News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by guelo on Monday October 06, 2014 @02:12PM (#8417236)
Cuba was the world's best experiment in total communism. Unfortunately the US ruined the experiment by imposing an embargo for decades out of spite. Still, when you compare Cuba to neighboring Dominican Republic they're doing better under many measures, including health, education and a GNP per capita of $5890 vs DR's $5620.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by jacobolus on Monday October 06, 2014 @02:35PM (#8417372)
Cuba did much better than all the Latin American countries that allowed the US to dominate them; it’s quite amazing, considering the economic strain put on by the embargo.

Though the Cuban regime was hardly friendly to dissidents, journalists, or activists, and hardly democratic (to say the least), their actions are nothing compared to the fascist police states backed by the US up through the 1980s throughout Latin America.

It’s really not until the 1990s when the US stopped worrying quite so much about Communism and focused our attention elsewhere in the world that most of Latin America was able to start acting more autonomously and solving their own problems. US relative non-involvement for the past 25 years has seen the growth of democracy, checks on the power of militaries, de-escalation of border conflicts and increasing economic cooperation.

One can only wonder what would have happened if the US government hadn’t spent the several decades before that installing and propping up puppet dictators, and overthrowing democratic governments.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by mercurial on Monday October 06, 2014 @04:50PM (#8418219)
To be fair, the Soviet-backed police states (eg, Idi Amin's Uganda) were not particularly appealing either. Unfortunately, both parties were too involved in their little games to care about the welfare of their pawns.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by sien on Monday October 06, 2014 @10:29PM (#8419434)
Cuba got a subsidy of about 25% of GDP from the USSR. [1]

It's also worth noting that Cuba's per capita GDP in the late 1950s was about the same as Italy of Spain.

[1] http://www.lexingtoninstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/Cuba/su...

[

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by euccastro on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:16AM (#8419968)
That is, post-WW2 Italy, post-civil war Spain. People were migrating in droves from Italy and Spain to e.g. Argentina in those years.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by argumentum on Monday October 06, 2014 @09:17PM (#8419285)
Would you rather live, today, in Cuba or (the poster boy for malicious US intervention) Chile?
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by ahi on Monday October 06, 2014 @09:45PM (#8419344)
If I was born tomorrow, I would definitely pick Cuba (infant mortality 5/1000) instead of Chile (8/1000). United States is 6/1000 by the way.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by joeguilmette on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:26AM (#8419983)
Having spent a good month living in Havana and 5 years in other places across the globe, I can tell you that Cuba is near the bottom of the "places I would choose to be born" list.

I don't care what anyone says about their medical care - I've seen more amputees in that country than anywhere else on the planet. Crushing poverty, a brutal regime that interferes with daily life in large ways, absurdly low education even in the capital.

I have a feeling that a lot of the numbers we see about Cuba come from the government and thus should not be trusted.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by briandear on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @05:18AM (#8420237)
Thanks for this. Many people here have some romantic vision of Cuba that is influenced by well-designed Cuban operations to accomplish exactly what they're accomplishing: influencing gullible left-leaning Americans to support Cuba. I remember when I was at the University of Houston, there was a Cuban Friendship Committee that held Cuban 'cultural' events for students. Interestingly many of the students invited to those events were majors in areas of rather strategic interest: journalism students. Interesting even more so were the free and discounted trips to Cuba being covertly offered to select students. The leader of this group even assisted with obtaining Cuban travel permits from the Cuban government. Now just why would that "Friendship" committee be so friendly? I have first hand experience because I was both a journalism student, a Reuters contract photojournalist and the photo editor of the student newspaper; so I was invited to these Friendship events almost constantly. This was back in 1995-1997. There certainly wasn't any other 'student' organization offering free trips for 'cultural' exchange, except for Hillel, but that's another discussion altogether..

The point is that there is a powerful clandestine and covert effort by the Cuban government to manipulate American influencers to present the image of Cuba that is so frequently transmitted. It's exceptionally effective; just read some of the comments posted on this very thread. However the reality on the ground is much different than Michael Moore would have you believe.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by argumentum on Monday October 06, 2014 @09:54PM (#8419359)
Wow, this is the definition of myopia.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by jessaustin on Monday October 06, 2014 @10:22PM (#8419419)
If you don't like that measure, suggest another. It's not as though infant mortality is some minor thing that no one cares about.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by argumentum on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @12:01AM (#8419604)
Respect for human rights? Political liberty? Quality of life? Social Mobility? Economic opportunity?

Myopia means excessive focus on one aspect at the neglect of the whole picture.

I would consider many things in deciding where to live. Each person has different priorities, but for me the most important measure is liberty (political, economic and social).

Chile is one of the freest countries in the world (usually in the top 10 of such rankings) and Cuba is usually amongst the bottom 10.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by bildung on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:08AM (#8419956)
Chile is one of the freest countries in the world (usually in the top 10 of such rankings) and Cuba is usually amongst the bottom 10.

I'd really be interested to see a link to a ranking placing Cuba at the bottom 10 countries in the world.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by argumentum on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @11:53AM (#8421865)
Here's one for economic freedom: http://www.heritage.org/index/ranking

Chile is #7 and Cuba is #177 (only North Korea is worse, at #178)

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by bildung on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @01:38PM (#8422597)
Hehe, ok, yeah, with economic freedom it's no surprise (although with heritage.org I'd really look into the methodology...) . But freedom usually implies human rights, and economic freedom is just a means to exactly that end. A lesbian friend of mine, mother Cuban and father Spaniard, recently moved back to Cuba because of rising homophobic discrimination in Spain. She now lives with her SO in Cuba, they now both operate a café together. Her freedom (as implied by the UN Charta on human rights) certainly is higher in Cuba than in Spain.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by argumentum on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @02:28PM (#8422985)
I don't mean to question your friend's decision, and I don't know the exact situation, but this is just anecdotal evidence. Was it discrimination by the government or by fellow Spaniards in a private capacity? If it's the latter (which I'd guess), then it's not really a restriction on individual freedom.

Nonetheless, I don't think this would conform to the experiences of the vast majority of Cubans, wrt individual liberty. I know several Cubans myself who fled the Castro regime.

The UN charter on human rights also includes the right to freedom of expression, freedom of assembly, for political action etc.

Take a scale of 1 to 10. Spain may be an 8/10 when it comes to equal treatment wrt sexual orientation. For the sake of argument, let's say Cuba is 10/10 in this measure. For reference, Saudi or Iran (where you can be executed for being gay) are 1/10.

In most measures of freedom, Spain (and Chile) would be 8+ while Cuba would be 1-2/10. Here's another rating (considering political and civil liberty) where Chile/Spain come out perfect and Cuba is one of the worst: http://www.freedomhouse.org/report-types/freedom-world#.VDQw...

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by bildung on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @02:37AM (#8425558)
Thanks for your response. To make that clear: I'd be very happy if people in Cuba could experience more individual freedoms.

If it's the latter (which I'd guess), then it's not really a restriction on individual freedom.

That perhaps is the main source of our disagreement :) 'Freedom' (or similar concepts like justice) an be approached from to angles. The first is the deontological, or institutional approach, e.g. freedom is what the laws provide. The second way is the consequentialist approach: freedom is what the individual actually experiences. Both ways have advantages and disadvantages. I personally lean more towards the latter, because that approach makes it possible to differentiate between classes of people inside a society.

Another anecdote :) I live in the eastern part of Germany, which as you know was socialist 25 years ago. People could not really vote, dissidents didn't have it easy etc. The current Germany is definitily more free from an institutional viewpoint. Yet, when I look out my office window, I can reguarly see people searching for food in the dumpsters. In the dumpsters! Thats a thing that was unthinkable in the former Eastern Germany. We now have children coming to school without having breakfast because of poverty and mismanagement of their parents. That, too, was unheard of before (schools provided breakfast in those cases, there was no mass unemployment -> way less parents were like that, without hope and self-regard etc.)

People like me definitely practically profit from the new institutional freedom, people like them don't. From a consequential viewpoint on freedom, their score dropped significantly.

I've read a really nice book about the theories of freedom and justice from Amartya Sen, it's called The Idea of Justice. Highly recommended, it's both informative and approachable.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by randomafrican on Monday October 06, 2014 @05:55PM (#8418547)
Costa Rica has done as well or even better
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by wwweston on Monday October 06, 2014 @06:08PM (#8418612)
Costa Rica may be the exception that proves the rule, or at least is notable for what it didn't do -- it didn't let itself become a colony/client state/banana republic, there was a state-led internal industrialization effort integrated with measured open-ness for international trade/investment, it didn't keep a standing military after its revolution.

And Cuba likely still would have done better without the US embargo.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by randomafrican on Monday October 06, 2014 @06:24PM (#8418691)
If Communist Cuba didn't exist, may be most of those dictatorships wouldnt have happened.

And Costa Rica may be an exception because their lefties (or liberals) were smart enough to keep their eyes on the price.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by ahi on Monday October 06, 2014 @09:58PM (#8419376)
You have causation wrong. Cuba is now communist because it was one of those dictatorships. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fulgencio_Batista

The countless dictatorships, puppet governments, and US/European interventions didn't start when Castro and Che came down out of the mountains in 1956.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by crimsonalucard on Monday October 06, 2014 @06:06PM (#8418601)
Good things came out of this. The embargo prevented cuba from becoming the world's best experiment in total communism but it instead made Cuba the best and ONLY experiment in creating a sustainable "green" civilization. There is no other place on earth where this has been reproduced for an entire society in a way that works.

The Living Planet Report from the World Wildlife Fund in 2007 identified Cuba as the only sustainable country in the world. The study involved two key parameters for measuring sustainable development, a commitment to "improving the quality of human life while living within the carrying capacity of supporting ecosystems". Cuba was the ONLY country on earth to achieve satisfactory benchmarks in both criteria for sustainable development.

You have to see it to believe it. Every inch of rooftop in Cuba is basically an urban/organic farm. Essentially Cuba represents the best possible outcome when modern society finally runs out of gasoline.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by waterlesscloud on Monday October 06, 2014 @06:12PM (#8418629)
Does this then mean that the standard of living in Cuba is about what we could expect from a sustainable society?

Not being snarky (I know it could sound that way). I'm curious if that's the outcome of sustainable living.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by crimsonalucard on Monday October 06, 2014 @06:52PM (#8418805)
Unfortunately, yes. Not even driving a Tesla will make a difference.

I wouldn't think of cuban culture/society as a primitive way of life. It's just different.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by Mz on Monday October 06, 2014 @09:16PM (#8419281)
Do you have any links (in English) about this? I am having a bit of trouble finding anything really substantive. I have an unfinished environmental studies degree, so I find this interesting.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by crimsonalucard on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:25AM (#8419982)
It's surprising how almost know one knows about this, especially someone with an (albeit unfinished) environmental studies degree.

Not sure what you define as substantive but this is what I know about:

There's a documentary about the topic called, The Power of Community - How Cuba Survived Peak Oil. You can watch at the link below.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UUWces5TkCA

another dense source: http://www-pub.iaea.org/mtcd/publications/pdf/pub1328_web.pd...

google: "cuba sustainability" no quotes for a bunch of stuff.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by Mz on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @12:41PM (#8422192)
Thank you.

I had a rather lengthy medical crisis, so I was out of the loop for a long time (and it is essentially the reason my degree was not completed). It is currently resolving and I am trying to get more back in the loop on things.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by euccastro on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:21AM (#8419976)
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by drzaiusapelord on Monday October 06, 2014 @02:54PM (#8417505)
> Still, when you compare Cuba to neighboring Dominican Republic

What kind of comparison is that? The DR is practically a failed state. By any rational metric Cuba is an economic and human rights disaster and continues to be. Its other, capitalistic, neighbor Mexico has 2x that GDP per capita. Heck, its only because of Western pressure that Cuba is only now, after decades of spite against its own people, started releasing political prisoners.

http://www.hrw.org/world-report/2014/country-chapters/cuba

>Unfortunately the US ruined the experiment by imposing an embargo for decades out of spite.

Pardon me if I think my nation should tolerate nuclear missiles 90 miles off our coast from a country aligned with our enemies who have a stated doctrine of first strike and tactic nuclear usage with zero warning in advance, held by a dictator who wanted nuclear war.

http://townhall.com/tipsheet/meredithjessup/2009/09/24/nytim...

I'm all for lifting of sanctions, but Cuba needs to up its game first. Rewarding the autocratic and oppressive Castro regime makes no sense. Democratic reforms, regime change, freedom of ownership, open elections, multi-parties, the right to sue, the right to travel, a free press, the right to petition, etc must all be respected. You're not automatically entitled to my money.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by mercurial on Monday October 06, 2014 @03:09PM (#8417605)
> I'm all for lifting of sanctions, but Cuba needs to up its game first. Rewarding the autocratic and oppressive Castro regime makes no sense. Democratic reforms, regime change, freedom of ownership, open elections, multi-parties, the right to sue, the right to travel, a free press, the right to petition, etc must all be respected.

Sure. You must be demonstrating every day for the same sanctions to apply in about all the Middle East countries the US has bases in, right? Moral arguments don't really mesh with real politics. Sanctions against Cuba are a relic of the Cold War, but the US does business every day with countries with a worse humanitarian track record.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by drzaiusapelord on Monday October 06, 2014 @03:29PM (#8417737)
I'm pretty sure Saudi Arabia never had nukes pointed at us or tried to. Ignoring the reality of the cold war and the brutality of Catro's regime and pretending everything is fine now is pretty ignorant. Modern Cuba still is the same disaster its always been. Why must the US reward the Castros? Why can't they make themselves a more viable trading partner? You're not entitled to my business, plain and simple.

Whataboutism isn't addressing my issues. Sadly, knee-jerk anti-americanism passes for "intellectualism" around here. Funny how an oppressive anti-capitalist state is applauded on a forum dedicated to VC funded startups. Oh, the irony.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by mercurial on Monday October 06, 2014 @03:55PM (#8417871)
> I'm pretty sure Saudi Arabia never had nukes pointed at us or tried to.

This was in 1963. And they sure don't have nukes now, or are likely to acquire them. Not to mention that you're conveniently forgetting US nukes in Italy and Turkey around the same time, or the Bay of Pigs invasion.

> Why must the US reward the Castros?

Why should it punish the Castros while turning a blind eye to Bahrain, who is busy oppressing its population with a brutality the Castro regime hasn't displayed in a long while?

> Whataboutism isn't addressing my issues.

If you didn't address the issue from a moral angle, your position may look a bit more solid than it is right now. Why not admit morality has a very small role to play in international politics, whatever narrative government dress it up in for internal consumption?

> Sadly, knee-jerk anti-americanism passes for "intellectualism" around here.

Oh, I'm not giving a pass to any government, don't worry.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by bildung on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:13AM (#8419964)
I'm pretty sure Saudi Arabia never had nukes pointed at us or tried to.

You mean the Russian nukes from 1963? Those that were a response to the nukes the US placed all over Turkey and neighbouring countries? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuban_missile_crisis

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by trhway on Monday October 06, 2014 @03:27PM (#8417725)
>Pardon me if I think my nation should tolerate nuclear missiles 90 miles off our coast from a country aligned with our enemies

Don't you think people of other nations may have the same intolerance to their enemies' nuclear missiles deployed right on their borders? The Cuban missiles were symmetric response to deploying the Jupiter missiles in Turkey - which is right on the border with USSR http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PGM-19_Jupiter

"They were all removed by the US as part of a secret agreement with the Soviet Union during the Cuban Missile Crisis."

Do onto others what you don't want others do onto you :)

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by drzaiusapelord on Monday October 06, 2014 @04:26PM (#8418066)
Russia was more than welcome to sanction Turkey.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by kevinskii on Monday October 06, 2014 @04:21PM (#8418040)
Perhaps the Jupiter missile deterrent was a bit impolite, but the USSR did enslave many hundreds of millions of people while showing every intention of growing this number.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by vidarh on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @05:15AM (#8420230)
The US "enslaved" vast numbers of people through proxy too, and contributed to several genocides by propping up various puppet regimes.

The US may have been morally superior at home but played just as dirty in large parts of the world.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by joeclark77 on Monday October 06, 2014 @04:23PM (#8418056)
The USSR was a totalitarian communist empire openly determined to conquer and enslave the entire world. The USA was a champion of liberty that pursued strategies intended only to defend the free world against the USSR. Your moral equivalency game indicates you're either ignorant of recent history, or that you're on the other side.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by mercurial on Monday October 06, 2014 @05:16PM (#8418355)
I hope this is sarcasm.

Sure, the USSR was a totalitarian state. That said, both sides pursued an aggressive, expansionist policy via proxy. The "champion of liberty" installed thoroughly repressive regimes all over South America which had little to envy to the Soviet Union. It didn't prove itself above manufacturing border incidents to trigger the Vietnam war, either. Was the USSR worse? Certainly. But this doesn't make the US the good guy in the story.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by redacted on Monday October 06, 2014 @08:41PM (#8419173)
The propaganda of the Cold War is breathtaking in its effectiveness. The USSR are the bad guys, comic book villains out to destroy the world. The US are plucky do-gooders, fighting to save the world from evil yet again (after single handedly winning WWII). There is no room for nuance. There is no grey area in perhaps the greyest of all conflicts since the Great Game. Both the US and USSR inflicted terrible damage to nations all over the world through proxy wars, intelligence agency coups. The ramifications of those conflicts are still felt throughout Latin America, the Middle East, and South East Asia.

And that all gets swept aside by "The USA was a champion of liberty that pursued strategies intended only to defend the free world against the USSR." Read the Wikipedia article on "Covert United States Foreign Regime Change Actions" [0], and see how many of those nations benefited in the long run, and how some incredibly brutal regimes were installed or propped up throughout the third world, simply because they weren't communists.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Covert_United_States_foreign_re...

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by joeclark77 on Monday October 06, 2014 @09:29PM (#8419313)
You should have said "the anti-American garbage that leftist teachers are feeding to grade-school kids is breathtaking in its effectiveness" but in order to do that, you'd have to have some understanding of the true (not the political) version of history.

What's really amazing is that you think your 1960s, nihilistic, self-loathing, theyre-all-the-same cynicism is thoughtful and original, and you assume that the reason I disagree with you is that I haven't heard of such a notion before, and must not be as educated as yourself...

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by mercurial on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @01:04AM (#8419740)
Well, even without opening a history book (sadly, "leftist teachers" did not get rid of Allende all by themselves), one would think that the US military adventurism of the last decade would have equipped US citizens (I'll go out on a limb and assume you are one) with a healthy dose of skepticism.

Governments have most often been waving various pretenses to make their actions look good. Manifest destiny, the white man's burden, the necessity to bring the socialist paradise... "Championing liberty" is just one of them. But you don't "champion liberty" by setting up something like the School of the Americas[1], or selling arms to Iran to fund Contras terrorists[2]. This is a different concept, which is "protecting your interests by whatever means available".

1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Hemisphere_Institute_fo...

2: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contras

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by rdtsc on Monday October 06, 2014 @08:42PM (#8419175)
Please. I lived in Soviet Union and United States for decades (in each). Not it wasn't a totalitarian evil empire. It was an empire. It didn't tollerate criticism of its government but:

* It provided free healthcare

* It provided free housing

* Crime rate was law

* It provided free and quality education (from kindergarten all the way to the highest degrees)

> The USA was a champion of liberty that pursued strategies intended only to defend the free world against the USSR.

Wait, are you being sarcastic. I am confused. Poe's Law in full effect here, ladies and gentlement.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by joeclark77 on Monday October 06, 2014 @09:33PM (#8419319)
Ignoring the genocides and the gulags for a minute, let's simply explore your theory that the USA and USSR were morally equivalent. The USSR conquered and imposed brutal slavery on every eastern european nation. The USA did not conquer any of the western european nations. We didn't even conquer Cuba. If we had the military power, why wouldn't we?
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by rdtsc on Monday October 06, 2014 @10:31PM (#8419440)
> The USSR conquered and imposed brutal slavery on every eastern european nation.

Slavery, like US had up until the mid 1800 and with the following oppression and segregation laws?

Or the country that based itself on ethnic cleansing and genocide of countless American Indians.

> The USA did not conquer any of the western european nations

No but it raped all the South American states and some East Asian states (Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia).

Also Middle East. Started Wars.

> We didn't even conquer Cuba.

Sure tried. And send saboteurs to plant IEDs, blow up bridges, plants. Destroy machinery. Can you say "War Of Terror" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuban_Project)

> If we had the military power, why wouldn't we?

Ok USSR didn't conquer Australia. They had the military power. Why didn't they. Probably didn't want to. And didn't care about.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by trhway on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @02:37AM (#8419901)
>your theory that the USA and USSR were morally equivalent.

mid-20th century significant share (if not half) of the world population was enchanted with the ideas of socialism/communism with those ideas symbolizing justice and freedom (not mass oppression as it ultimately turned to be). In that respect, _back then_, they were morally equivalent or at least close to it. We know better _now_, after observing of many decades of that failed experiments.

>The USSR conquered and imposed brutal slavery on every eastern european nation. The USA did not conquer any of the western european nations.

They all had their respective zones of occupation in Europe, Korea, Japan after the WWII. With time socialist regime in USSR zone turned to be the regime of "conquest and slavery", while capitalism in the western zones, South Korea and Japan happened to be more freedom conducting. For example South Korea wasn't fan of being occupied by US (for example among others http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autumn_Uprising_of_1946 ) and it took decades for it to ultimately start benefiting from having been occupied by US instead of USSR. Again, back then, it wasn't that clear for huge number of people, and it took decades for the differences to appear clearly.

>We didn't even conquer Cuba. If we had the military power, why wouldn't we?

you think it is easier to fight in Cuba jungles than in Vietnam one or that Cubans would be less fierce fighters than Vietnamese?

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by guelo on Monday October 06, 2014 @04:00PM (#8417907)
> What kind of comparison is that?

Mexico is a giant country with huge (though dwindling) oil reserves, and the advantages of NAFTA (all the Detroit automakers have relocated down there).

Cuba and the DR are similar sized geographically and demographically, and have similar climates and resources.

> The DR is practically a failed state.

Don't know why you say that, DR has been politically stable for decades and is economically similar to many other small Latin American countries.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by keepper on Monday October 06, 2014 @05:17PM (#8418361)
> What kind of comparison is that? The DR is practically a failed state.

You've already gotten down voted enough, but wow. DR has had a 7% growth rate for the last 20 years, one of the highest in the Americas...

Your others points are equally off.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_the_Dominican_Republ...

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by araes on Monday October 06, 2014 @06:39PM (#8418752)
While per capita GDP is a useful number that reveals some information about the economics of a country relative to the world stage, I may be alone in finding that its often misleading - particularly when we're talking about what life is like for the common man.

In those cases, I tend to find that things like: The Big Mac Index [1]; the more general World Price Index (a standardized basket of goods) [2]; or the even more general Purchasing Power Parity [3]; are better reflective of the human scale question, which IMO is "for a common wage, what can be purchased, and how expensive is it."

Basically, its great if our per capita GDP is 2x someone else, if our local prices are also 2x, then our actual wage goes roughly the same distance. Another way is: if I had the equivalent of a $1M in Cuba, went to Mexico, and exchanged it with no fee, how would my relative purchasing power change.

Major Caveat: Findings for PPP are heavily dependent on your reference basket of goods.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Mac_Index

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Price_Index

[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purchasing_power_parity

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by davidw on Monday October 06, 2014 @03:41PM (#8417793)
Ending the embargo would probably sweep away their failed economic experiment within 10 years. Keeping it in place gives their leadership an excuse for why the economy is so bad.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by bilbo0s on Monday October 06, 2014 @05:09PM (#8418326)
"...Its other, capitalistic, neighbor Mexico has 2x that GDP per capita..."

Initially, I thought... that HAS to be wrong... because Mexico has 10x the resources that Cuba has. But I looked it up... and you're right... Mexico only has 2x the GDP.

Not really taking any sides here on the whole capitalism v communism thing...

But Mexico has 120 MILLION people, 100 times the energy reserves AND trade with the US... and it STILL cannot even double the GDP of a nation with 11 MILLION people and an embargo (ie - NO trade with the US)... (Cuba: 6,051 Mexico: 10,307)

That's pretty pathetic. I mean REALLY? You have 10x the resources, 100x the energy reserves... and you can only muster twice the GDP ??? Something's not right about that.

I guess that's not really a comment on Cuba as much as it is a comment on Mexico. I didn't realize it was that bad... I don't blame Mexican immigrants for trying to come to the US.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by bzbarsky on Monday October 06, 2014 @05:33PM (#8418432)
Twice the GDP per capita. The "per capita" part is important.

The GDP of Mexico is 20 times greater than Cuba's. The population is 10 times bigger.

Of course as you point out the lack of an embargo, access to oil, etc would lead you to expect that Mexico's per capita GDP would be higher than Cuba's. Whether you'd expect the factor by which it's higher to be 2 or more or less is an interesting question that I'm not qualified to answer. ;)

> Something's not right about that.

Yes, your understanding of the meaning of "per capita GDP".

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by srcmap on Monday October 06, 2014 @08:22PM (#8419120)
I was born and grew up in China in the 60. Cuba now is like China under Mao before embracing market economy. Personally US embargo has little to do Cuba's economy development difficulty. Without US, it can still trade with Canada and rest of Latin America. Like China in 60,70, It is the central planning aspect of economy that is killing any incentive for normal people/organizations to be productive.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by hikarudo on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @01:45PM (#8422654)
Thank your for writing this. Many people have commented in this thread that the US embargo on Cuba is responsible for Cuba being a poor country.

However, Cuba can still trade with other countries. They could even buy American products through other countries. They don't do so (in a significant scale) because they have nothing to offer. Cuba offers little of value to the rest of the world.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by exelius on Monday October 06, 2014 @05:17PM (#8418357)
Ironically (and yes, this is the proper usage of irony) the US embargo on Cuba likely made communism in Cuba more successful than it otherwise would have been. It united the Cuban people in their lack of access to goods on the International market, and helped create an egalitarianism that otherwise doesn't exist if people have access to international trade markets.

Cuba has managed to do a lot with very little, especially with regards to education and health care. Their systems are on-par with those in developed, capitalist countries while their per capita income places them among the most impoverished countries on earth.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by cletus on Monday October 06, 2014 @08:48PM (#8419192)
I couldn't disagree with this more for two reasons:

1. Cuba was historically supported financially by the USSR up until it collapsed; and

2. This belief that the US placed a trade embargo out of "spite" is misguided. Cuba under Castro nationalized assets belonging to US citizens (eg casinos in Havana). Agree or disagree, the US government acted to protect the interests of its citizens.

As to whether that embargo still makes sense, I make no comment on that.

I haven't visited Cuba but it does seem like if I had to be stuck in a communist dictatorship, I'd probably choose Cuba over the alternatives. I'm not sure that's the ringing endorsement one is looking for.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by joeclark77 on Monday October 06, 2014 @09:34PM (#8419325)
Well the climate sure beats North Korea's.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by briandear on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @05:02AM (#8420188)
What a great experiment! Any form of government that tortures people because of their political disagreements is worth an embargo. Most people that write wistfully about Cuba have never lived there. As much as a police state as the U.S. has become, you can still write blog posts against the government without ending up in prison. Try that in Cuba. Remember Che? Brutally murdered opponents in the name of the 'people.' The love-fest some people have with Cuba is astounding. The Cuban Intelligence agency does a great job of propaganda. Blaming the US embargo for the actions of Castro's government brutality is stupid. Are we next going to suggest that North Korea would be a friendly place if it weren't for those pesky South Koreans? The blame America for everything meme is starting to get old. People don't risk their lives trying to escape the Dominican Republic on a raft made from old car tires. Why is that? If the DR is poorer than Cuba, why aren't rafts washing up in the Florida Strait filled with Dominicans? How would Cuba have been doing without the decades of subsidies from the USSR? That experiment in total communism would have fallen flat on its face. The Soviets had a near 100% literacy rate and 'universal' health care, yet you ask anyone over the age of 50 if they would want to live under the Soviets again and it would be an overwhelming 'No.' Let's ask the Polish what they think of Soviet communism.. Any place where the answer to dissenting thought is arrest and imprisonment is a terrible place -- no matter how many doctors there might be. US prisons have universal health care too, but that doesn't mean we would want to live there. When Cuba has free and open elections, then maybe I'll change my tune. But when the people have no voice, then we should not be rationalizing a government just because the kids score well on a math test and it's cheap to get diabetes medicine. I would invite anyone here who thinks Cuba is so great to go live there. Defect to Cuba and let us know (assuming you can) how you're doing in 5 years.
Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by _delirium on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @07:41PM (#8424600)
> ask anyone over the age of 50 if they would want to live under the Soviets again and it would be an overwhelming 'No.'

Do you know any such people? I do know a few of them. Not a statistically valid sample, since I don't research such things professionally. But I happen to have a few in my social group, through family and friend connections. And what's most surprising about them is how strongly pro-Soviet they are. The young people are not; they are mostly pro-West. But the older people are much different, much more nostalgic for Soviet times, and anti-West. Especially those who served in the scientific-industrial-military complex, which is many. Congregations of elderly scientists and engineers tend towards a pro-Soviet tone, especially in the form of complaining about how these useless new countries don't do science the way the old USSR did.

Re:In the medical response to Ebola, Cuba is punching above ... by vidarh on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @05:04AM (#8420198)
Cuba was no such thing. Castro turned to the Soviet Union after his advances to the US were rebuffed. The "sovietization" of Castro's party took years.

It took two years before Castro proclaimed his government socialist, it wasn't until 1965 that his party became the Communist Party of Cuba.

Eventually they became dogmatic Leninist, but substantial parts of the party, including Castro came to Soviet style socialism out of necessity. That's not to say that there weren't many of them that clearly had socialist leanings of various types before that, but the Castro regime was the making of the unholy marriage of rejection by the US and a toxic embrace by the Soviets.

There may have been less of a gap between theory and practice in Cuba than elsewhere, in that the elite appears to have been less greedy and reinvested more in actually making peoples lives better, but it's still an oligarchy with drastic class differences reinforced by the party, rather than fought by it.