Re:Finding a Video Poker Bug Made These Guys Rich
by mattzito on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @01:32PM
(#8422550)
...but he lied. If they had said, "Hey, why do you want this?" and he said, "I think I've got a system for beating baccarat", and they went ahead anyway, they're idiots.
But they asked and he said that he was just superstitious, it was for luck. At that point he was being disingenuous.
Was it legal? Probably, I'm not a lawyer. Was it ethical? I'm leaning towards no.
Re:Finding a Video Poker Bug Made These Guys Rich
by CDRdude on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @01:38PM
(#8422596)
In a great many circumstances (i.e. not testifying in court), lying is not illegal. If you're lying to a casino, I don't think it's even immoral.
Re:Finding a Video Poker Bug Made These Guys Rich
by CaveTech on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @01:45PM
(#8422655)
Being disingenuous is not a crime, in fact, it's incredibly common. No one should be compelled to reveal their true intentions, regardless of if they're in good faith or bad.
Intentions are subjective, actions are not.
Re:Finding a Video Poker Bug Made These Guys Rich
by toomuchtodo on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @01:39PM
(#8422605)
There is a large valley between lying and fraud.
Phil Ivey's edge sorting hack is phenomenal. That the casino thinks they should be insulated from smart players is unfortunate but it is their prerogative to refuse play. However, it absolutely should NOT be possible to claw back winnings from players who were NOT cheating, only playing smartly.