News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by krallja on Monday October 06, 2014 @12:22PM (#8416696)
A drivers license has always been a privilege, not a right.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by tedks on Monday October 06, 2014 @12:29PM (#8416741)
Likewise, having a cell phone is a privilege, not a right, but it's nearly impossible to survive in modernity without one, so restricting access to one becomes a form of coercion. No matter how you spin it, this is an attempt to coerce people into incriminating themselves.

There's nothing stopping these states from going further and saying that driving a car implies consent to have that car searched at any time, or impounded to be emissions-checked at the state's leisure.

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by tptacek on Monday October 06, 2014 @12:49PM (#8416846)
Having a cell phone is a privilege? In what state, owing to what statute?
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by tedks on Monday October 06, 2014 @01:39PM (#8417081)
It's certainly regulatable, though it isn't now. Since cell carriers lease public airwaves, it'd be possible to mandate that they block some people from using their service, only sell phones if the person's ID is checked, etc.. This is drastic and would disrupt (in the traditional sense of the word) pay as you go phones that are popular for various demographics, but it seems possible, and there certainly isn't a reason why it couldn't happen.

If felons can be denied the right to vote, I think it'd be an easy sell to deny them the right to cell phones. Any state could pass it as a "tough on crime" measure.

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by tptacek on Monday October 06, 2014 @04:27PM (#8418080)
It's not true that anything one can imagine being regulated can legally be regulated. The state has an extremely compelling interest in regulating automobiles --- they are incredibly dangerous and create externalities. It is harder to see how a restriction on free speech and association could pass Constitutional muster.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by tedks on Monday October 06, 2014 @05:52PM (#8418531)
There's no free speech or association here, only questions of who can access government-controlled radio spectrum.

This is also incredibly dangerous -- nearly all drug trafficking is orchestrated via cellular networks, and it's not a stretch to imagine that felons might lose the right to use government radio spectrum to communicate in the same way they lose the right to vote in many states.

To put it another way, which seems more of a central right in the democratic system: voting, or controlled frequency access?

It seems very quixotic to make this an issue of free speech, when free speech itself is so highly regulated. Ask the protesters outside the free speech zone if free speech exists beyond state regulation -- the silence is your answer.

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by ganeumann on Monday October 06, 2014 @02:56PM (#8417525)
NY's Senator Schumer tried to pass a law that made anonymous prepaid cellphones illegal in 2010 (http://www.schumer.senate.gov/new_website/record.cfm?id=3252...).

While this bill seems to have quietly died, it shows that it is certainly possible.

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by rabid_fish on Monday October 06, 2014 @01:05PM (#8416931)
I have family that have been restricted from internet use. This includes the use of most cellphones. Makes it hard to get or maintain a job.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by seanflyon on Monday October 06, 2014 @01:55PM (#8417164)
Restricted why? They are allowed to take away rights as punishment for a crime.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by vertex-four on Monday October 06, 2014 @12:56PM (#8416889)
> Having a cell phone is a privilege?

The ownership of a physical phone is not; having service for that phone involves a voluntary transaction that may be denied, and is therefore a privilege.

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by seanflyon on Monday October 06, 2014 @01:58PM (#8417179)
It is a voluntary transaction between 2 private parties. Either party can deny that transaction, but the government stepping in and preventing the transaction seems like a very different thing. I suppose some would say it's part of thew government's right to regulate interstate commerce.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by tedks on Monday October 06, 2014 @03:11PM (#8417612)
Well, the government owns the radio spectrum that the communication goes over, so it's more direct than that.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by kasey_junk on Monday October 06, 2014 @04:40PM (#8418161)
"owns" in this sentence is problematic. It is a highly technical discussion so it is probably best not to dwell on it. But the government regulates the radio spectrum on behalf of the public, who own it.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by tedks on Monday October 06, 2014 @05:55PM (#8418544)
"The public" is an abstract concept. If you try to use radio spectrum in ways the government dislikes, it will stop you with violence, so they own it for all intents and purposes.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by kasey_junk on Monday October 06, 2014 @06:23PM (#8418685)
For that matter, the "government" is an abstract concept. So what? The point is, the "government" doesn't own anything. They regulate it. That is completely different than ownership, and in the case of radio spectrum the very concept of ownership is really hard to even reason about it.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by vertex-four on Monday October 06, 2014 @08:31PM (#8419138)
What is ownership of a piece of land, precisely, then, and how does it differ from ownership of the radio spectrum? My understanding is that ownership of a piece of land simply means that you'll (or a proxy, whether private entity or Government, will) use violence (or threaten it) to keep other people from using it without your permission.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by kasey_junk on Monday October 06, 2014 @10:47PM (#8419462)
1) That is a very loose definition of ownership. For instance, I can threaten my next door neighbor to take over his deed. That doesn't make me the owner of the land. Ownership of anything is a social construct, without which the greatest warlord wins.

2) Even given the social construct of ownership, the enforcer of the social construct is not the "owner". If I pay a private security firm to guard my property, most people don't assume I've ceded ownership to them.

3) Even given those narrow definitions, the radio spectrum is much more nuanced than physical property. Radio waves literally travel around the world. I as a property owner can enact physical boundaries that have a fair chance of preventing trespass and providing an uninformed arbitrator to make a decent decision. When it comes to radio frequency, even the act of trespass is a highly technical and subjective topic.

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by vertex-four on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @06:28AM (#8420376)
> For instance, I can threaten my next door neighbor to take over his deed. That doesn't make me the owner of the land.

The thing is, the only reason you can't do that is that your next door neighbour will allow a proxy (the Government) to get involved (or rather, has already allowed so as part of the social contract we all "agree" to).

If there wasn't someone stronger than you who has a vested interest in keeping things as they are, you decidedly could threaten your neighbour to take over the ownership of the land. "Non-violent" ownership is solely a thing because there's an entity, with more power and ability to be violent than anyone else, which has an interest in keeping it that way.

> Even given the social construct of ownership, the enforcer of the social construct is not the "owner". If I pay a private security firm to guard my property, most people don't assume I've ceded ownership to them.

That is why I specifically mentioned a proxy.

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by vertex-four on Monday October 06, 2014 @12:52PM (#8416866)
The distinction between privileges and rights, while interesting from a moral perspective, isn't of much use in the real world. The vast majority of us would not be able to survive without the use of numerous privileges and "voluntary" transactions, and we require more and more every day.

What's more, if you manage to live completely off the grid on your own land, the result is that you have fewer resources to protect you in the case that someone who does make use of those privileges decides that they want to violate your rights.

Privileges and voluntary transactions are a myth - anyone who is restricted from them is at a significant disadvantage, and at significantly higher risk of loss of rights to property or to life.

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by ctdonath on Monday October 06, 2014 @01:04PM (#8416923)
During the original debate over the Bill Of Rights, a primary concern was that the failure to enumerate a right would be construed as non-existence thereof - exactly the opposite of what the Founding Fathers intended.

Methinks if the Founding Fathers had conceived of the notion of vehicular transportation being prohibited without governmental consent & licensing, they wouldn't have hesitated to include that as a fundamental right (just as security requires armaments, and speech requires presses - ownership & use of equipment facilitating both explicitly may not be infringed/abridged). As the notion of vehicle licensing (both horse and horseless) was never considered, unto inconceivable, they didn't enumerate it as a natural right. Require a driver's test and license a horse & carriage? absurd! ...well, now the technological improvement plus lack of enumerated right means 'tis common to construe vehicular travel as a "privilege" in a society where one is darned near dysfunctional without.

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by nsxwolf on Monday October 06, 2014 @02:23PM (#8417301)
This use of the word "privilege" has always irked me - maybe I'm just not reading it in the correct sense. It sounds very paternalistic.

Driving is a regulated activity, but you do have a right to a drivers license if you are able to comply with the regulations. "Privilege" sounds so arbitrary, as if someone could say "I don't like your face, no license for you".

Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by anonbanker on Thursday October 09, 2014 @02:37PM (#8434282)
from Thefreedictionary.com's legal dictionary [1]:

License: The permission granted by competent authority to exercise a certain privilege that, without such authorization, would constitute an illegal act, a Trespass or a tort. The certificate or the document itself that confers permission to engage in otherwise proscribed conduct.

let's think about that: Driving is illegal. Marriage is illegal. Fishing is illegal.

1. http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/license