News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by pan69 on Saturday October 11, 2014 @06:15AM (#8441759)
I'm no grammar Nazi but the first sentence on this website had me completely tripped up:

>> Linux distribution is well-tested collection of packages carefully organized and supported by the vendor.

wat?

Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by pessimizer on Saturday October 11, 2014 @08:00AM (#8441920)
It's just article-dropping; get to know a few Eastern Europeans well and you might start doing it yourself.

One of my old bosses was Bosnian Croat, dropped articles like crazy, and added them in the wrong places. She would run her important emails by me for article-fixing before sending them. She was still smarter than me and better at her job than I was. Turns out that mastery of the arbitrary rules of English article placement and choice isn't a very good indicator of intelligence or competence.

Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by ianlevesque on Saturday October 11, 2014 @05:50PM (#8443530)
No, but still a useful skill when communicating in English.
Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by deathanatos on Saturday October 11, 2014 @07:14AM (#8441853)
> I'm no grammar Nazi but

Our author seems to consistently make the same mistake: there's a distinct lack of articles in the writing. Sprinkle some in, and things start to make sense:

> [A] Linux distribution is [a] well-tested collection of packages

> we would like to have [an] internal mirror of [a] package repository

> some packages are missing in [the] official distribution

> we would like to own [a] package repository, that is to have [a] package repository

> There are many tools to create [a] mirror of [the] Debian package repositories

… and so on. At any rate, this consistency suggests (to me, at least) that he's probably not a native English speaker; in fact, the writer is almost certainly Russian. There's a link to a sponsor, which has a Russian phone number, and if you click around enough, you can find his CV quite easily.

Not everyone on the Internet speaks English, however, enough people do that I could easily see it being beneficial to put your content in English. Who knows?

Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by eLobato on Saturday October 11, 2014 @07:42AM (#8441894)
For some reason, native speakers of Slavic languages who learn English as a second language, often omit some prepositions in English. It's 100% understandable, but I'm really curious what's the actual reason why this happens.
Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by groovy2shoes on Saturday October 11, 2014 @08:22AM (#8441957)
Not sure about prepositions, but the articles are often omitted because most Slavic languages don't have articles.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_%28grammar%29#Variation...

Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by ithinkso on Saturday October 11, 2014 @09:15AM (#8442043)
Funny thing is, when we(native speakers of Slavic languages) read such english text with omitted articles we do understand it as intended and often we do not even realize that it's missing something.
Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by szabba on Saturday October 11, 2014 @08:07AM (#8441934)
It probably has something to do with out languages having more grammatical cases than English (which, arguably, has two, though it's possible to only use one).
Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by smira on Saturday October 11, 2014 @06:58AM (#8441822)
Sorry for my bad English.

Does this sound better:

"Linux distribution is a well-tested collection of packages that are carefully organized and supported by the vendor."

Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by pluma on Saturday October 11, 2014 @09:10AM (#8442034)
Grammar aside, I'd say the plural feels more natural in this case:

"Linux distributions are well-tested collections of packages …"

But for singular you need to qualify "Linux distribution":

"A Linux distribution is a well-tested collection of packages …"

And I'd probably say "by a vendor" instead of "by the vendor" as it's not clear you're talking about a specific vendor.

Also, the "a" is wrong in this:

"There’s a support for …"

This should be: "There is support for …", in other words: "Support exists for …". Support is non-countable (like water, peace or terrorism) in English.

As a rule of thumb:

* if it's non-countable, just leave it bare: "I bought water", "It has support", "This is murder". * if you're referring to a specific instance of something the audience knows about or you're going to qualify, use "the": "I bought the house [I previously told you about]", "I shot the gopher that kept digging up my lawn". * otherwise use "a": "I bought a house" (this is news to you), "I ran over a cat" (if you say "the cat", the listener would instantly think "which one?").

English is "fun".

Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by pbhjpbhj on Saturday October 11, 2014 @07:59PM (#8443788)
In English (en-gb) colloquialism "I ran over the cat" would be perfectly fine as "the cat" is understood to mean "our/my cat". "Your dinner's in the dog", "I locked the keys in the car", et cetera.

Similarly in a sentence like "Why don't you and the family come up to the house sometime for tea.". "The house" substitutes for "our house". Now all you need to work out is whether tea is afternoon tea, a cup of tea, or an evening meal and if the offer is sincere. I gather the response is supposed to be "That would be lovely." rather than actually trying to arrange the proffered social meeting.

Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by pluma on Sunday October 12, 2014 @08:58AM (#8445160)
Sure, but presume neither the speaker nor the recipient owns a cat. Without an obvious context ("the cat"? what cats could we both know of?), it's not entirely clear.

Saying "the" instead of "a" generally assumes a context that has either been established before during the conversation or outside of it.

Imagine a stranger telling you they "accidentally killed the koala". You'd be confused. Not that strangers telling you about exotic animals they accidentally killed wouldn't be confusing enough.

Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by pbhjpbhj on Sunday October 12, 2014 @11:38AM (#8445549)
I wasn't disagreeing I was just adding extra depth to what you said. Yes it's not entirely clear language, that's why it's colloquialism rather than being adopted as proper speech/writing.

Like you say "the item" means there should be an antecedent [previous mention].

If someone said they'd "killed the koala" I'd assume it was a euphemism for something!!

Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by dllthomas on Monday October 13, 2014 @02:22PM (#8449864)
English has a countable "support" - it can be used to refer to several physical objects in various structural contexts (architecture being one). That is not the sense in which it's being used here, though.
Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by codeflo on Saturday October 11, 2014 @07:17AM (#8441855)
The missing article at the start of the sentence makes it very hard to decipher if you're talking about Linux distributions in general or a specific one. "A Linux distrubution is ..." is probably what you intended to say, but I'm not sure.
Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by smira on Saturday October 11, 2014 @07:28AM (#8441876)
Thanks for your suggestions!
Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by robinson-wall on Saturday October 11, 2014 @07:59AM (#8441918)
Have you considered making the website / documentation source available in github? That would make it very easy for others to contribute suggestions.
Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by smira on Saturday October 11, 2014 @09:36AM (#8442089)
It is actually available: https://github.com/aptly-dev/aptly-dev.github.io/tree/trunk

In trunk branch, the markdown under content/ folder.

Re:Aptly: Owning Your Debian Distribution by padraic7a on Sunday October 12, 2014 @10:22AM (#8445347)
I see you've just added changes, are you looking for anyone to proof read at this stage?