News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The SSD Endurance Experiment: Only Two Remain After 1.5PB by Retric on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @06:16PM (#8358683)
I normally find it annoying when they run endurance tests like this using only one drive of each brand and treat the results as particularly meaningful. However, in this case I think the failures may suggest things about the drives underlying architecture not just who picked the best sample from the bin.
Re:The SSD Endurance Experiment: Only Two Remain After 1.5PB by rodgerd on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @06:41PM (#8358796)
> I normally find it annoying when they run endurance tests like this using only one drive of each brand and treat the results as particularly meaningful.

The main takeaway for me from this is less around the reliability of individual drives, but that SSDs as a whole have moved into a space where I don't really need to worry about them being signifiantly less reliable than hard drives.

Re:The SSD Endurance Experiment: Only Two Remain After 1.5PB by redangstrom on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @07:19PM (#8358935)
While the conclusion is true and has been for some time, the supporting data is insufficient.

For example, the author doesn't even bother to gloss over key reliability parameters such as data retention, which is primarily impacted by cycling.

(By data retention, I mean the ability of drive to retain written data over a period of time, such as 6 months, since written. This is usually accelerated in testing by a bake cycle.)

That said, it's a fun read and I'm glad there's more exposure on this topic.

Re:The SSD Endurance Experiment: Only Two Remain After 1.5PB by jychang on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @08:22PM (#8359208)
Well, they could still improve.

My Macbook's SSD died in a blaze of reallocated sectors and write failures just last week, and that thing was just around 2 years old.

For comparison, I've only had 2 spinning hard drives fail on me (I've owned around 25), and those were >10 years old and mostly decommissioned.

It could be a statistical fluke, and the sheer speed of SSDs means that even now, a higher failure rate is acceptable, but SSDs in general don't have the longevity of older magnetic hard drives.

Re:The SSD Endurance Experiment: Only Two Remain After 1.5PB by jahewson on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @01:51AM (#8360096)
My Macbook's SSD lasted just six months before it failed, right before printing a boarding pass for a transatlantic flight. Afterwards it turned out Time Machine had been making corrupted backups, which wasn't fun, fortunately no user data loss, only Applications. I've learnt my lesions about SSDs: they don't give you any hints that they're about to fail, and one they do, it's game over.
Re:The SSD Endurance Experiment: Only Two Remain After 1.5PB by fulafel on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @06:51AM (#8360757)
> SSDs as a whole have moved into a space where I don't really need to worry about them being signifiantly less reliable than hard drives

The majority of SSD reliability problems never had anything do with flash endurance. You can tell this from the failure mode too: all the data disappears. Instead, they are caused by firmware and design bugs that cause occasional corruption of the FTL internals.

Regular benchmark-style IO patterns aren't a good way to tickle these bugs so the endurance test doesn't really say anything about this main problem.

Re:The SSD Endurance Experiment: Only Two Remain After 1.5PB by VLM on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @09:13AM (#8361212)
Could someone with experience on the technical side of the industry (not marketing or astroturf) tell us if "one drive of each brand" applied to a dozen pieces of hardware is a dozen different brand stickers attached to the eventual output of the same NAND chip foundry, or is it realistic that its really a dozen foundaries? Fundamentally rewrite testing does not test the physical parameters of a brand name sticker, it tests the physical parameters of one kind of IC cell. I would not be entirely surprised to hear there are very few foundries making this exact type of IC but I can't estimate how much larger or smaller than number is relative to the much more well known number of brand name stickers.

As a message to the marketing people I excluded in the above paragraph, I would be willing to pay a modest amount extra money to have the honest foundry name on the marketing material for a drive, and lets be honest I'm only going to buy multiple quantities of your product if I can order from separate foundries so please don't lie and also please give each foundry a different UPC code or something. Somehow I get the feeling this will end up like power supplies where "everyone knows" there is one model of supply and stacks of different wattage stickers applied to the same device to maximize revenue. The market is too corrupt and unequally informed for this to happen. Still, a guy can dream.

Re:The SSD Endurance Experiment: Only Two Remain After 1.5PB by Mithaldu on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @06:28PM (#8358747)
Given that return rates for these drives can go up to 2.5% even under normal usage conditions (though granted, that was OCZ), it's really quite meaningless to do this kind of test without having a whole batch of drives for each type.
Re:The SSD Endurance Experiment: Only Two Remain After 1.5PB by simoncion on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @09:06PM (#8359374)
Two words: IBM Deathstar.
Re:The SSD Endurance Experiment: Only Two Remain After 1.5PB by pyre on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @11:12PM (#8359714)
What does that have to do with commentary on needing to have larger cross-batch samples?
Re:The SSD Endurance Experiment: Only Two Remain After 1.5PB by vidarh on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @04:42AM (#8360424)
When bringing up OCZ' notorious high return rate, and using that to indicate a high failure rate for SSD's, bringing up the IBM DeathStar is a very relevant counterpoint.

Larger cross-batch samples is absolutely a good idea, but the dig at SSD's applies just as much to regular harddrives.

[For those who don't know, DeathStar was a nickname given to the IBM DeskStar line of harddrives after one of the models had a problem that gave them high odds of catastrophic head crashes - so bad in fact that they'd strip most of the magnetic material off the glass platters when they crashed[1] -; out of 10 IBM DeskStar drives we had at the time, all 10 failed within a week or two of each other, under a year after we bought them. The problem was is often considered to be one of the main reasons why IBM unloaded their hard drive business to Hitachi]

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HGST_Deskstar#mediaviewer/File:...

Re:The SSD Endurance Experiment: Only Two Remain After 1.5PB by michaelt on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @08:39AM (#8361095)

  The problem was is often considered to be one of the main 
  reasons why IBM unloaded their hard drive business to 
  Hitachi
Who, in a compete reversal of fortunes, now produce some of the most reliable drives [1].

[1] https://www.backblaze.com/blog/hard-drive-reliability-update...

Re:The SSD Endurance Experiment: Only Two Remain After 1.5PB by pyre on Friday September 26, 2014 @03:23PM (#8374393)
You're missing the fact that (IIRC) prior to that DeskStar were considered some of the best drives on the market.