Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r...
by lmm on Thursday September 25, 2014 @07:23AM
(#8366580)
Land can't really be private property in the usual sense. You can't take it with you, and using it is pretty much always going to impact other people (in a way that really isn't true of normal property). We already have the notion that land "ownership" is different from ordinary ownership (e.g. compulsory purchase laws).
The argument for private ownership of land is usually that it makes it possible for people to invest in long-term improvements to the land, e.g. building houses there, or irrigating it for agriculture. But that doesn't really apply to beaches; most of us think that beaches provide more value to society when they're public than if you built houses or grew crops there.
So yes, beaches are special - they're unusually valuable as public property, relative to their value as private property.
The argument for private ownership of land is usually that it makes it possible for people to invest in long-term improvements to the land, e.g. building houses there, or irrigating it for agriculture. But that doesn't really apply to beaches; most of us think that beaches provide more value to society when they're public than if you built houses or grew crops there.
So yes, beaches are special - they're unusually valuable as public property, relative to their value as private property.