Re:The Horror of a 'Secure Golden Key'
by freshhawk on Thursday October 09, 2014 @05:03PM
(#8435013)
> If the key was only ever going to be kept in a secure vault buried under Fort Knox forever, it would probably not constitute a significant vulnerability
I think that's the main point when people disagree about this kind of thing. One side says "but theoretically our fort knox vault solution would be secure" and the other side says "What I just heard you say is 'If I sprinkle magic pixie dust around this intentional vulnerability and ignore it then it would be secure' and that's ridiculous, a group of humans would not almost certainly not act securely around that vault because they never have".
Of course the "other side" is right, but people don't think that way naturally so this kind of proposal/argument keeps coming up.
The problem is that government agencies have demonstrated very clearly that they will use such a key as often and as liberally as they can get away with. Every time the key is brought out and used, it becomes vulnerable to interception or disclosure to the point where pretending that it is sure to be safe is just completely out of touch with reality.