News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Shot in the Arm: How Job Lock Hurts Entrepreneurs by tptacek on Wednesday September 23, 2009 @05:33PM (#840169)
Pregnancy isn't the only issue, and it wasn't the issue in our case. You'll forgive me for not getting into more detail here. It is not as simple as "we don't want to subsidize pregnancy" (I sympathise with that). It's "women of childbearing age are more expensive to cover for a variety of reasons".

Despite a total lack of chronic medical problems in my family, declining maternity coverage would not have helped us. So let's lose that red herring.

Do I agree that the government shouldn't have to pay for routine predictable medical expenses? Of course I do. I understand the concept of insurance (to avoid catastrophic losses from rare events), and I also understand how totally distorted our health care system is because of the twisted incentives and lack of transparency in the private employer-funded health insurance system. I'm not wishing for the NHS, but I'm also not naive enough to think that one regulatory tweak (guaranteed issue) is going to solve our problems.

Finally, if you have a problem with the idea that the young, healthy, and fortunate are subsidizing the old, infirm, and poor, you need to revisit the entire concept of insurance. People who avoid acquiring insurance in their 20s --- all of whom will certainly try to get coverage in their late 30s --- are free-riding.

Re:A Shot in the Arm: How Job Lock Hurts Entrepreneurs by jdminhbg on Wednesday September 23, 2009 @05:51PM (#840194)
The twentysomething "freeriders" are overwhelmingly the source of startup founders. If you want to force them to subsidize older people, that's fine, but it's not going to have the effect of increasing entrepreneurship, which is ostensibly the point of the article.
Re:A Shot in the Arm: How Job Lock Hurts Entrepreneurs by tptacek on Wednesday September 23, 2009 @05:56PM (#840201)
Did you read the article, or do you just have strong opinions about health care? Either way is fine, but the point of the article is that one of the reasons twentysomethings are a huge fraction of startup founders is that they aren't locked into jobs by health insurance.

(It is also, by the way, simply not the case that twentysomethings are overwhelmingly the source of startup founders; what they do seem to be is an overwhelming source of YC company founders. Go make a list of 10 VCs, read their portfolios, and go look at the "Management Team" sections on their websites.)

Re:A Shot in the Arm: How Job Lock Hurts Entrepreneurs by jdminhbg on Wednesday September 23, 2009 @06:11PM (#840226)
Having re-read the piece, I don't see anywhere that he defines his point as being that "one of the reasons twentysomethings are a huge fraction of startup founders is that they aren't locked into jobs by health insurance." I'm sure from your personal experience you think this is the case, but the author doesn't assert that it's the case, or try to provide evidence that in countries with universal coverage there are more older entrepreneurs.

I personally think that health insurance is pretty far back on the list of reasons older people are less likely to found startups than young people. I'm willing to be convinced there by some sort of evidence. Regardless, in order for it to be the case that "[u]niversal health insurance, far from suppressing entrepreneurship, could be a boon to it," it would have encourage more older entrepreneurs than it discourages among the young.

Re:A Shot in the Arm: How Job Lock Hurts Entrepreneurs by tptacek on Wednesday September 23, 2009 @06:36PM (#840254)
Which brings us back to entrepreneurship. Some of tomorrow’s potential entrepreneurs are today’s employees at firms that provide health insurance. They may have powerful new ideas that will build the firms of tomorrow. But if they leave their current job to work on those ideas they may find themselves without access to reliable health insurance. If they are very young and healthy, this may not be a major impediment. But for older entrepreneurs who have developed ideas through years of working for others, the fear of losing health insurance when they go out on their own can be a barrier to taking that leap.

You're right, though. I used the word "the" when I should have used the word "a".

Re:A Shot in the Arm: How Job Lock Hurts Entrepreneurs by locopati on Thursday September 24, 2009 @10:04AM (#841143)
Anecdote != data, however, I will say that my decision to stay in my job is quite tied to the health insurance my family (w 1 child) receives through that job. It is simply too risky and expensive to take a lower paying job that might provide worse health insurance or part time work in order to attempt a startup.
Re:A Shot in the Arm: How Job Lock Hurts Entrepreneurs by philwelch on Wednesday September 23, 2009 @06:06PM (#840220)
Combining guaranteed-issue with an individual mandate may make the actuarial math work out profitably for a lot of scenarios. It would never happen in a free market--the marginal cost of accepting someone with preexisting conditions already exceeds the marginal revenue--but if each insurance company has to take on enough healthy people for each sick person they can still profit.

No system is perfect. I think there are a lot of pieces of reform that have been proposed that would be an improvement, though.