News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by phkahler on Monday October 06, 2014 @01:05PM (#8416930)
"Sir, can you tell me how fast you were going?" I've always wondered what the best answer would be.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by morganvachon on Monday October 06, 2014 @02:41PM (#8417406)
Maybe it's a regional thing, but around here the question is always "Do you know why I pulled you over?" to which I've answered, "no, sir." To answer anything else is to incriminate yourself, and officers will write in the comments section of the ticket (for the judge to see) that you affirmed your offense, essentially pleading guilty on the spot.

For example, let's say you're going 10mph over the speed limit and you're aware of that, but you don't know your tail light is out. The officer pulls you over for the tail light, asks the question, and you answer "because I was speeding, I guess". Now he can not only write you the ticket for the tail light, but you just gave him a confession for the speeding too. Now you've guaranteed that you'll get two citations when you might have just gotten off with a "fix that tail light" warning.

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by anonbanker on Thursday October 09, 2014 @02:39PM (#8434299)
You are absolutely correct. However, a court will accept that you tried to plead guilty at the earliest point in time, and will usually give you a reduced penalty for doing so. You'll usually get no points on your license, either.

from thefreedictionary.com's legal dictionary: In civil lawsuits, the term guilty does not imply criminal responsibility but refers to misconduct.

Source: I settle approximately 4 speeding tickets a month for customers.

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by anonbanker on Thursday October 09, 2014 @02:34PM (#8434260)
"Yes." And leave it at that. he'll move on to the next line of questioning. Acceptance of the speed you were going, along with a confirmation that you were not being inattentive while driving (which is the point of the question) will solve your issues much faster. I have gotten out of speeding tickets by simply stating "Yes".

"Not fast enough; you still caught me" is definitely not the best answer, but a funny one.

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by breischl on Monday October 06, 2014 @01:51PM (#8417140)
In some cases they're giving the opportunity to self-incriminate for speeding.

Maybe they didn't get a solid read on their radar gun, or maybe you saw them and were slowing down already when it locked, so they may have no actual evidence. But if they can trick/scare you into admitting that you were speeding, then they don't need the radar gun readings. So you should be very hesitant to tell them any numbers that are above the legal limit.

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by frenchman_in_ny on Monday October 06, 2014 @02:02PM (#8417192)
They don't need the radar gun reading to give you a ticket for speeding. There was a discussion of it here on HN, where all they need is "based upon my training and experience" and a visual estimate of your speed, you can get nailed without a radar gun.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by nsxwolf on Monday October 06, 2014 @02:29PM (#8417340)
I've always said "... I thought I was going the limit... was I?" and I get off with a warning most of the time. I always answer any follow up some utterance like "oh...", but I never explicitly admit fault.

I get off with a warning for most offenses but I think it's more about being very polite and cooperative.

Source: I get stopped once or twice a year for various reasons. (Have been driving for 20 years, 20-40 stops)

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by baddox on Monday October 06, 2014 @01:08PM (#8416955)
Perhaps another question: "How fast was I going, officer?"
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by phkahler on Monday October 06, 2014 @01:18PM (#8417009)
My friend recently tried "do you know how fast I was going" with his best smile of course. The officer responded something like "yes, but I want to see how honest you're going to be with me" with his best smile of course. This was probably a slam dunk for the officer, but my friend got off with 5-over, a hundred dollars, and no points. They were just out to generate revenue on a holiday weekend - and maybe get people to slow down - and I think we all knew it.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by mahyarm on Monday October 06, 2014 @02:49PM (#8417474)
They weren't using radar guns and they didn't tell him their readings?