News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by falsestprophet on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @04:47PM (#8358112)
This democratizes the stock market like online casinos democratize gambling. Fees are the least of the layperson's problems in the stock market or a casino.
Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by webwright on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:45PM (#8358504)
This isn't a good comparison. Casinos are incentivized to have you fail/lose (but enjoy the process).

Pay-per-trade brokers are incentivized to have you trade frequently and/or buy certain securities. RobinHood doesn't actually profit from each trade, so it could be argued that they have are likelier to care about the retail investor's long-term success (providing automated tools for monthly investments in low-fee funds, etc).

Regardless, let's give some love to the fact that people are accountable for their actions and the vast amount non-bad information on the internet. A beginning retail investor is one search away from a strategy that is a metric ton better than not investing at all (which is what most of them do): https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&rlz=1C5...

If RobinHood causes some people to piss away their savings on crazy-risky investments, it's not because those people didn't have access to decent investment advice.

Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by kasey_junk on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:57PM (#8358585)
Robinhood definitely does profit from each trade. They are paid by third parties to route the trades through them.

[edit] link to comment below as requested https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8358217

Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by webwright on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @06:24PM (#8358729)
Do you have a link for that? From their FAQ, here's their (admittedly not super clear) answer to "How does Robin Hood Make Money?":

Robinhood will offer margin trading as well as API access, which will allow partnered developers to build applications in conjunction with Robinhood. Robinhood will also receive remuneration for providing trade volume in certain markets. In the future, we plan to offer premium services for active investors.

"Robinhood will offer margin trading as well as API access, which will allow partnered developers to build applications in conjunction with Robinhood. Robinhood will also receive remuneration for providing trade volume in certain markets. In the future, we plan to offer premium services for active investors.

Robinhood is venture-funded by Google, Andreessen Horowitz and many others, which affords us the freedom to focus on building a wonderful brokerage experience rather than short-term profits.

Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by slykat on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @02:58PM (#8363410)
See the comment by chollida1 in another part of the thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8358217

"They get paid to sell your orders to Knight Capital, Lava and Credit Suisse.."

Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by avmich on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @06:09PM (#8358650)
How do those third parties profit then?
Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by kasey_junk on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @06:15PM (#8358673)
I've never worked on an order flow based trade but the ways that seem most obvious to me are: 1) decreased fees with the exchanges due to higher rebate levels. 2) updated knowledge of the depth and nature of price levels making pricing algorithms more intelligent. 3) capturing the spreads on market orders.
Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by rwissmann on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:35PM (#8358441)
Precisely. As a small, personal investor the last thing you is to make frequent trades thinking that you can beat the market- unless it is your toy money.

Wealthfront and others are making the stock market better for individual investors, retirement savers, and so on. This to the contrary appears like stressing the gambling aspect of it.

I would love to be wrong, but it is hard to see how this will make markets better and not lose people a lot of money. (Provided they don't 'pivot' in the future.)

Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by webwright on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:49PM (#8358540)
Frequent low dollar trades != risky day trading of penny stocks. It very well could mean an automated $50/week in low-fee mutual funds. Or talking half of your lawn mowing money and putting it into a college account and investing intelligently with it.

The last thing these guys want is tons of articles saying, "I lost my life savings on Robinhood". Why wouldn't they do their best to give their customers access to smart context-specific investment advice?

Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by seanflyon on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:35PM (#8358440)
The reason the stock market is generally referred to as "investing" instead of "gambling" is because the expected return is positive instead of negative. While I would not recommend randomly investing, it's not such a terrible thing.
Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by alex_duf on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:46PM (#8358514)
That's making the assumption that economy can grow indefinitely. I wouldn't be surprise if we hit the roof soon.
Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by seanflyon on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @06:50PM (#8358825)
I wouldn't rule out the possibility of the market crashing. I would rule out the possibility of us being near any kind of fundamental maximum amount of value in the economy.
Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by apostate on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:07PM (#8358260)
Are you suggesting that it is a bad idea for laypeople to participate equity markets?
Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by timtamboy63 on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:11PM (#8358287)
It's bad because the majority of people who invest their own money invest without enough information about the company. Finance is almost deliberately obfuscated to keep retail investors out, and unless you have the time and the knowledge, it's going to be difficult to make decent returns unless you're investing in mutual funds, ETF's, etc.

Disclaimer - founder of http://capp.io and this is basically what we found in our market research.

Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by Lost_BiomedE on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:37PM (#8358448)
Depends on the size of the company, IME. Small to mid-caps can be very transparent. To add extra protection, buy at the lower end of the market cycle or when the sector of the stock is out of favor.
Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by Guvante on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:28PM (#8358400)
> Finance is almost deliberately obfuscated to keep retail investors out

Is it retail investors they are worried about, or is it expecting that the market won't undo any trickery?

Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by timtamboy63 on Wednesday September 24, 2014 @01:09AM (#8360015)
No idea. I think investing is advanced enough that you typically need somewhat complex jargon and data to actually make money - over time it's basically become an old boys club and no-one's really trying to make it accessible to regular investor.
Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by apostate on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:32PM (#8358424)
Your use of disclaimers shows that you are well versed in compliance matters when it comes to dispensing investment advice ;)
Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by drcode on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:12PM (#8358294)
I'm sure falseprophet's response would be something along the lines of "index funds bla bla bla professional investors bla bla bla efficient market hypothesis bla bla bla" which isn't necessarily wrong (I agree with this line of thinking myself, mostly) The problem is when people complain about new opportunities for average folk and use an argument that amounts to "we need to protect dumb people from themselves" which is too simplistic an answer for complicated problems, in my view.

Often, people end up being smarter than you think, when given the opportunity (not that I'm endorsing Robinhood... I'd be very cautious about using them, based on first impressions)

Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:38PM (#8358459)
If we stopped protecting dumb banks from themselves and everyone else, we wouldn't need to worry so much about protecting dumb people from themselves.

As for efficient markets - I'm still trying to understand how social institutions that melt down every decade or so and are a consistent focus of criminal proceedings can be considered 'efficient.'

Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by apostate on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:19PM (#8358339)
We are probably in the same camp; I just wasn't sure if GP was comparing casinos with 'stock trading' or the equity asset class in general, which, if one subscribes to the 'boring' methods of index fund investing, are hard to beat over a 5+ year time window.

I would hope ETFs are available on this platform, since they trade like stocks.

Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by ryandrake on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @06:15PM (#8358678)
He's probably suggesting that it's risky, because it is. Laypeople should know what they're getting into. I've had the opportunity to invest a sizable chunk of change into the US equity market twice in my life: once in 1999, and again in 2006. I lost my shirt both times. The stock market is not for everyone. It is not always a magical money-increasing machine, although it might "statistically" and "historically" produce positive returns over a long enough term.
Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by jordan0day on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:16PM (#8358316)
That's a bit of a loaded question.

If "laypeople" just means "not financial industry insiders", then no, it's not necessarily bad.

If "laypeople" means "people who haven't bothered to spend any time at all learning how the market works (or at least, how it's supposed to work)", then yes, it's a very bad idea. For those people, the market may end up being functionally equivalent to a casino, but without the free drinks.

Re:Robinhood Raises $13M to Democratize Stock Market with Ze... by apostate on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:26PM (#8358380)
I think if an ignorant person wishes to trade stocks, the lack of a platform like this won't stop them. Retail brokers like Etrade and Scottrade got the pennystock crowds long ago.

Mentioned in another reply, I would hope ETFs are available on a platform like this, since they trade like stocks. Hopefully that would allow more people to put small amounts of savings into index funds. That being said, Robinhood wouldn't be very innovative on that front, since many brokers offer the more popular index-based ETFs without fees anyway.