News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by gnarbarian on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @01:35PM (#8389603)
They are going straight into "think of the children mode"

" Smartphone communication is “going to be the preferred method of the pedophile and the criminal. We are going to lose a lot of investigative opportunities."

Apparently "what about the terrorists?" isn't as effective anymore. Let's hope the public will see through their manipulative talking points.

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by higherpurpose on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @01:52PM (#8389763)
I'm surprised they even admit it's mostly used in the war on drugs. As if we want the US government to help [1] the Sinaloa cartel dominate even more - sorry, I meant to "win the war on drugs" (ha ha!).

[1] - http://www.businessinsider.com.au/the-us-government-and-the-...

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by Roboprog on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @01:33AM (#8392992)
Hmm. Kind of like the reverse of the bit in Charles Stross' "Merchant Princes" novel series where the trans-dimensional smugglers donate to the Partnership for a Drug-Free America to help keep drugs illegal and the price up.

Except your example is real, just like back in the 80s when the govt (CIA?) helped smuggle in cocaine.

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by brandonmenc on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:35PM (#8390175)
Quote from Cathy Lanier, the police chief whose ridiculous uniform resembles that of a four star general.

fwiw my friend's dad was our chief of police for years, and he only ever wore a shirt and tie.

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by GHFigs on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:52PM (#8390312)
For what it's worth -- and here I have to wonder how much it's worth to criticize someone's point of view based on a photograph of them -- that's a dress uniform.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dress_uniform

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by CamperBob2 on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @03:13PM (#8390489)
Sometimes a photo tells you all you need to know about a person: e.g., http://i.imgur.com/4CIFpFe.jpg . Modern American law enforcement: a gang of wannabe tinpot dictators with weapons they have no business with, and that they probably have no idea how to use.

Finger off the trigger, Sheriff.

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by rosser on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @06:29PM (#8391761)
You do realize that's Joe Arapio, right? He's the poster child for law enforcement that's so egregiously overreaching it's become self-parody.

Of course he's holding a cocked firearm with his finger on the trigger. He pretty much doesn't have any other state.

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by sitkack on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @04:33PM (#8390982)
Not only is his finger on the trigger but the weapon is cocked.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by wl on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @05:19PM (#8391330)
That's an M1911. They're designed to be carried in condition one, which means that the hammer is cocked and the manual safety is engaged, otherwise known as "cocked and locked."

His trigger discipline is still inexcusable.

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by sitkack on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @01:43AM (#8393012)
And a law enforcement "professional" shouldn't be carrying a gun that is "cocked and locked" SA firearms are not safe for everyone involved.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by tomsthumb on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @05:18PM (#8391324)
Don't worry dude it's probably not loaded.

cue cries of "every gun is always loaded"

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by MCRed on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @11:28PM (#8392674)
I don't know why you're getting down voted, maybe people don't know the first rule of gun safety: Always treat the firearm as if it is loaded. (which on the internet is "the gun is always loaded" shorthand.)
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by GHFigs on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @03:32PM (#8390604)
"Instead of criticizing one person based on a picture, I criticize thousands of people based on a picture! That'll show him!"
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by CamperBob2 on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @04:39PM (#8391025)
Yeah, stereotypically speaking, it's the 90% of bad cops that give the 10% a bad name. Funny, though, the "good" 10% don't seem to have a problem with that.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by rosser on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @06:36PM (#8391794)
The ratios are nothing like 90 bad:10 good. That kind of hyperbole is uninformed at best, and disingenuous at worst.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by GHFigs on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @06:08PM (#8391631)
I understand where you're coming from. I have an uncle that feels the exact same way about black people and Muslims. Wait, what?
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by CamperBob2 on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @06:24PM (#8391730)
To the extent police work is someone's religion, I'd submit that these are exactly the police I'm talking about.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by dragontamer on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @07:27PM (#8392021)
So you're a bigot against Police _and_ Muslims.

Got it. At least you're consistent.

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by CamperBob2 on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @07:38PM (#8392056)
Yes, my simplistic worldview often gets me into trouble. But this will come as no surprise to you, I'm sure.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by brandonmenc on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @03:24PM (#8390556)
I agree that her uniform is largely irrelevant to the discussion. She also likely has no choice in it.

I'm trigger happy pointing out police militarization, which manifests in overt ("tanks") and subtle ways (military dress).

Perhaps it's a stretch, but I believe that militarization doesn't ease the tendency of the police to desire and acquire powers they shouldn't have.

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by Zigurd on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @03:09PM (#8390455)
Dress uniform for police? That's not quite as bad as the paramilitary BDUs, but, really?
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by freehunter on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @03:57PM (#8390768)
Police do have official events to attend. In my state capital there is a yearly event to honor fallen officers where representatives from every police force in the state show up in their dress uniforms for a mass memorial service.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by Zigurd on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @10:44PM (#8392550)
They could wear suits. That might remind them they are of the people, and their first priority is to serve the people. They might also consider attending the memorial service for Mike Brown. In suits.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @02:02AM (#8393062)
They'd have to only attend if off-duty then wouldn't they? One point of police uniform is to identify a person as being a warranted police officer on duty (then there's the appearance of officialdom and the sense of inferiority it breeds in others, the camaraderie, ...). You'd probably need to change the law if you want to allow regular warranted officers to be on duty in civilian clothing, jurisdiction dependent of course.

I don't really understand why you don't want to be able to identify your police officers though - even the UPS drivers wear uniform.

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by fnordfnordfnord on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @08:32AM (#8393950)
Thank you for making this point. The very last thing we need is to have police disguise themselves as regular folks. It creates a number of dangerous conditions for both the police and the public.

"Who is this random person yelling and waving a gun?" Should I pull over for this random person with flashing lights in their grille?"

It's already bad enough having some traffic enforcement types in unmarked cars or in cars with "ghost" decals.

OTOH, her uniform is very "Aladeen" and while fussing about her uniform is a mostly trivial distraction, having a uniform that is a bit less "Aladeen" would probably short-circuit such criticism. If there weren't more important problems with this person, I would fully support mocking her ridiculous uniform.

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by psykovsky on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @06:42AM (#8393668)
The ones who work at NSA/CIA wear shorts and suits. I don't think they are reminded of who they are and what their priorities are, by it.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by earless1 on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @01:45PM (#8389702)
Yeah, I let out an audible WTF when I read that. I wish this argument would stop.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by legomylibrum on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:09PM (#8389915)
Oh, it gets better.

"The notion that someone would market a closet that could never be opened – even if it involves a case involving a child kidnapper and a court order – to me does not make any sense."

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by pdabbadabba on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:15PM (#8389970)
Seriously. Perhaps one would call this sort of exotic and nefarious contraption a "safe"?
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by earless1 on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:45PM (#8390255)
Well we all know that law enforcement gets a copy of every safe key made. you know just in case
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by GHFigs on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @03:52PM (#8390734)
They are going straight into "think of the children mode" ... apparently "what about the terrorists?" isn't as effective anymore.

"They" in this case is the chief of a metro police department, whose forensic and surveillance resources are more often spent on pedophiles and drug dealers than terrorism. What else would they say?

If the article's authors wanted a "what about the terrorists?" quote they would have gone to a counter-terrorism official, just like they rang someone at the DEA for a "but drug organizations!" quote.

You're reading a paint-by-numbers article about government impotence and corporate supremacy like it's finely crafted pro-government propaganda.

Let's hope the public will see through their manipulative talking points.

You (and most HN commenters) didn't. Why should they? e.g.:

a) "Beyond lobbying the companies, there is little law enforcement can do without congressional action."

b) "A half-dozen police and federal officials interviewed said that Apple, in particular, was taking an aggressive posture on the issue."

When you take away the outrage-kindling, the gist of the article is that the stodgy old Washington government is incompetent and hip California tech companies are glorious. Not exactly a controversial opinion among the commentariat.

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @04:36PM (#8391006)
> "They" in this case is the chief of a metro police department, whose forensic and surveillance resources are more often spent on pedophiles and drug dealers than terrorism. What else would they say?

You're saying "pedophiles and drug dealers" as if it wasn't 99% drug dealers.

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by gnarbarian on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @04:37PM (#8391010)
If anything I'm more prone to believe this is disinformation meant to allay our fears and draw us into a false sense of security when using our smartphones. xnull's comment nailed it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8390150
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by krapp on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @04:50PM (#8391120)
Is there any evidence that smartphone purchasing or use has dropped significantly as a symptom of widespread fear of government spying and overreach?

From what I can tell, the only thing most Americans are concerned about at the moment is whether the iPhone will bend if you keep it in your pocket for too long. Disinformation is a plausible strategy, but most Americans simply do not, and have never, cared (and a significant portion of those who do, think it's perfectly justifiable and would tell you Edward Snowden needs to swing from a rope, once you reminded them of who he is.) Would it even be necessary?

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by gnarbarian on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @05:07PM (#8391248)
The average consumer isn't who they are trying to convince, it's the security conscious who take measures to protect their privacy. They are the people who need to be tricked into thinking the iphone's passkey is bulletproof.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by sixothree on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:05PM (#8389880)
Hmm sounds to me like they are trying to convince people to use their phones for illegal doings.

Also, all of the comments in this thread (not this one specifically) make me wish HN threads root comments defaulted to collapsed so people might avoid duplicate root comments. Maybe...

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by jcromartie on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @03:21PM (#8390538)
That's an interesting idea. It's not often that people in law enforcement or military intelligence will come out publicly and say "if such-and-such adversary were to use this widely-available technology we'd be stymied!"
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by sixothree on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @04:20PM (#8390905)
Possibly reminiscent of the Freakonomics suggestion for terrorists to buy life insurance from their bank.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by brational on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @01:52PM (#8389760)
I don't understand this argument. Wouldn't law enforcement still be allowed to access phone records unecrypted if they have an actual suspect and court order?
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by gnarbarian on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @01:56PM (#8389800)
Yes but they want the data on the mobile device. For example, I use textsecure when texting my friends. Its encrypted locally and over the wire so the records would only help them show who not what I was talking about.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by williamcotton on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @01:58PM (#8389823)
With end-to-end encryption where the messages are encrypted and decrypted on the client it would not be possible for anyone with access to phone records or central servers to read what was said. They would need to obtain the private keys that are generated on the client devices themselves.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by rsync on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @03:41PM (#8390664)
"With end-to-end encryption where the messages are encrypted and decrypted on the client it would not be possible for anyone with access to phone records or central servers to read what was said. They would need to obtain the private keys that are generated on the client devices themselves."

Would that it were.

You are using the application processor (the "computer") to do that work, but there are two other computers inside your phone - the baseband processor and the SIM card.[1] Your carrier has access (OTA updates, etc.) to the baseband processor and can load new code/functions on it without your knowledge at any time. Depending on the SOC your phone is based on, the baseband processor can have DMA access to your application processor. What that means is, the baseband processor (which you have no control over whatsoever) can read your RAM directly.

Your cryptosystem that you describe probably works quite well on a desktop or laptop computer, but your carrier completely and totally owns your phone and everything on it.

... and we haven't even gotten to what they can do with the SIM card ...

[1] Yes, the SIM card is a computer with its own processor, RAM and programs running on it right this moment.

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @04:44PM (#8391067)
It seems like what we need to do is separate the damn things. Build the phone as two independent machines that only communicate with each other over ethernet. Then the user controls the one that runs Android and the other one never sees plaintext.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by Roboprog on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @01:27AM (#8392968)
Don't expect to see that architecture on the floor of a retailer near you anytime soon. Maybe in the EU??? NOT in the US.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by brational on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:02PM (#8389862)
But they'd still be able to do that given a warrant? Or is this unwarrantable protection, for lack of a better word?
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by chaz72 on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:08PM (#8389909)
Nope. They could use a warrant to compel the sender or the recipient of the messages to unlock them or face jail time. But Apple doesn't have the keys.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by netcraft on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:21PM (#8390023)
wouldn't the 5th amendment protect against that?
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by smtddr on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @03:47PM (#8390707)
I think the most important thing here is that law enforcement must approach the individual. What happens next may end up a complicate web of legal acrobatics, but the individual at least knows the law is after them. That's a good thing, IMHO. If your privacy is being violated by police forcing you to open your phone to them... at least you know the "when", "how" and "what" info they're getting. I'm also pretty sure you'd at least have a strong suspicion on the "why" it's happening to you as well - fair or otherwise.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by CHY872 on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @11:47PM (#8392712)
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by chaz72 on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:32PM (#8390140)
er - possibly, I'm not a lawyer. I read it somewhere on the internet and it sounded credible at the time.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by matwood on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:09PM (#8389917)
Assuming they can get the client device(s) before they are destroyed.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by rscott on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @01:56PM (#8389806)
Probably harder and takes longer than searching through a confiscated phone from a suspect.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by scott_karana on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:28PM (#8390095)
Bingo! You can, as far as I know, confiscate and search a suspect just based on probable cause, whereas you'd need to have at least a subpoena if not a warrant to get wiretap authorization or phone records.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by plorg on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:56PM (#8390350)
A recent Supreme Court ruling[0] makes it unlawful for authorities to search confiscated cell phones without a warrant. They could, theoretically, confiscate your phone based on probable cause, but searching it would be a different matter.

[0] http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/13pdf/13-132_8l9c.pdf

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by scott_karana on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:59PM (#8390381)
Oh, excellent! At least that prevents overt searches.
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by codyb on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @03:36PM (#8390625)
They talk about a balancing act and a criminal underworld free for all but I haven't seen too many complaints from the FBI about the millions of Americans whose constitutional rights are infringed upon every day during the NSA's total government free for all (as well as the wide variety of stories pertaining to other agencies and local law enforcement which are abusing various forms of intelligence gathering).
Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by dragontamer on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @07:24PM (#8392002)
Law Enforcement (aka FBI / DEA) battles pedophiles and drug dealers. These guys typically make the "think of the children" arguments.

Defense (Army / CIA / NSA) battles terrorists.

Keep an eye on the names of the agencies involved. This is an FBI / Law Enforcement story, so the excuses are going to be different than the NSA-case a few months ago.

Re:U.S. Law Enforcement Seeks to Halt Apple-Google Encryptio... by droopybuns on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @08:49AM (#8394004)
Remember how iOS 6 stopped all child pornography? What a great operating system.