News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r... by eurleif on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @11:40PM (#8365475)
>The concept of a "private beach" would be strikingly alien and unnatural in any ethical universe.

What's so special about beaches? Or do you want to do away with all forms of private property?

Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r... by vidarh on Thursday September 25, 2014 @12:25AM (#8365615)
Land is a limited resource in general, but special land features are both more desirable and important to people than others, and more scarce, and have a long history of special treatment, and so we tend to place special emphasis on securing access to certain types of land.

There's also no need to do away with private property to guarantee access. Consider the principle of Freedom to Roam [1], which is today most protected in Scandinavia, but used to be more widely recognized (and have in fact in recent years gotten more recognition, with the expansion of legal rights in the UK)

Basically, when I grew up in Norway, everyone expected that we were free to walk in any forest, access any beach, and in general have unfettered access to nature, irrespective of property rights to those areas. This includes protections to prevent property owners from blocking access. Trying to limit such access is pretty much seen as morally similar to theft.

The modern justification is that any restriction of access is a substantial limitation of the freedom of the public, and that if you wish to maximize freedom, you must limit the ability of property owners and find a balance that protects their ability to secure their home and business and protect their privacy but without taking away public freedoms that predates even our written laws. (In Sweden, this right is even part of the constitution)

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_to_roam

Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r... by benjohnson on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @11:46PM (#8365492)
Public access to beaches and waterways is an ancient idea - Institutes of (Emperor) Justinian in the 6th century are often cited:

By the law of nature these things are common to mankind, the air, running water, the sea, and consequently the shores of the sea. No one, therefore, is forbidden to approach the seashore, provided that he respects habitationes, monuments, and buildings which are not, like the sea, subject only to the law of nations.

2. All rivers and ports are public; hence the right of fishing in a port, or in rivers, is common to all men.

3. The seashore extends as far as the greatest winter flood runs up.

Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r... by yummyfajitas on Thursday September 25, 2014 @12:02AM (#8365554)
Also, we should strip citizenship from anyone who is not a Christian, and punish participation in pagan rituals as severely as murder. This is an ancient idea - Institutes of (Emperor) Justinian in the 6th century are often cited.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corpus_Juris_Civilis

If you want to appeal to authority rather than answer the question, pretty much any Roman emperor makes an odd choice.

Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r... by KC8ZKF on Thursday September 25, 2014 @12:26AM (#8365620)
It's not an appeal to authority. "Because Justinian said so, and he's emperor so he should know." is an appeal to an authority.

But here, Justinian's argument is given. Seas and rivers are part of the commonwealth, so nobody should be denied access.

Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r... by yummyfajitas on Thursday September 25, 2014 @12:39AM (#8365654)
What is Justinian's argument? He doesn't actually mention the "commonwealth" at all. He merely appeals to the "law of nature".

In any case, if there is some principle underlying Justinian's edict, what is it? How did he determine that the sea is part of the "commonwealth", but that a mountain or someone's house is not? This is hardly explained in the given quote.

Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r... by KC8ZKF on Thursday September 25, 2014 @01:15AM (#8365753)
This doesn't really answer your question, but I think it's interesting to note that Institutes of Justinian are doing two things here. First, they are announcing to the Romans that the seas and running waters are part of the commonwealth. Second they are making the seas and running waters part of the commonwealth. They are simultaneously making a declaration and changing the world to fit that declaration.

In short, seas were part of the commonwealth because Justinian said so. An <ahem> appeal to authority. But an appeal that Justinian made, not benjohnson.

Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r... by vidarh on Thursday September 25, 2014 @12:29AM (#8365624)
He did answer the question: This has a very long historical precedent.

That we continue to accept some historical precedents as good, but have discarded others is not at all odd, and does not invalidate the historical importance placed on access to waterways just because the same people also had lots of ideas we consider idiotic today.

Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r... by yummyfajitas on Thursday September 25, 2014 @12:43AM (#8365662)
If "a very long historical precedent" were sufficient to justify a policy, it would also justify the policies you wish to discard.
Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r... by vidarh on Friday September 26, 2014 @04:21AM (#8371831)
I have not suggested they were sufficient to justify a policy, nor does the reference to Justinian appear to have done so.

A long historical precedent is however sufficient to explain it's modern day existence, which is what happened here.

You appear to have an uncanny ability to read far more into messages than what were intended.

Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r... by jrapdx3 on Thursday September 25, 2014 @12:16AM (#8365594)
Let's put it this way, the question could be turned around, would you have no public property? Would it be satisfactory to have no public parks, monuments, museums, even streets, or other amenities?

Of course not. Cities, states, regions need to preserve public spaces for the public good. The beach is a rare and precious natural asset that can't be duplicated, so logically ought to be open to the public.

Once you've seen the Pacific Ocean from most anywhere in the Upper Left Coast you'll know it's beautiful and inspiring. Furthermore, it's an important recreational resource and since ancient times a source of food for many people and remains so to this day.

Despite having many differing political points of view in our state, AFAIK no one has ever suggested closing off beach access to the public. If such ideas were broached at the state level, I expect it would set off quite a loud and negative reaction.

Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r... by nouveaux on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @11:50PM (#8365511)
Beaches should be viewed like a national park, and it should be a right granted to man. It should be granted as a right because it allows man to connect to nature, and can be seen as a benefit to society.
Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r... by lmm on Thursday September 25, 2014 @07:23AM (#8366580)
Land can't really be private property in the usual sense. You can't take it with you, and using it is pretty much always going to impact other people (in a way that really isn't true of normal property). We already have the notion that land "ownership" is different from ordinary ownership (e.g. compulsory purchase laws).

The argument for private ownership of land is usually that it makes it possible for people to invest in long-term improvements to the land, e.g. building houses there, or irrigating it for agriculture. But that doesn't really apply to beaches; most of us think that beaches provide more value to society when they're public than if you built houses or grew crops there.

So yes, beaches are special - they're unusually valuable as public property, relative to their value as private property.

Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r... by tim333 on Thursday September 25, 2014 @06:39AM (#8366478)
>What's so special about beaches?

For one thing they usually abut the sea which is generally public access. In the UK we have no private beaches. Seems to work fine. You don't get many protesters saying won't you please think of the billionaires.