase. A company who offered this could potentially make some good money...
Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by dllthomas on Sunday October 12, 2014 @05:09PM (#8446611)
Only if they are able to convince people that paying more up front is worth while for cheaper cups. That's always been a tough sell, even if it's correct.
Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by colinbartlett on Monday October 13, 2014 @06:15PM (#8450979)
It seems like American consumers especially, have a hard time with the "higher upfront for cheaper in the long run" way of thinking.

Look at all these cell phone companies that lock consumers into a two year contract with a much higher monthly premium than an alternative prepaid service. $200 phone + $100/month is somehow much more palatable than $800 phone + $50/month.

Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by icebraining on Sunday October 12, 2014 @02:49AM (#8444628)
DRM in Linux that prevents modules I haven't signed from loading would be a Good Thing

I don't think that has anything to do with DRM, can you explain?

Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by gizmo686 on Sunday October 12, 2014 @02:56AM (#8444643)
The technology required to prevent untrusted modules is the same as is required for effective DRM. In both cases, you need to keep the computer operating in a known and approved state.

The difference is that in the Linux example, the user controls the keys that is necessary to determine what such a state is, whereas with DRM the user necessarily does not.

Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by icebraining on Sunday October 12, 2014 @03:21AM (#8444675)
Oh, sure, the tech might be the same, but I don't think we should muddle the terms. DRM is defined by the purpose of the tech, not by implementation details. Calling security features "good DRM" is perilous.
Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by ObviousScience on Sunday October 12, 2014 @05:17AM (#8444833)
I use trusted computing channels/methods to handle sensitive documents and prevent unauthorized programs from interacting with the data.

It's literally DRM, and I think it's a good thing, because it lets me protect sensitive information from theft.

Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by icebraining on Sunday October 12, 2014 @07:10AM (#8444984)
If you're not trying to protect data from the user itself, I'd still say it's not DRM. What counts is the goal, not the technology. DRM was certainly a motivation for the development of TC, but that doesn't mean all uses of TC are necessarily DRM.
Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by click170 on Sunday October 12, 2014 @11:49AM (#8445584)
I agree that DRM is most often used against the user but I disagree that it has to be used against the user for it to be called DRM. DRM is Digital Rights Management, there is nothing in the name about being used against a specific group of people. I could use it to prevent you from playing a song just as I could use it to prevent unsigned kernel modules from loading on a secure system, the only difference is that DRM is so often used against us consumers that the colloquial definition is shifting away from including things which are technically DRM but which aren't used against you.

This is the same kind of thing that happened to the "native advertising" people who hide adverts as news stories and wonder why people have come yo loath the term native advertising. They've unintrntionally established a colloquial definition that is actually quite distant from the textbook definition through their abuse. I argue the same has happened to DRM.

Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by icebraining on Monday October 13, 2014 @10:28AM (#8448832)
DRM is Digital Rights Management, there is nothing in the name about being used against a specific group of people.

No, but we had those systems before, we just call it "security" and "authorization layer". DRM arose, as far as I know, to describe copy-protection mechanisms like SecuROM.

They've unintrntionally established a colloquial definition that is actually quite distant from the textbook definition through their abuse. I argue the same has happened to DRM.

Maybe so, but then I never got the original definition, and I don't understand why there was the need for a new term when authorization layers are old as dirt.

Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by ObviousScience on Sunday October 12, 2014 @08:00PM (#8446987)
It's a shared system, in that other people can access the same server the files are actually located on. The DRM is definitely meant to stop other users of the system from accessing the files, and only permit me to view it through a thin terminal when showing the proper credentials.

You seem to have an ideological need to call DRM bad in all cases and tell me how every other use of DRM is not "True DRM!", but I'm using it to stop people with access to the server from being able to open certain files even if they somehow break other security features which should prevent them from even getting access to the bits.

I'm not sure how much more DRM you can get than stopping people from viewing content unless they show their credentials to prove they're an authorized user.

Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by icebraining on Monday October 13, 2014 @10:23AM (#8448811)
and only permit me to view it through a thin terminal when showing the proper credentials.

Yes, which is why I wrote it's not DRM if you're not trying to protect data from the user itself. In that case, you are.

I'm using it to stop people with access to the server from being able to open certain files even if they somehow break other security features which should prevent them from even getting access to the bits. I'm not sure how much more DRM you can get than stopping people from viewing content unless they show their credentials to prove they're an authorized user.

I'm using the UNIX filesystem permissions for that. Is UNIX DRM now?

As far as I know, DRM as a term arose to describe the technologies that tried to allow the user to view the content while preventing him/her from copying it.

You seem to have an ideological need to call DRM bad in all cases and tell me how every other use of DRM is not "True DRM!"

No, I'm just trying to make sense of the fact that people are using a term in a different way than I've always seen it used, and which happens to be (in my opinion) much less useful, since it turns any authorization layer into "DRM".

Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by sliverstorm on Sunday October 12, 2014 @03:34AM (#8444692)
So what is the answer? Are we essentially rejecting the business model of "cheap appliance, recoup costs"?
Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by infogulch on Sunday October 12, 2014 @04:28PM (#8446489)
How about rejecting "cheap appliance; recoup costs with shady, anticompetitive business practices"
Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by sliverstorm on Sunday October 12, 2014 @05:02PM (#8446586)
It's inherent to the business model to block out competition on the "recoup" item. What business sells the appliance at a loss and meekly accepts being overrun by third-party suppliers? Dead businesses, that's who...
Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by TeMPOraL on Sunday October 12, 2014 @08:46AM (#8445133)
Yup, I think we should, because it leads to the world where appliances suck.
Re:When Keurig fights “coffee pirates,” who loses? Loyal con... by sliverstorm on Sunday October 12, 2014 @04:26PM (#8446483)
Downside: the model is "progressive", where more people can afford to use the appliance because it is subsidized by people with high usage. So if we axe that model, product X becomes inaccessible to many people.