News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by jobu on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:36PM (#8423468)
The government’s position, the complaint said, “forces Twitter either to engage in speech that has been preapproved by government officials or else to refrain from speaking altogether.”

Isn't that the definition of censorship? I'm surprised they don't actually use that word in the lawsuit: http://www.washingtonpost.com/r/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/201...

Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by biot on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @05:16PM (#8424060)
If you present a conclusion, your opponent can claim it's an invalid conclusion based on faulty premises. However, if you only present evidence-backed facts, your opponent can't argue against the evidence and you force your opponent to reveal their hand earlier. In this case, the hand being revealed is ultimately one of national security... but by structuring the argument in this way, they are likely to avoid a prolonged argument with the government over the conclusion's validity.
Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by neumann on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @01:33PM (#8428189)
This is a fantasticly instructive comment. thanks.
Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:52PM (#8423581)
The language they do use is familiar,I suspect from precedent that establishes a test for violation of the free speech clause. Which is probably why they use it, and not the fuzzier term censorship. A legal complaint has a different audience than a press release.
Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by rayiner on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @01:32AM (#8425449)
"Censorship" isn't unconstitutional (e.g. obscenities laws). Certain kinds of censorship may be, and they have specific names.
Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by adventured on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @04:28AM (#8425849)
That's an interesting statement. I regard obscenities laws to be unconstitutional. Specifically, to be extremely anti-free speech and anti-free press (depending). All forms of censorship are unconstitutional and blatant violations of the first amendment.

Given the countless flawed or flat-out wrong positions the Supreme Court has taken over the centuries when it comes to individual rights, I think we can likely agree they are not always right in their conclusions.

Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by rayiner on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @07:51AM (#8426400)
The exceptions to the first amendment are largely rooted in historical practice, which informs what the founders would have understood the scope of free speech to be. I don't think its a supportable statement that they would have understood all forms of censorship to violate the first amendment.
Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by cwp on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @02:56PM (#8428746)
The point is that the constitution doesn't mention "censorship". You may be right that censorship does violate the first amendment, but there are precedents that establish that censorship is permissible in certain circumstances.

Twitter's best line of argument is to go directly to violation of their First Amendment rights, and avoid getting side-tracked on questions of "is this censorship" and "is censorship constitutional in the general case".

Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by tobylane on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @01:34PM (#8428198)
>In Rosen v. United States (1896), the Supreme Court adopted the same obscenity standard as had been articulated in a famous British case, Regina v. Hicklin (1868). The Hicklin test defined material as obscene if it tended "to deprave or corrupt those whose minds are open to such immoral influences, and into whose hands a publication of this sort may fall."

They weren't trying to constitutionally base it. Does that help?

Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by pessimizer on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @07:26AM (#8426325)
Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by someone234 on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @09:42AM (#8426792)
Well, the Constitution says everyone has the right to say anything they want. That's what "free speech" means, and that includes things that someone thinks are "obscene".

Not that the government gives a fuck, but still, just to be clear about what we're discussing here. But yeah, "obscenities laws" are most certainly unconstitutional.

Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by rayiner on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @11:39AM (#8427472)
The Constitution says, "Congress shall make no law . . . abridging the freedom of speech."

What is "the freedom of speech?"

You can take it literally: the freedom to say anything you can speak. You probably don't want to go down that route, because the obvious corollary is: "fine, then the First Amendment doesn't cover publication, electronic communications, or expression" because those things are outside the dictionary definition of "speech."

You can also treat it as a phrase that has meaning in context, like "object" does in computer science. But you can't have your cake and eat it too: the same interpretive process the Supreme Court has used to create exceptions to the freedom of speech has also been used to take the freedom far beyond what literally qualifies as "speech." This is particularly true if you're talking about obscenities laws, which mostly deal with things like images and performances which aren't literally speech.

Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by tptacek on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @10:53AM (#8427170)
That's an argument that suggests that libel and fraud laws are also unconstitutional.
Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by pjc50 on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @10:14AM (#8426938)
Hasn't the supreme court ruled otherwise, and the supreme court gets to determine what's constitutional as per article 3?
Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by blackaspen on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:50PM (#8423576)
Supposing the word 'censorship' isn't censored...

Really happy to see more companies doing this though!

Re:Twitter sues U.S. government over ability to disclose sur... by pessimizer on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @07:22AM (#8426310)
That's the implication of the complaint; it's saying 'prior restraint' without saying it.