News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by bdcravens on Sunday October 05, 2014 @02:49PM (#8413048)
The easier it gets to buy Bitcoin, and accept Bitcoin, the worse it will be. Even if you wanted to spend Bitcoin, you had to think ahead. Now Circle lets you buy within minutes (in most cases) of setting up your account. On the other side of things, Bitpay and Coinbase let merchants convert back to USD (or other currency) right away. So it's possible to do "just in time Bitcoin": Bitcoin is merely the payment protocol.

When Bitcoin becomes a pure cash equivalent, no one will care about the price. I believe that once the price becomes irrelevant, it'll trend downward. I think it'll take something serious to move the price upward, like a serious event creating major doubt in USD.

Most of the bulls are quick to conflate the advantages of the protocol, as if that magically makes it more valuable as a traded commodity. Bitcoin is simultaneously a currency and a protocol. I believe when it was hard to obtain, the use of a store of value held the most potential, and early risk takers had an opportunity for reward. It's entirely possible, as the protocol becomes more or more utilized, those days of risk and reward are well behind us.

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by pron on Sunday October 05, 2014 @02:52PM (#8413058)
> like a serious event creating major doubt in USD.

I think you are way overestimating Bitcoin's (current) significance. If something major happens to the USD -- i.e. something major happens to the US economy -- Bitcoin will be the last thing people think about, and there are quite a few other currencies (with much better track records) that people will prefer before betting their money on Bitcoin.

> It's entirely possible, as the protocol becomes more or more utilized, those days of risk and reward are well behind us.

If you have any evidence that Bitcoin is becoming more and more utilized, I'd love to hear. And I mean actual transactions, not services supporting the protocol (which could be publicity stunt, very cheap bets for something that just might take off one day, or simply wishful thinking).

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by zanny on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:00PM (#8413091)
> there are quite a few other currencies (with much better track records) that people will prefer before betting their money on Bitcoin.

So I'm in the US. Assuming hyperinflation starts tomorrow, the only money I have, or anyone else will accept broadly enough to keep me able to exchange in the market, is bitcoin. Nobody has Euros, nobody takes them, nobody takes Canadian dollars on the boarder, and nobody would accept or buy the equipment to measure weights of gold or platinum.

Of course, the market would probably broadly move (more due to ignorance than any real justifiable reason not to) towards another states fiat in the event of a gradual loss of faith in USD. You would not have a situation where you woke up tomorrow and suddenly your dollars are worthless, at least if you are paying attention.

> If you have any evidence that Bitcoin is becoming more and more utilized, I'd love to hear. And I mean actual transactions, not services supporting the protocol

Overstock is apparently making like 2% of revenue from bitcoin sales. I know the Subway nearby that takes bitcoin is making money when I spend btc there. I'm exclusively buying computer hardware for customers through tigerdirect / newegg in bitcoin, though they have not released statements on how much revenue is generated through it yet.

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by pron on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:07PM (#8413120)
Assuming this Glen Beckian Armageddon, I doubt you'll be able to use Bitcoin much at all, as it requires internet access and electricity, both could experience disruptions in the chaos that will surely ensue when world's leading economy collapses (remember, nobody (seriously) lost faith in the USD even during the 2008 meltdown, so nothing short of a '29-like collapse will do it). If that world-changing catastrophe happens, people will start taking Euros, Pounds, Yens, or Yuans long before BTC.
Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by krschultz on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:33PM (#8413196)
In retrospect, it seems that 2008 was the same order of magnitude as 1929. Sure, the safety net was there to prevent bread lines, but the economic damage was pretty close. Europe's lack of recovery is especially alarming.

Which only reinforces your point, we've gone through one of the worst recession/depressions of all time, and USD survived. I really can't imagine what would change it other than insanely reckless monetary & fiscal policy - which is absolutely not happening right now.

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by adventured on Sunday October 05, 2014 @04:06PM (#8413292)
There are only three scenarios that would alter the USD reserve status: 1) gradual erosion over decades, via the rise of the yuan for example; 2) if the QE / stimulus era explodes and the globe sinks into an even more protracted recession (ie if the Keynesians were wrong), in which case the US government will print incredible sums; 3) if the US initiates a war against the major European powers or China, that could open a fault-line in the global economy (this is another hyper unlikely scenario)
Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by georgemcbay on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:32PM (#8413194)
"the only money I have, or anyone else will accept broadly enough to keep me able to exchange in the market, is bitcoin"

Virtually nobody really "takes" bitcoin, it just seems like they do because they are using a 3rd party service which abstracts those transactions into USD for them. How long this sort of acceptance would last if the USD tanked is left as an exercise for the reader.

As goofy as I think it is that people speculate in gold as a good "collapse" currency, at least if a US Dollar destroying event takes place gold will still be shiny, whereas good luck trading bitcoin when the power and wired networking infrastructure is no more.

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by zanny on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @12:37AM (#8419680)
> when the power and wired networking infrastructure is no more.

There is a plethora of point to point networking protocols, and solar panels exist. If it looked like there was a chance of USD collapse, I'd go buy some, and move somewhere without anyone around to riot and destroy my stuff and stab me. Preferably somewhere that is not the US, if I could get away with it at that point.

But honestly, that won't happen, at least any time soon to even fathom worrying about it. The US economy is too entrenched in global politics and economics to just fall over because of bad fiscal policy. I mean, we have already had bad fiscal policy for forty years! What is another few decades?

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by sanswork on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:06PM (#8413118)
If you're in the US and hyperinflation starts tomorrow who is going to be buying your hyperinflating USD for bitcoin?

>Nobody has Euros, nobody takes them, nobody takes Canadian dollars on the boarder

That is because they don't have to USD is fairly stable if it starts to go into hyperinflation that will change quickly. Also as a Canadian that travels to the US a lot. There are large swaths of the US where CAD is accepted.

>Overstock is apparently making like 2% of revenue from bitcoin sales.

At last disclosure Overstock had done $2.6m in bitcoin revenue in 9 months. They are far from 2% of revenue. Their CEO keeps throwing out random numbers about what they plan to do by the end of the year that don't make sense(He still claims $10-20m by year end regularly) to cover the fact that their bitcoin revenue has been dropping from day one.

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by Aqueous on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:24PM (#8413168)
That's not true at all. The need to convert to dollars is present only most assets are denominated in dollars, taxes are paid in dollars, and our basic needs are paid for in dollars. What happens when vendor adoption expands to the point where you can buy enough from vendors - food, clothing, housing - with BitCoin that it is no longer absolutely necessary to convert to dollars, because you can subsist entirely on BitCoin?
Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by bdcravens on Sunday October 05, 2014 @04:35PM (#8413367)
That world is several years away, if it ever exists. Even then, it's a cash equivalent unless they do business with vendors that stop denominating in USD or hold BTC long-term.
Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by forthefuture on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:28PM (#8413183)
You're still paid in dollars.
Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by Aqueous on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:32PM (#8413193)
Some people already aren't paid in fiat. I'm not one of those people - because I realize BitCoin still has a ways to go before I start to put more than the money I can afford to lose into it.
Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by tzs on Sunday October 05, 2014 @05:16PM (#8413480)
> Some people already aren't paid in fiat

(This is not directed at you. You just provided a convenient place to fork from)

I think the way many people in Bitcoin circles use the term "fiat" can be a bit misleading. Most people outside of Bitcoin circles use "fiat" as part of a dichotomy. In this dichotomy, a currency is either a fiat currency or a commodity-backed currency.

With Bitcoin, we have a trichotomy: government-backed fiat currency, commodity-backed currency, and non-government backed non-commodity-backed currency.

If Bitcoin has to be placed in the fiat/commodity-backed dichotomy, it is a lot closer to fiat than commodity-backed. Bitcoin is essentially a non-government fiat currency.

By using "fiat" as part of a different dichotomy, fiat vs. Bitcoin, Bitcoin people are risking inadvertently misleading people who use non-fiat to mean not commodity-backed. I'm pretty sure I've seen "gold bug" types misunderstand Bitcoin because of this. The "mining" terminology probably doesn't help here, either...

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by nivertech on Sunday October 05, 2014 @05:56PM (#8413585)
and non-government backed non-commodity-backed currency

I think hashing power is a commodity, just like electricity or bandwidth.

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by tzs on Sunday October 05, 2014 @06:11PM (#8413611)
Hashing power may be a commodity, but does it back Bitcoin? Hashing is used to create a new Bitcoin, but that seems more like a resource consumed as part of production, not something that is backing the currency.

When a currency is backed by a commodity, such as a currency backed by gold, you can exchange the currency for the commodity at a fixed rate. The currency is a proxy for the commodity. When you hold a unit of a commodity backed currency, the appropriate amount of that commodity is being held for you somewhere.

When you hold a Bitcoin, there is not someone holding a fixed amount of hashing power in reserve for you somewhere. The Bitcoin represents not hashing power available but rather hashing power that has been expended. In terms of gold coins, hashing power in Bitcoin is like the labor of mining the gold. I don't think that there is anything in Bitcoin corresponding to the gold.

I suppose you could argue that Bitcoins themselves are the commodity, but that seems to me like calling USD a commodity-based currency based on its physical paper and ink. We don't count that because the commodity is essentially worthless compared to the value of the currency. The currency doesn't derive its value from the commodity.

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by Aqueous on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @02:51PM (#8423144)
I think the 'gold' would be the hash collisions that the mining process discovers - this is like gold in the sense that these hash collisions are mathematically scarce and of finite supply, and very difficult to discover/extract. They are unlike gold in that they are not very useful by themselves, whereas gold is used as a material in many things.
Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by zanny on Sunday October 05, 2014 @02:56PM (#8413071)
If it becomes more utilized and popular, assuming people use it as currency and not as exchange medium, then inherently the price has to go up because demand for bitcoins goes up, and the supply barely changes and does so with algorithmic inputs and constant loss due to lost wallets.

I like to think of bitcoin as cryptogold. The inevitable outcome assuming continued success of the bitcoin protocol is that as more people want it and supply cannot change it becomes a lot like gold, in that it is traded as a resource backing currency. You could still use it for transactions, but a money that is long run appreciating in value is not very conductive of exchange. Something like dogecoin, peercoin, or any cryptocurrency implemented that algorithmically adjusts generation rates to maintain consistent monetary velocity would be much better suited as a day to day exchange commodity.

Also, one of the most prominent uses of bitcoin is in international exchange, in which case yeah, it acts as an intermediary between local fiats, but there is substantial pressure to just use the bitcoin outright rather than constantly converting it back.

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by rhino369 on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:01PM (#8413095)
The price right now isn't based on actual demand for usage. It's over priced due to speculation.

But some of these methods of using bitcoin greatly increase the velocity of bitcoin. If demand rises 10x but velocity increases 20x, the price would fall.

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by rhino369 on Sunday October 05, 2014 @02:57PM (#8413077)
Also, if bitcoin is basically abstracted from the user, there is risk that the middle men will switch a newer protocol. Coinbase and bitpay could easily switch. All the people speculating in bitcoin price would be left holding the bag.
Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by imaginenore on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:10PM (#8413128)
> When Bitcoin becomes a pure cash equivalent, no one will care about the price. I believe that once the price becomes irrelevant, it'll trend downward

Assuming world wide adoption scenario, that's mathematically impossible. People generally have some amount of wealth (most of us have it in a bank). If you have, let's say, 100 million people (a small fraction of the world really) using bitcoin instead of fiat, and, let's say, they have $2,000 worth of bitcoin on average (which is much lower than the current US average), it would mean that 1 bitcoin = $2,000 * 100M / 21M = $9523.8.

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by aftbit on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:34PM (#8413200)
The idea is that rather than hold your wealth in Bitcoin, you would continue to hold it in your local fiat, and only use Bitcoin for the payment protocol.

Imagine if Paypal operated in "PPBUX" instead of local currency. Because of the large volume and high speed of transactions, PPBUX <-> USD would not be a very important number. You would only hold PPBUX for the few minutes required to make the transaction, during which it's pretty unlikely to move against you.

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by imaginenore on Monday October 06, 2014 @03:40PM (#8417785)
You missed the premise: "When Bitcoin becomes a pure cash equivalent".
Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by maxerickson on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:25PM (#8413173)
The price can't be irrelevant, miners are going to change their activity based on it.

It also doesn't make so much sense that companies helping people complete transactions in situations where traditional methods are expensive/slow/regulated will successfully continue to avoid regulation or bother to give miners a share.

Re:Bitcoin falls below $300, lowest in 11 months by ThomPete on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:36PM (#8413205)
But that regulation would have to happen globally then no?