Re:Postgres full text search is good enough
by orbifold on Monday September 29, 2014 @07:24AM
(#8382401)
I think that is not so much because of the fact that people do not want to use search, just that by experience they've learned that it is usually next to useless on most sites. At least that is my experience.
Re:Postgres full text search is good enough
by aw3c2 on Monday September 29, 2014 @05:11AM
(#8382148)
As a user I never trust myself to know the "right" search terms nor the search box to show the "right" results. If I browse, I know that I see all the items and I can filter with exact, pre-defined (trusted) attributes.
Re:Postgres full text search is good enough
by wuliwong on Monday September 29, 2014 @11:32AM
(#8383348)
I'm making the same observation on my site. I thought search would be the clear way to get to where you want to go but it is relatively unused. I have a site which lists tutorials for a specific language. You would think people would be looking for something specific, but it seems 90% click whatever is displayed first and other just surf around using the basic filters and pagination.
Re:Postgres full text search is good enough
by narag on Monday September 29, 2014 @10:20AM
(#8382917)
I think orbifol is right: we've learned that site searches are mostly useless.
But also: when navigating to a page, people are usually using the mouse. Switching between mouse and keyboard is somehow costly. While there are options (choosing from a combo box), users will use it and only switch to keyboard if there's no other way.
We started to notice that customers will use the menu and filtering options, rather than searching for an item. Need something from the "electronics" category, click the electronics menu tab, and pick the subcategory. From there customers browse or filter until they find what they're looking for.
Of cause so do use the search, and most people would have better results if they did search directly.
My point is: Maybe we could have just used Postgresqls full text search in this case. The queries will be rather simply anyway. The new syntax won't matter much, you need to learn something new anyway if you use Solr or ElasticSearch. Search is fare less important than people think, it just needs to be there and be "good enough".
Yes, Sphinx is awesome, if you're doing plain searches, filtering can get complicated pretty quickly.