News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by ryanSrich on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @08:08PM (#8398653)
Full disclosure: I am a remote worker. I love working remotely. I will (never say never but..) never work for a company that doesn't have a remote culture.

So, even with putting my bias aside, this seems like such a bad move. I am so much more productive as a remote worker than I was as a monkey sitting at a desk everyday. Not only is the quality of my work better but I'm much more efficient (I get more done in 4 hours remotely than I did in a full 8 hour day at an office). I know I'm not special, in fact I believe I'm in the majority.

Remote cultures in my opinion are the best. Mostly because:

- less meetings (hangouts is glitchy so we make the ones we do have count)

- hardly any email at all (async chat ftw)

- records records records. Remember that conversation you had about that one awesome improvement but you just can't remember what it was...oh wait it's in chat.

- minimal distractions. The only things to distract you are your cat and the internet. If someone pings you online you can leave it an answer it later, a tap on the shoulder? Not so much.

Even if you could mimic my points above at a physical office, remote working is far better for work/life balance because:

- you can earn a high wage living in a cheaper location. This is a huge benefit of working remotely.

- you can stay around your family (since you'll be home more often)

- you don't have to commute (of course some use co-working spaces but it's the freedom to choose that matters)

Why would Reddit force their remote workers to relocate to the most expensive city in the US? That seems like a huge disadvantage to their employees. A relocation package is nothing compared to being able to afford a house, or spend time with your family.

This is just sad.

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by meritt on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @09:06PM (#8398886)
At my company, we've been struggling to "make it work" with remote workers for the past few years and it's been really problematic. We've had a lot difficulty getting remote employees to maintain consistent work schedules, provide frequent updates (trello), or simply communicating regularly (hipchat). I don't think it's a lack of tools at all: I think it's hiring the wrong people or having the wrong management (My fault either way. I'm mediocre at hiring and definitely not a good manager). I guess I just assume people will approach work with the same autonomy, motivation, and drive that I do myself. Unfortunately that has not been the case.

Either way, we've decided to scrap the idea of remote workers and are opening an office + hiring local next month to see how that goes. We're in Portland though, not SF, so it's not a ridiculously expensive decision like Reddit is making.

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by jnbiche on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @10:10PM (#8399091)
I'm sorry it didn't work. I wished you had Asked HN, I suspect a lot of us remote workers could have offered valuable input (if you did that, then I'm sorry for missing it).

At the top of the list, I'd say you were measuring the wrong benchmarks. Consistent work schedules shouldn't be a goal with remote workers: attaining specific, measurable objectives should be.

On the other hand, lack of communication is a problem, as long as you weren't wanting updates 3-4 times a day (once a day at most should be entirely sufficient -- wanting more frequent updates points to trust issues). I'm guessing you either hired people with no remote experience, or you hired lazy people (or both!). However, to be fair to your workers, I should also point out that sufficiently poor management and co-workers can frighten off even the best, most motivated remote workers (and I have no way to tell if your claims of not being a good manager are just false modesty).

For anyone reading who's struggling with remote workers, your top hiring consideration -- right alongside their job expertise -- should be demonstrable experience as a successful remote worker. The more the better. Remote work takes a certain kind of person, and even highly talented people who are primarily motivated by external feedback will struggle at remote work.

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by meritt on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @11:55PM (#8399353)
I should have clarified that the concern with a routine work schedule and availability only came about after people were consistently not meeting objectives, and dropping the ball without letting anyone know, or spending days toiling away at something without providing adequate updates so we might better manage that project and help with hurdles.

I'm definitely a subpar manager, it's a big area of weakness and it's something I'm actively working to improve upon.

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by CPAhem on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @10:53PM (#8399203)
Measuring the wrong indicators is the primary reason companies don't like remote work. They measure showing up, not results.
Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by briandear on Thursday October 02, 2014 @03:29AM (#8399723)
Yes. It's the 'attendance grade' nonsense drilled into us since kindergarten. It's funny how in college I could get nearly perfect scores on exams, yet would get penalized some percentage because of attendance. I don't need to be there to get the job done, but some people seem to think that there's cotton to pick in the office.
Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by ryanSrich on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @09:13PM (#8398907)
You're absolutely right in regards to tools.

Just as knowing photoshop doesn't make you a solid designer using Slack and Google hangouts doesn't make you a solid remote company.

Remote working is 100% people and culture. If you are having a hard time finding responsible, communicative employees remotely I highly suspect you'll have the same issues hiring locally.

Communication is not only important for remote teams.

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by joelrunyon on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @10:40PM (#8399161)
Completely agree that it's dependent on the people. Some handle it great - some terribly.
Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by briandear on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @08:30PM (#8398747)
I agree with you completely. In terms of forcing them to relocate to the most expensive city, it's simple. The Reddit execs are f'ing morons and should be forced to work in a fried chicken restaurant as punishment. They certainly don't deserve VC money. As far as the investors, if I had the inclination, I'd call them out for being fools as well, assuming they had something to do with this. I would NEVER move to San Francisco. Besides the cost of real-estate, you also have the ridiculously communist state and local government, high taxes among other things.
Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by x0x0 on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @09:22PM (#8398941)
A communist state and local government?

You're an idiot.

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by zak_mc_kracken on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @08:29PM (#8398740)
Worse for the employee, better for the company.

Companies draw the line between these conflicting goals at various places.

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by gkoberger on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @08:48PM (#8398814)
It's a trade off. You gain raw code output but lose a lot of the culture and serendipitous communication that leads to awesome breakthroughs. So many great things have come from random talks or drunken brainstorming.

As an employee, I always tried to work from home 2-3 days and then work from the office 2-3. Was a great happy medium.

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by prawn on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @10:37PM (#8399154)
This sounds like it could work well but unless there was desk sharing, companies would end up paying for floorspace lying idle half the time.
Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by ryanSrich on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @08:34PM (#8398764)
How is it better for the company? That's my whole point. I feel like people produce better work as remote employees.
Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by terravion on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @09:34PM (#8398986)
Many, many business leaders feel that real collaboration takes place in person. Google and Yahoo seem to be two prominent examples. Remote productivity may be wildly different for different roles.

MIT tech review just published a piece about Eric Schmidt's view on remote work and leadership: http://www.technologyreview.com/news/531056/google-execs-hav...

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by judk on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @11:02PM (#8399222)
Places with giant piles of bad code require maintenance coders to sit with the original authors.

Linux Kernel is 100% remote workers.

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by chrisbennet on Thursday October 02, 2014 @01:13PM (#8401757)
And look how badly Linux turned out. ;-)

(sarcasm in case it wasn't obvious)

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by funkyy on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @09:21PM (#8398937)
It is better for company, because it can control workers.

There is a reason companies give all those perks to employees - their (employees) loyalty grows. Employees get addicted to all the great stuff large corpo have to offer.

Its like small startups getting office dog. People get emotionally connected to it so they wont leave the company... Cheap trick but it works. Free snack bar, transport and gym anyone?

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by drewg123 on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @10:39PM (#8399159)
That doesn't always work. Working remotely is worth far more to me than free food, massages, free flu shots, laundry, etc.

I worked remotely for a small company that was acquired by Google & I had to relocate with my family to the SF Bay area against my will, similar to the Reddit folks. I had 10x the loyalty to the small company that I will ever have to Google, mostly because of the forced relocation. I can't wait for the retention bonuses to run out & to move back home.

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by funkyy on Thursday October 02, 2014 @12:38AM (#8399448)
You dont get it. I said its better for company. Ofc its worse for you, but why those large companies should bother? They are interested in results and royalty. No explanation from you is worth as much as having employee in-house for them.
Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by lutusp on Thursday October 02, 2014 @01:01AM (#8399483)
> You dont [sic] get it. I said its [sic] better for company. Ofc its [sic] worse for you ...

Only explanation -- a broken apostrophe key.

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by jordanb on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @09:14PM (#8398911)
Probably better for the investors who own SF property, that's why I assume VC are always so anxious for companies to relocate.
Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by saumil07 on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @11:04PM (#8399228)
"Investors who own SF property?"

I would be hard-pressed to name a venture investor that also finds themselves in the real estate business to such an extent that they want their investments to relocate? Investors do not own SF property for their companies and even the traditional ones on Sand Hill Road are leasing (expensive) office space like the rest of us.

It is possible that the investment and the board had influence on the decision but that could be for reasons independent of real estate ownership.

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by e12e on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @09:55PM (#8399056)
> hardly any email at all (async chat ftw)

While I can see the use for chat (with centralized logging, be that IRC, XMPP or whatever) -- hardly any email sounds odd to me. Anything wrong with internal mailing lists? It's what people have been using for remote working since forever (eg: Linux kernel, Debian project etc etc).

How is asynchronous chat any better than asynchronous email?

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by frostmatthew on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @09:58PM (#8399059)
> How is asynchronous chat any better than asynchronous email?

People tend to be less verbose in chat. Not using three paragraphs to communicate what only needs two lines saves time for both/all parties.

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by e12e on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @11:16PM (#8399268)
Sounds like poor language skills.

If you've written three paragraphs, for something that needs two sentences, chances are you should spend another 5-10 minutes re-writing your email and say what you need to say, not just send a stream-of-conciousness document to burden your colleagues.

Still odd that someone that manage to be concise and to the point in asynchronous chat, should be verbose in email?

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by S4M on Thursday October 02, 2014 @09:40AM (#8400650)
I think people perceive email and chat differently. For example, I would find normal to ask someone "what's the status of X?" in an asynchronous chat, but it would seem borderline rude to write an email saying just that - I would wrap it up with some standard formulae ("Hi", "Please, could you update..." "cheers", etc.) Maybe it's just me but I feel that I can be much more direct in an asynchronous chat, closer to how I would be when talking directly with the other person.
Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by JoshTriplett on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @10:13PM (#8399097)
That's a corporate culture issue, and to some extent a tools issue as well. If email is a lot of trouble, then by the time you get around to using it, you write a lot. If a two-sentence email takes you more than a couple of seconds to prepare and send (not counting the time needed to actually think of the two sentences), there's something horribly wrong with your workflow.

So, chat can potentially fix that by forcing people to use a different tool to which their preconceptions don't apply, but in the absence of those preconceptions, you can use email as a terse communication medium.

Re:After raising $50M, Reddit forces all remote workers to r... by monksy on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @09:03PM (#8398873)
> - hardly any email at all (async chat ftw)

Thats not the case everywhere. In my previous remote only job there was a reply all deal and usually a lot of people were on the email.