News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by ChuckMcM on Monday October 06, 2014 @04:12PM (#8417976)
Here is a suggestion, tell them to state their intentions or go away. Once they state their intentions tell them they have to sign a Memorandum of Understanding about what you're going to talk about and if they walk away it will cost them $X million (pick a number that would be able to resolve your debts and pay off any investors with a slight return).

What ever you do, do NOT be lured into thinking they are thinking about maybe a big exit for you, your interests are not aligned yet and you need to realize that. If there is any IP possible make sure you have provisional patents filed before you talk to them about anything. Even if you don't think it is patentable, force them to either buy you or risk infringing you if they go into competition with you.

Seriously, you have nothing to gain from this distraction if they aren't serious, and if they are serious they will put it in writing for you.

Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by mblevin on Monday October 06, 2014 @07:39PM (#8418980)
As a former M&A guy and later a founder - It's not just that your interests aren't aligned in terms of financials or IP, your timelines aren't aligned and your desired outcomes aren't aligned.

There is ZERO hurry with a lot of BigCo acquisitions - there are layers and layers of board approvals, analysis, opportunity costs, competitor research, etc.

There may not be any actual interest in an acquisition of people or technology, but rather a curiosity about the space - e.g. "what are smart and hungry people in X space capable of actually building?" or "what does technology Y in the wild actually look like?"

It's all fun and games for the BigCo but can absolutely kill a startup with delays and 180 degree turns on the product roadmap.

Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by lateguy on Monday October 06, 2014 @11:06PM (#8419502)
@mblevin Completely agree with this. I went throught this from a startup perspective.
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by saanilb on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @12:11AM (#8419633)
@mblevin completely agree with you. Bigco will take its own sweat time to close, so better focus on product launch and have parallel discussion on acquisition.
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by ryanhuff on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @12:34AM (#8419673)
Parallel tracks is very tough for a 3 person team and not sacrifice the product.
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by saanilb on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @01:06PM (#8422351)
@ryanhuff ya, can understand. then 1 person can focus the discussion and other 2 can be on product. I know easy to tell, but really difficult to practice. :(
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by bengali3 on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @02:42PM (#8423075)
BigCo know this too :)
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by jbverschoor on Monday October 06, 2014 @04:27PM (#8418074)
Yup.

Had a similar story here, but didn't have that in place.

Very educational and made some good contacts though.

In the end there was not a deal we could live with, so we ended up with no deal. But also with 6 months of almost 100% delay for us. Total loss of focus.

Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by Lops on Monday October 06, 2014 @06:33PM (#8418727)
Agreed on delay, these things are very time consuming.
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by simonswords82 on Monday October 06, 2014 @08:31PM (#8419139)
Yep - had a similar experience with our little start up about one and a half years ago. I would have saved a lot of time and second guessing by making them put their cards on the table at the outset. Instead I dicked around providing info and data and eventually we came to the conclusion a deal couldn't work - but only after I'd spilled my guts thinking I was about to land the big one...
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by feverishaaron on Monday October 06, 2014 @05:49PM (#8418515)
Excellent advice. We lost a lot of time "working with" a large company, including building a detailed demo using part of their platform – and it ended up coming to nothing.
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by throwaway__x on Monday October 06, 2014 @06:09PM (#8418614)
Right, I get that, but at the same time how can we expect them to buy something or commit cold hard cash when they are pretty much in the dark?
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by trcollinson on Monday October 06, 2014 @07:19PM (#8418900)
I'll give you a more specific example from my past. A startup seemed interesting to the large fortune 50 company I was working with. We, the large company, had a rather large budget to buy them, like 7 figures, not bad for a company without a published v1 and with no revenue. We did not specifically say how much we were willing to give or what we were willing to do for them, because that is negotiation. On the other hand, they hide behind lawyers, talked to us only generally, and left us in the dark. In the end we decided the time wasn't worth it (their technical skills and product offering sure were, but that's another story), so we ended the discussions. Ultimately they ran out of funding and said it was our "large companies distractions" that kept them from "making it big". Maybe that is true, I can't rewrite history to know for sure whether it is or not. However, what I can say is if they had said "Sure we're willing to show what we can do, we want $x,000,000 if we can show we are capable", we would have given it to them. Hell we would have paid for the due diligence ("We want $200,000 to go through your due diligence whether we make a deal or not" would have been a very acceptable request). Your milage WILL vary, but remember business, funding, and moving forward can take a number of routes.
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by karl_gluck on Monday October 06, 2014 @06:23PM (#8418684)
That's their decision. You don't have to make it easy for them--especially if they are going to be your competitors.

For a motivated big company, cold hard cash isn't as hard to come by as you might think.

As for now, the only thing I can do is echo how absolutely crucial it is for you to have a knowledgable lawyer on your side RIGHT NOW. Get several on the phone today, and make a decision as soon as you can. If you're in the Dallas/Fort Worth area, I can make a recommendation but please, please do this.

Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by apinstein on Monday October 06, 2014 @06:55PM (#8418818)
While it never hurts to have a good lawyer, if you are ever in a contemplating a deal where you say something like this to yourself: "they can't do that to us, we have a contract", you're already screwed. I have gotten screwed too many times on this, despite spending tons on lawyers ahead of time.

Bottom line, make a deal that is a WIN WIN and doesn't put you at huge risk w/o some offset you consider reasonable or don't do a deal at all.

You do not have an easy road ahead, but you can at least avoid a disaster. Remember, your BATNA is continuing your startup as if you'd never been approached!

Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by deeths on Monday October 06, 2014 @07:41PM (#8418985)
What sort of information have you shared already?
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by throwaway__x on Monday October 06, 2014 @07:47PM (#8419006)
Enough for them to realize they can either buy us or spend the next year with a team of at least 5 people replicating it. We didn't share anything that got them to realize we are now unnecessary, quite the opposite in fact.
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by bagels on Monday October 06, 2014 @04:57PM (#8418260)
Right, so they're either trying to buy you, or trying to steal information. Seems like you'd want to establish which.
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by x0x0 on Monday October 06, 2014 @04:44PM (#8418184)
Yeah, remember how best buy had to pay out $25m for stealing a startups IP -- http://techcrunch.com/2012/12/05/techforward-wins-27m-in-law...
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by mbesto on Monday October 06, 2014 @10:33PM (#8419444)
This. Focus on your launch.

Launch and then talk. Depending on how big the company is, it'll take them most likely at least 3 months to get a deal done.

Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by jwilliams on Monday October 06, 2014 @05:58PM (#8418558)
Unfortunately only have one upvote. All the above is true.
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by ecesena on Monday October 06, 2014 @05:12PM (#8418336)
I'd also recommend provisional applications for patent. They don't cost much and they're an asset anyway.

If you're seriously oriented towards an aquire-hire, an option can also be to look for an experienced corporate dev to join you as an advisor or as part of the team.

Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by pnathan on Monday October 06, 2014 @06:17PM (#8418649)
I would also add to this: lawyer up.
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by adammichaelc on Monday October 06, 2014 @07:04PM (#8418845)
This is excellent advice!
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by tiatia on Monday October 06, 2014 @04:18PM (#8418017)
Just stick to this advice.
Re:Ask HN: Big company approached our stealth startup – what... by beachstartup on Monday October 06, 2014 @04:36PM (#8418138)
i have never been in this situation but i like this answer.

what you're doing is forcing them to negotiate as soon as possible on something specific and concrete - someone who isn't willing to negotiate isn't willing to give you any money.